“Bonanza” ran on NBC from September 12, 1959, to January 16, 1973. That is 14 seasons and 431 episodes. No other Western on the network lasted longer. Only “Gunsmoke” on CBS ran longer among Westerns on American network television. A series does not reach that mark on premise alone.
The Ponderosa and the Comstock Lode
The title is a mining word. “Bonanza” comes from the Spanish for a rich ore body, and it refers to the 1859 discovery of the Comstock Lode, the silver mines under Virginia City, Nevada. The Cartwrights live near there, on a ranch called the Ponderosa, on the eastern shore of Lake Tahoe, opposite California, at the edge of the Sierra Nevada.
The ranch name comes from the ponderosa pine. The vast size of the Cartwrights’ land was quietly revised to “half a million acres” in Lorne Greene’s 1964 song, “Saga of the Ponderosa.” That is the kind of detail the series traded in: vast land, a family, and a town close enough to ride into when the week’s trouble arrived.
Virginia City is where the Cartwrights talk to Sheriff Roy Coffee, played by Ray Teal, or his deputy Clem Foster, played by Bing Russell. The show is set in the 1860s.
Ben Cartwright and Three Sons
Ben Cartwright is the thrice-widowed patriarch, played by Lorne Greene. He has three sons, each by a different wife. Adam, the eldest, is an urbane architect, played by Pernell Roberts, and he built the ranch house. Eric, called Hoss, is the warm and lovable giant, played by Dan Blocker. Joseph, called Little Joe, is hotheaded and impetuous, played by Michael Landon.
Each wife had a different ancestry: English, Swedish, and French Creole. The family’s cook is Hop Sing, a Chinese immigrant played by Victor Sen Yung.
That is the whole engine of the series, and it is a strange one for 1959. A Western whose core is not the range but a father and three dissimilar sons, how they care for one another, their neighbors and just causes.
“You always saw stories about family on comedies or on an anthology, but Bonanza was the first series that was week-to-week about a family and the troubles it went through,” the source material notes. That claim is the show’s real legacy, and it holds up better than most of the episodes do.
A Western That Argued With Its Own Time
“Bonanza” was atypical for its era. The storylines dealt less with cattle and land than with moral dilemmas, and the show is known for presenting pressing moral dilemmas. It was a period drama that attempted to confront contemporary social issues.
That is a harder trick than it sounds. A Western set in the 1860s that wants to talk about the 1960s has to smuggle its argument past the horses. “Bonanza” did it week after week, and when it worked, the show was better than its reputation suggests.
When it did not work, the moral arrived like a fence post.
Candy, Griff, and Jamie
The cast did not stay fixed. The series initially starred Greene, Roberts, Blocker and Landon. Later it featured, at various times, Guy Williams, David Canary, Mitch Vogel and Tim Matheson.
David Canary played Candy Canaday. Mitch Vogel played Jamie Hunter Cartwright. Tim Matheson played Griff King. The billing order at the start of each broadcast appeared to be shuffled at random each week, with no relation to the episode that followed. That is a small, odd choice, and it says something about how the show thought of itself: an ensemble, not a star vehicle, even when one star was clearly carrying it.
The Theme Song and the Rankings
The theme song, also titled “Bonanza,” became a hit. Only instrumental renditions were used during the series’s long run, without Ray Evans’s lyrics. That decision aged well. The melody is the part people remember, and the words are the part nobody missed.
In 2002, “Bonanza” was ranked No. 43 on TV Guide’s 50 Greatest TV Shows of All Time. In 2013, TV Guide included it in its list of The 60 Greatest Dramas of All Time. The show continues to air in syndication.
What the 431 Episodes Actually Prove
Here is the case for “Bonanza” at 7.5 of 10. Length is not the same thing as quality, and the two get confused constantly. Fourteen seasons is an achievement of endurance, scheduling and audience habit. It is not, by itself, an argument that any given hour was good.
What is an argument is the structure. A father, three sons by three dead wives, a cook, a ranch, a town. That is a machine for generating stories about obligation, and it ran long enough to wear every combination out. In this paper’s view, the early seasons with Roberts, Blocker and Landon together are the ones that matter most. The later seasons, with Canary, Vogel and Matheson cycling through, are the ones that test your patience.
The moral-dilemma approach is the part worth defending. A Western that wants to argue about justice rather than just shoot at it is aiming higher than most of its competition, and “Bonanza” hit that target often enough to justify the reputation. It also missed often enough that the reputation should come with an asterisk. The show could be preachy. It could be slow. Its idea of a social issue was sometimes a speech.
The Verdict on the Ponderosa
“Bonanza” is not the best Western of its era. By the one measure the source gives plainly, it is the second-longest-running Western on American network television, behind CBS’s “Gunsmoke.” The source does not rank the two on quality, and this paper will not pretend it does.
What the record does support is the family structure. The show moved its weight off the range and onto a father and three sons, and that is the thing worth studying. Whether later week-to-week family dramas owe it a debt is a claim the source does not make, and this paper will not make it either.
The score is 7.5 of 10. That feels right. It is a show with a real idea, a strong cast in its prime, a theme song that outlived the episodes, and a long tail that diluted the whole. Watch the first several seasons. Know that the last several are there. The Ponderosa was enormous, and not all of it was worth riding across.
KEY FACTS BOX
- Score: 7.5 of 10
- Network: NBC
- Run: September 12, 1959 – January 16, 1973
- Seasons: 14
- Episodes: 431
- Created by: David Dortort
- Setting: 1860s, near Virginia City, Nevada
- Ranch: The Ponderosa, near Lake Tahoe, on the edge of the Sierra Nevada
- Theme song: “Bonanza,” instrumental renditions only during the run
- TMDB audience score: 7.5/10 (499 votes)
- TV Guide 2002 ranking: No. 43, 50 Greatest TV Shows of All Time
- TV Guide 2013 list: The 60 Greatest Dramas of All Time
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.