Return to PopoloCrois: A Story of Seasons Fairytale wants to be two games at once, and it mostly gets away with it. Marvelous Entertainment built a crossover between the PoPoLoCrois fairy tale RPG and the Story of Seasons farm sim, then handed it to XSEED Games to publish on the Nintendo 3DS in 2015. The result is a turn-based RPG with a working farm attached, and the tension between those halves is the whole story.
Trailer, via Marvelous Europe.
Prince Pietro’s 13th Birthday
The setup is a birthday party that turns into an exile. Pietro, the prince of PopoloCrois, turns 13, and the kingdom throws him a celebration. Among the guests is Marmela, a representative from a kingdom called Galariland.
Her country is being ruined. Shadowy creatures corrupt the soil, and crops will not grow. The same thing is happening in PopoloCrois, so the king asks Marmela what to do. Her answer: send Pietro to Galariland as an ambassador, so he can see the damage himself and learn how the Galari fight back.
He goes. Then he cannot get home. And his title means nothing to the people he meets there.
That is a sharp turn for a game with a birthday cake in the opening scene, and it gives the farming a reason to exist. Pietro is not tending crops because a menu told him to. He is tending crops because he is stuck in a strange country and has to live somewhere.
It is up to you, as Prince Pietro, to make a life for yourself in Galariland while seeking a way home, doing everything you can in the meantime to cultivate the earth and new friendships alike.
Crop-Raising and Rock Quarrying
The farm side is generous. You raise crops, catch bugs, quarry rock and synthesize items. The game lists these as its life simulation elements, and they carry real weight next to the combat.
The RPG side is classical. Combat is turn-based, and the game is played from a bird’s-eye or isometric perspective. Towns are full of NPCs who talk, and the narrative leans on them. The source pitches that story as one veterans or newcomers to either franchise can enjoy, which is a modest claim rather than a boast.
The mode is single player.
A Working Farm Attached
The farm does not wait for the plot, which is the point of the crossover. The activities the game puts on the table break down like this:
| Element | What it covers |
|---|---|
| Farming | Crop-raising |
| Life simulation | Bug-catching, rock quarrying |
| Crafting | Item synthesis |
| Combat | Turn-based battles |
| Narrative | Towns full of NPCs |
That spread is where Return to PopoloCrois either clicks or does not. If you want a story that moves when you want it to move, the chores will feel like a toll. If you want a world that rewards showing up, the chores are the world.
What Actually Works
The best thing here is the premise doing double duty. The corrupted soil in Galariland is not a backdrop. It is the reason the farming mechanics exist, the reason Pietro is far from home, and the reason the story has somewhere to go. Few crossovers bother to weld their two halves together this tightly.
The weaker half is the combat. Turn-based battles in a game this gentle are serviceable, but they are not the draw, and they never become the draw. The towns and the NPCs carry more weight than the fighting does, which is an odd thing to say about an RPG and an honest thing to say about this one.
The 3DS library is deep in both genres. A crossover has to justify itself against the pure versions of each, and Return to PopoloCrois does that with charm and structure rather than with depth. It is a game you play for the texture of Galariland, not for the difficulty curve.
The published critical aggregate sits at 6.9 out of 10 across seven outlets. That number is fair. This is a good game with a great idea, held back by combat that never rises to the level of its premise, and it is worth playing anyway if the premise is the part that appeals to you.
What the score does not capture is how rare the welding job is. Plenty of RPGs bolt on a farm. This one makes the farm the plot. That is the part worth keeping.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
