Ron Howard’s In the Heart of the Sea has a whale, a shipwreck and a cannibalism-adjacent survival trek, and still manages to feel like a museum exhibit you are escorted past at walking speed. The film premiered in New York City on December 7, 2015, opened in U.S. theaters on December 11 from Warner Bros. Pictures, and grossed $94.3 million against a $100 million budget. That number tells you what audiences did with it.
Trailer, via Warner Bros..
Herman Melville at the Inn
The framing device is the problem. In 1850, Herman Melville (Ben Whishaw) visits innkeeper Thomas Nickerson, the last survivor of the whaleship Essex, and offers money for his story. Nickerson refuses, then agrees after his wife intervenes.
This is a film that keeps telling you why the story matters instead of letting the story matter. Every time the movie cuts back to the inn, it drains tension from the ocean. Whishaw is fine. The structure is not.
The Essex Leaves Nantucket
In 1820, a Nantucket whaling company refits the Essex for a hunt to bring back whale oil. Fourteen-year-old Nickerson (Tom Holland) joins as cabin boy. Veteran whaler Owen Chase (Chris Hemsworth) is hired as first mate and is disappointed not to get a captain’s commission.
Captain George Pollard (Benjamin Walker) is an inexperienced mariner who envies Chase’s skill and popularity. They clash. Pollard sails into a storm against Chase’s advice. Then they agree to put their differences aside.
That reconciliation arrives too early and costs nothing. Two men who dislike each other decide to get along, and the movie moves on. There is no scene that makes you feel the decision.
The White Whale at the Offshore Grounds
Three months pass without success. Pollard realizes the Atlantic holds no sighting of whales. The Essex rounds Cape Horn to the Pacific. In Atacames, Ecuador, a Spanish captain describes the “Offshore Grounds” 2,000 miles west, and says a vengeful “white whale” destroyed his ship and killed six of his men.
Undaunted, Pollard and Chase lead the expedition west. They find the grounds. A massive bull sperm whale with white, scarred skin damages the boats and turns on the ship. Chase harpoons it from the deck. The whale rams the hull, killing two men.
The crew abandons the sinking Essex in three whaling boats with limited supplies. The whale attacks again. They escape to Henderson Island, where Chase finds long-dead skeletons of earlier castaways and the crew fears it may die waiting for rescue. Four men stay. The rest sail on.
Chris Hemsworth and the Barrels
Hemsworth was cast as Owen Chase in June 2012. Holland won young Nickerson in April 2013. Cillian Murphy signed on as Matthew Joy that June. Before Walker was set as captain, the actors considered included Benedict Cumberbatch, Tom Hiddleston and Henry Cavill.
Nearly 200 wooden barrels were fashioned for the film by master cooper Alastair Simms, who appears on screen making casks on the ship. That detail is the most alive thing in the production. You can see the work in the barrels. You cannot see it in the men.
The cast is deep — Brendan Gleeson as old Nickerson, Michelle Fairley as Mrs. Nickerson, Paul Anderson as Thomas Chappel, Frank Dillane as Owen Coffin, Joseph Mawle as Benjamin Lawrence, Edward Ashley as Barzallai Ray, Sam Keeley as Ramsdell. Most of them are given nothing to play beyond wet and hungry.
What the Film Gets Wrong
One oddity worth naming: based on the look of Gleeson’s elder Thomas Nickerson, the filmmakers appear to have based his appearance on a photograph of a different Thomas Nickerson, a railroad executive born in Massachusetts in the correct period but a completely different person. It is a small error that fits a larger pattern. This is a movie assembled from parts that look right and do not connect.
Charles Leavitt wrote the screenplay from a story by Leavitt, Rick Jaffa and Amanda Silver, working from Nathaniel Philbrick’s 2000 non-fiction book. The source is a real book about a real sinking. The film treats it as a tagline delivery system: “Based on the incredible true story that inspired Moby Dick.”
That is the whole pitch, and the movie never earns it. Melville’s 1851 novel gets invoked at the start and the end, but the film never shows you why the sinking would produce that book. It shows you a whale hitting a boat, repeatedly, and men getting thinner.
The Verdict on In the Heart of the Sea
Here is the ranking that matters, worst to best, of what this movie has to work with:
- The whale attacks — staged with weight, and the only sequences with real momentum.
- The barrels — genuinely built, genuinely on screen, a rare piece of craft.
- The survival trek — grim, but the film rushes the desperation it needs.
- The Pollard-Chase rivalry — declared, then dropped.
- The Melville frame — a device that explains the story instead of telling it.
In the Heart of the Sea wants to be about obsession, vengeance and what men do when the sea takes everything. It is 122 minutes of a very expensive production that never finds a reason to exist beyond its own tagline. The whale is the star. The whale is also the only character the film trusts.
KEY FACTS
– Release date: December 11, 2015 (U.S.)
– Premiere: December 7, 2015, New York City
– Distributor: Warner Bros. Pictures
– Runtime: 122 minutes
– Budget: $100 million
– Gross: $94.3 million
– Metacritic: 47/100
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
