Bates Motel, the A&E series that ran from 2013 to 2017, took a famous horror icon and made him young without losing what made him scary. The show followed Norman Bates and his mother Norma as they ran a motel in the Pacific Northwest, with Vera Farmiga playing Norma and Freddie Highmore as Norman. Carlton Cuse, who co-created Lost, served as showrunner and directed episodes.
What made Bates Motel work where most prequels stumble is simple: it refused to play by the rules. Rather than trying to match the continuity of the 1960 film, the show reimagined Norman’s youth entirely, setting it in contemporary times. That means Norman had smartphones and online booking. The show wasn’t pretending to be a period piece; it was telling a new story about the same characters.
The Freedom of Not Being Period-Accurate
Most prequels struggle with continuity. Shows like House of the Dragon and NCIS spend enormous effort making sure their stories line up with the originals. They bend over backwards to explain why events happen the way they do. Bates Motel didn’t bother. The show invents its own lore, creating a universe where Norman’s troubled adolescence unfolds in a modern setting.
This freedom is what makes the show brilliant. It adds heavy winks at the audience while staying different enough to create legitimate plot twists that are hard to forget. Instead of catching the series making a canonical mistake, viewers are just excited to see what happens next. The show is liberated by continuity rather than constrained by it.
What Bates Motel Got Right
The show doesn’t just hint at the incestuous relationship between Norma and her son. It shouts it from the rooftops. The place on A&E gave the series immense leeway to get away with such disturbing plot points, and it never let audiences down. That boldness is part of what makes the show stand apart from Hitchcock’s masterpiece.
“Bates Motel stands on its own as a valid crime story that requires no prior knowledge to impress audiences.”
The crime series delivers an ending that is heart-wrenching as well as inevitable. It catches up to the timeline of Psycho and still doesn’t feel ruled by it. It goes off the beaten path to deliver a finale that feels earned rather than forced.
Comparing Bates Motel to Other Prequels
| Series | Approach | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Bates Motel | Reimagined Norman’s youth in modern times | Liberated by continuity, bold plot twists |
| House of the Dragon | Based on George R.R. Martin’s books | Held to an impossible standard, measured against Game of Thrones |
| NCIS | Continues established characters and cases | Bends over backwards to preserve continuity |
Bates Motel’s approach is the opposite of the other two. It doesn’t try to measure up to a predecessor. It just tells its own story, and the result is a show that stands on its own.
Why Bates Motel Wouldn’t Come About Today
The show was a product of network television, not streaming. That context mattered. A&E had the freedom to let the show be disturbing without watering it down. The show was one in a million, and it certainly wouldn’t come about in the time of streaming.
Bates Motel caught up to the timeline of Psycho and still didn’t feel ruled by it. It went off the beaten path to deliver an ending that was heart-wrenching as well as inevitable. The show was a rare success in the common trend of prequel series that try to capitalize on original IP.
The Legacy of Carlton Cuse
Carlton Cuse’s role as showrunner and director was central to the show’s success. The show’s willingness to bend continuity is a credit to his leadership.
The show’s success also speaks to the power of a strong premise. Norman Bates is a character audiences already know, but seeing him as a teenager facing love, loss, and a mother who may be just as disturbed as he is is fresh territory. The show doesn’t rely on name recognition alone. It earns its place by telling a compelling story.
Bates Motel is a rare example of a prequel that works. It bends continuity rather than worrying about it. The show stands on its own as a valid crime story that requires no prior knowledge to impress audiences. That’s a tall order for any prequel, and Bates Motel pulls it off.
The show’s success is notable. It proved that a prequel can be more than a cash grab. It can be a bold, inventive story that honors its source material while carving out its own identity.
See the video the story is built around at Collider.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.