Liam Neeson plays a bank robber who tries to turn himself in, and Honest Thief is built entirely around that setup. The twist is simple: the FBI agents assigned to take his confession are corrupt, and they try to kill him. Neeson spends most of the film fighting them, hiding out with a psychologist named Annie Wilkins, and trying to prove his innocence to the people chasing him. The problem is that the setup is familiar, the execution is thin, and Neeson’s star power is not enough to carry the weight of a script that doesn’t know what it wants to be.
Trailer, via Rotten Tomatoes Coming Soon.
Tom Dolan’s Past
Tom Dolan is a former US Marine demolitions expert who turned to bank robbery after a personal loss. He stores his stolen money in a rented storage unit, where he meets Annie Wilkins, a psychology graduate student working at the facility. She helps him store the cash and falls for him. A year later, Tom wants a clean slate, so he calls the FBI and offers to surrender himself and the money in exchange for a reduced sentence. That call sets the whole movie in motion.
The FBI’s Betrayal
FBI special agent Sam Baker agrees to meet with Tom the next day. But Baker is busy, so he hands the case to lower-ranking agents John Nivens and Ramon Hall. They visit the storage unit, find the money, and decide to keep it for themselves. They return to the hotel where Tom is staying and try to kill him. Tom fights back, and the two agents flee. Later, Nivens and Hall shoot Baker with a 9mm, then point the gun at Tom, who charges at him. Tom and Nivens fall through the hotel window and land in front of Annie, who is on her way to visit Tom. Tom and Annie drive away while Nivens and Hall keep shooting at them.
The Confession
Tom finally confesses to Annie that he turned to bank robbery as revenge for his father’s CEO’s unfair treatment of him. His father became depressed after the death of someone close to the family, and Tom saw the man as the cause. That backstory explains why Tom wants to leave the criminal life, but the film never digs deeper into it. The revenge angle is there, but it feels like a placeholder rather than a fully realized motivation.
Neeson’s Performance
Neeson carries the film with physicality and menace. He moves fast, fights hard, and never loses his cool even when surrounded by armed men. His scenes with Annie are warmer, but they don’t get much screen time. The supporting cast is thin. Kate Walsh plays Annie with a quiet strength, but she doesn’t get much to do beyond waiting for Tom and driving him away from danger. Jai Courtney and Jeffrey Donovan play the corrupt agents with a sneer, but their characters feel like stock villains rather than people with their own arcs.
The Script’s Weaknesses
The script, written by Mark Williams and Steve Allrich, leans heavily on the good guy vs. corrupt system formula. It’s a formula that works well in better films, but Honest Thief doesn’t add anything new to it. The twists are predictable, the pacing is slow in the middle, and the climax is rushed. There’s a scene where Tom and Annie hide in a car trunk while Nivens and Hall search the building above them. It’s tense, but it’s also a trick the audience has seen a hundred times before.
The film also struggles with tone. It wants to be a thriller, but it keeps dipping into romantic comedy territory whenever Annie appears. That tonal shift doesn’t work. The two modes can coexist in better movies, but Honest Thief can’t hold both at once. The result is a film that feels unfinished, as if the writers ran out of ideas before they finished the story.
Technical Craft
The film was released in theaters, including IMAX, on October 16, 2020, by Open Road Films and Briarcliff Entertainment. The production values are modest. The action scenes are competent but not spectacular. The sound design is loud, and the editing is fast during the chases. None of it elevates the material. The film looks and sounds like a standard Hollywood thriller, but the standard is low.
| Release Detail | Detail |
|---|---|
| Director | Mark Williams |
| Writers | Steve Allrich, Mark Williams |
| Lead Actor | Liam Neeson |
| Release Date | October 16, 2020 |
| Distributor | Open Road Films, Briarcliff Entertainment |
Where It Lands
Honest Thief is a competently made film with a star who knows how to fill the frame. But the script is weak, the villain is a stereotype, and the tone keeps shifting. The film never commits to being a thriller or a romance, and that indecision shows in every scene. Neeson is good, but he’s not great. He’s doing the best he can with a script that doesn’t treat him well.
The film’s tagline, “Never steal a man’s second chance,” promises a moral about redemption. But the movie doesn’t deliver that promise. Instead, it becomes a story about a man who gets betrayed and fights back. That’s a smaller idea, and it’s a weaker one. The film’s failure is not in its ambitions but in its execution. It knows what it wants to say but doesn’t know how to say it.
Final Verdict
Honest Thief is a forgettable entry in Neeson’s long career. It’s not bad enough to avoid entirely, but it’s not good enough to recommend. The film is most watchable when Neeson is fighting or running, and least watchable when the story slows down to explain itself. The film’s critical reception has been mixed, with reviewers praising Neeson’s performance while noting the film’s familiarity. That balance holds up as a fair reading of the picture. The film is worth watching once if you’re a fan of the genre, but it’s not worth seeking out again. Just don’t expect it to stick with you afterward.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
