Game Reviews7.8/10
Madden NFL 25 Trades Visual Polish for Clumsy Controls
A review of Madden NFL 25, wherein presentation shines yet gameplay falters, yielding a score of 7.8.
CLAY TRIBUNE / THE ARCHIVE
Category: Game Reviews
Every game we have scored, from the NES library to current releases.
Game Reviews7.4/10
Thirteen Years On, Scribblenauts Unmasked Still Lets Players Summon Anything They Can Name
A vast dictionary of words, summoned into a world of capes and cowls — a review of Scribblenauts Unmasked.
Game Reviews7.3/10
WWE 2K14 Review: Career Mode Shines, Online Stumbles
A wrestler's tale of a vast roster, a deep career mode, and an online realm that falters—this review weighs WWE 2K14's triumphs and stumbles.
Game Reviews7.4/10
Twelve Years On, Styx’s Underwater Breathing Still Defines Its Stealth Design
A thief who breathes air beneath the waves must slip past guards unseen in this palace of shadow.
Game Reviews7.4/10
Unlimited World RED Review: Familiar Faces, Familiar Combat, Familiar Trouble
A vast ocean of foes, a roster of familiar faces, and swift blows — this review weighs the worth of One Piece's battle game.
Game Reviews7.9/10
Eleven Years On, Heroes of the Storm Still Delivers Fast, Deep Team Play
A review of Blizzard's team-based arena game, where heroes from many realms clash upon small maps of ruin.
Game Reviews8.6/10
MLB The Show 19 Review: Pitching and Fielding Overhauls Carry the Weight
A review of MLB The Show 19, a baseball simulation with a new pitching system, improved fielding, and a deep career mode.
Game Reviews7.6/10
Valiant Hearts Review: Puzzles Hold Up While Its War Story Sags
A tale of five souls bound by war, where puzzles and quiet sorrow hold the heart captive.
Game Reviews7.5/10
Manny’s Father Drinks Too Much in Papo & Yo, and So Does the Game
A boy named Manny travels a strange world to save his father, a man who drinks too much and turns into a giant creature.
Game Reviews7.3/10
Alone With You Turns Dying Into a Quiet, Repetitive Ritual — and Earns a 7.3
A quiet game about sitting with a dying patient, without combat, score or hurry — a rare, honest look at grief.