This week Andy Burnham gave a speech where he attempted to balance two separate aims. He wished to honour his father while also setting out his political plan for his first complete year as prime minister. Chris Mason of the BBC argues these two purposes reinforced each other rather than coming into conflict.
Grief as the Spine
The key thing to understand about Burnham’s speech, Mason writes, is that it came from a man who is both mourning and governing. Burnham became prime minister during the final weeks of his father’s life, and he prepared the speech while still dealing with the grief of his loss. The funeral will take place in a few days’ time.
This deeply political speech carried a personal core drawn from reflections on his dad’s life and influence. Mason describes it as such.
The Broad Pitch
Mason splits the address into two distinct sections. One part covers what Burnham hopes to accomplish before the next general election. The other part is the longer-term prospectus he is building for polling day inside the next three years.
Gestating the biggest ideas often requires the most extended timeframe and the greatest need for prolonged deliberation. The headline grabber was revamping social care in England.
Previous attempts to do so, by both Labour and the Conservatives, haven’t survived the intensity of a general election campaign, having been announced close to an election. Burnham’s plan aims to seed a conversation now about what a new system might look like.
The Pension Plan
The proposal for financing the overhaul of social care marks a departure from how pensions work now. Under the triple lock, the state pension rises each year by the most generous of three measures: inflation, average earnings growth, or 2.5%, whichever is greatest.
The annual earnings link is what Burnham wants to remove, starting from April 2030. Should Labour win the next general election, the state pension would get a further rise if necessary, so it remains above 30% of the full-time average wage.
The union and Labour’s political rivals moved swiftly. The prime minister, aware that he would face blunt criticism about scrapping the existing triple lock, seemed eager to provide as much reassuring detail as possible.
| Policy | Detail | Timing |
|---|---|---|
| Social care revamp | Seed a conversation now | Longest timeframe |
| Pension triple lock | Drop earnings link from April 2030 | 2030 |
| Voting system | Change planned for next manifesto | Review to come |
| EU relationship | Closer relationship proposed | Details not yet known |
Housing, Water and Energy
Burnham covered several topics outside social care and pensions. He said a public body would put money into the electricity grid, and he noted housing changes for England along with greater public management of the water industry.
The speech lasted more than an hour. Beyond a broad reference to Labour’s opponents on the Right, the party’s rivals didn’t get a mention.
Mason notes the energy and sense of urgency in Burnham’s pitch. The prime minister has created a battalion of dividing lines with Labour’s political opponents, and his cabinet and many in his party are relishing the battle of ideas he has set up.
Delivering on the Vision
Mason raises a question about Burnham and his administration: do they have the ability to actually carry out what they propose? The second part of the inquiry concerns public confidence: can they persuade voters that their vision is coherent, appealing and affordable?
The setting works against success. A sluggish economy and a restless global situation will make it hard to turn any of these plans into reality.
Whether the government can maintain the position it took is what matters now.
Source material: “Chris Mason: Burnham delivers deeply political speech with a personal core,” the BBC.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.