“Dancing With The Stars” has done it again. The ABC competition’s 35th season sailed through its third week on Yacht Rock Night, and the night ended with a surprise: a real contender with genuine potential was voted off, giving fans their first truly surprising elimination of the season.
The theme was all about the low-key tunes your dad might play while firing up the grill. The judges scored high, the couples danced well, and then the floor dropped. Here’s how it went down.
Yacht Rock Night Runs Smoothly For Most Couples
The show hit its stride early. Safe couples delivered their best performances yet, and the judges responded with some of the highest scores of the season.
Amber Glenn and pro Pasha Pashkov opened with a foxtrot to “Hold the Line” by Toto. The judges gave them 24 out of 30, the first eights of the season. That score came despite Amber giving Pasha a wicked bloody nose in rehearsals.
Julia Stiles and pro Ezra Sosa followed with a salsa to “I Can’t Go for That (No Can Do)” by Daryl Hall and John Oates. Between Julia’s emotion over last week’s scores and a potential rib injury in rehearsals, there were worries she’d fall apart. She didn’t. The judges scored 19 out of 30, her first seven.
Guillermo Rodriguez and pro Witney Carson performed a foxtrot to “Escape (The Piña Colada Song)” by Rupert Holmes. They added an umbrella prop to the first section, and it worked. Guillermo handled the flip like a pro. The judges scored 15 out of 30.
Tatyana Ali and pro Jan Ravnik brought a quickstep to “Maneater” by Daryl Hall and John Oates. The judges scored 21 out of 30, her first sevens.
Harry Shum Jr. and pro Jenna Johnson danced a jive to “You Make My Dreams Come True” by Daryl Hall and John Oates. The judges scored 24 out of 30.
Maura Higgins and pro Mark Ballas performed a quickstep to “Turn Your Love Around” by George Benson. The judges scored 22 out of 30.
Ciara Miller and pro Brandon Armstrong closed with a cha-cha to “Never Too Much” by Luther Vandross. Ciara’s orange two-piece and grill outfit drew attention, and the judges noted she has details to finesse sooner rather than later.
The Elimination
The night took a sharp turn at the end. A real contender with genuine potential was voted off, and it gave fans their first truly surprising elimination of Season 35.
The recap does not name the eliminated couple. It simply documents the performance, the judges’ scores, and the outcome.
What The Scores Show
The scoring was generous across the board. Several couples earned their highest scores yet, and the judges handed out some of the season’s best numbers.
Here’s how the safe couples ranked:
- Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov — 24 out of 30
- Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson — 24 out of 30
- Tatyana Ali and Jan Ravnik — 21 out of 30
- Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas — 22 out of 30
- Julia Stiles and Ezra Sosa — 19 out of 30
- Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson — 15 out of 30
The top of the list was tight. Amber and Harry both scored 24, which tied for the highest of the night. Tatyana and Maura were close behind at 21 and 22. Julia and Guillermo lagged at the bottom.
The Choreography Details
The recap is full of specific choreographic observations. Each couple’s routine had a distinct personality, and the judges’ critiques landed with precision.
Amber’s foxtrot highlighted her figure skating background. The recap noted that Pasha works in Amber’s skating chops subtly, with jumps, twirls, and leaps that fit her routines at the rink without feeling forced. One dramatic scream from Week 2 raised eyebrows.
Guillermo’s foxtrot included an umbrella prop. The recap admitted nervousness at the sight of it but praised Guillermo for handling the flip like a pro. The routine also drew an annual link to Witney and Milo Manheim’s freestyle, a performance you can never rewatch too much.
Tatyana’s quickstep was fast. Jan gave her speedy choreography, and she met that pace remarkably well without looking overwhelmed. There was a moment when Jan kneeled down and Tatyana strutted over his body with the right amount of attitude.
Harry’s jive was fun but imperfect. The judges gave him eights, but the recap wished for more constructive feedback. His hip-hop stylings have crept into two of his three dances, and the instinct to get fluid with his movements held back the crispness of this jive at times.
Ciara’s cha-cha was a step forward. She looked exponentially more comfortable on the dance floor, but the judges noted details that need refining.
The Commentary Tone
The recap’s tone is consistently amused and affectionate. It treats the show as a guilty pleasure, documenting every prop, every wardrobe choice, and every score with warmth.
The recap also touches on the show’s long-running dynamic. Guillermo-esque contestants start getting mildly condescending comments as the season progresses, and the recap suspects that trajectory can only go on for so long. But for now, the recap is here for the low-stakes good time that Witney and Guillermo seem to be having.
Final Thoughts
Yacht Rock Night was a success for the show. The couples danced well, the scores were generous, and the elimination was surprising.
The recap’s final line invites viewer reactions on Yacht Rock Night in a comment. That’s a direct invitation to engage, and it fits the show’s format of building a community around each broadcast.
For fans, the takeaway is simple: the season is heating up. A real contender is gone, and the remaining couples have shown they can deliver. The judges have set a high bar, and the next episodes will need to clear it.
The recap’s amusement is the right response. The show is entertainment, and the eliminations are part of what makes it compelling. Fans will tune in next week to see who survives, and the drama continues.
Source material: “Dancing With The Stars Sails Into The Season's First Shocking Elimination On Yacht Rock Night — Who Went Home?,” TVLine.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.