Aquarius wants to be two shows at once, and it mostly manages neither. The 2015 NBC crime drama sets itself in 1967 Los Angeles, following LAPD detective Sam Hodiak as he tracks a small-time criminal named Charles Manson, who is gathering a following around him. The series blends real history with invented fiction, and the result is a show that feels both promising and uneven, a period piece that stumbles through its own ambitions.
Trailer, via La Guía del Ocio.
Sam Hodiak and the Case That Opens It
David Duchovny plays Sam Hodiak, a veteran detective whose personal life is complicated in the way television likes to complicate its heroes. He investigates the disappearance of Emma Karn, a teenage girl, with the help of Brian Shafe, played by Grey Damon, an undercover officer who works alongside him. The case leads Hodiak to Charles Manson and his followers, a group of people under Manson’s control.
The first season centers on Manson’s growing influence. The second season shifts toward the Tate murders and Manson’s belief in an impending race war, which he calls “helter skelter.” The show wants to be a portrait of a city in transition, caught between the counterculture movement and the violence that would define the decade. It also wants to be a procedural about a man who becomes a cult leader, and it struggles to balance those two goals.
Manson’s Portrayal and the Fiction Around Him
Gethin Anthony plays Charles Manson, and the series treats him as a charismatic figure who draws followers in part because of his ability to speak to vulnerable women. The show is careful to frame Manson as a small-time criminal whose ideas grow larger, but the writing sometimes leans on stereotypes about cult leaders rather than building a fully realized character.
The series also includes several other notable actors. Emma Dumont plays Emma Karn, the teenager at the center of the investigation. Claire Holt plays Charmain Tully, and Michaela McManus plays Grace Karn. Brían F. O’Byrne plays Ken Karn, and Milauna Jackson plays Kristin Shafe. Ambyr Childers plays Sadie, and Chance Kelly plays Detective Ed Cutler. Madisen Beaty plays Patricia Krenwinkel, and Cameron Deane Stewart plays Tex Watson.
The cast is full of recognizable names, and the show uses them well in smaller roles. The ensemble gives the series a sense of scope, even when the writing fails to justify it.
What Works and What Doesn’t
The show’s strengths are its period detail and its performances. Duchovny gives a grounded, weary performance as Hodiak, a man who understands that the world around him is changing faster than he can keep up. The production design captures the look of Los Angeles in 1967, with its sunlit streets and its shifting social landscape.
Where the show falters is in its pacing and its handling of the Manson figure. The first season drags in stretches, spending too much time on the slow build of Manson’s influence before reaching the events that would define him. The second season rushes through the Tate murders and the helter skelter theory, compressing years of history into a handful of episodes. This compression leaves some viewers feeling that the show skipped over the very events it promised to explore.
Ratings Struggles and the NBC Decision
Aquarius received positive reviews from television critics, with praise for its period detail, storytelling, and Duchovny’s performance. It was among the eight series to receive the Critics’ Choice Television Award for Most Exciting New Series in 2015. Despite that recognition, the show struggled with ratings. NBC cancelled Aquarius on October 1, 2016, after two seasons and 26 episodes.
The cancellation came after two seasons, a modest run for a network drama. The show had a dedicated audience but could not sustain the numbers that NBC demanded. The critical praise did not translate into commercial success, and the network made the call to move on.
The Tate Murders and Helter Skelter
The second season of Aquarius focuses on the Tate murders and Manson’s belief in an impending race war, which he calls “helter skelter.” The show depicts the killings as the culmination of Manson’s ideology, a moment where his rhetoric about a coming apocalypse becomes real violence. The episodes dramatize the events with a mix of documentary-style reconstruction and fictionalized scenes, drawing on historical accounts of the murders.
The show’s treatment of helter skelter is central to its narrative arc. It presents the idea as Manson’s answer to the social upheaval of the time, a vision of racial conflict that he believed was inevitable. The series does not fully explain why Manson held this belief, and the show’s compressed timeline means that the transition from talk to action happens quickly.
Comparing the Two Seasons
| Season | Focus | Pace |
|---|---|---|
| Season 1 | Manson’s growing influence | Slow build |
| Season 2 | Tate murders and helter skelter | Rushed compression |
The table shows the tension at the heart of the show. The first season spends too long establishing its premise, while the second season tries to cover too much ground too quickly. Neither approach serves the story well, and the show suffers for it.
A Promising Premise, Underused
Aquarius had a strong premise: a detective in 1967 Los Angeles tracking a man who would become one of the most notorious figures of the decade. The show’s blend of historical fact and fictional characters allowed it to explore the cultural shift of the era without being tied to a single true story. It could have been a sharp, character-driven drama about a man out of time.
Instead, it became a show that struggled with its own ambitions. The first season drags, and the second season rushes. The pacing issues are real, and they undercut the potential of the premise. The show is watchable, but it is rarely compelling.
The Verdict on Aquarius
Aquarius is a show with a good idea and a weak execution. Its period detail is strong, its cast is capable, and its lead performance is solid. But the pacing problems are persistent, and the show’s handling of its central figure is uneven. It is a show worth watching for its craft, but not one that rewards repeated viewings.
Key Facts
- Premiere: May 28, 2015
- Finale: September 10, 2016
- Network: NBC
- Seasons: 2
- Episodes: 26
- Critical award: Critics’ Choice Television Award for Most Exciting New Series in 2015
- Cancelled: October 1, 2016
- Creator: John McNamara
The show is a reminder that television criticism is not just about talent. It is about execution, and Aquarius executed its premise with a mixed hand. The show deserves credit for attempting something ambitious, but it falls short of delivering on that ambition. It is a watchable show, but it is not a great one.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
