John Murdoch wakes up in a hotel bathtub with no memory of who he is. The phone rings, and a doctor named Daniel Schreber tells him to run. A group of pale men in trenchcoats, the Strangers, are chasing him. That setup is simple. The execution is not.
Dark City is a 1998 science-fiction thriller directed by Alex Proyas, co-written with Lem Dobbs and David S. Goyer, and starring Rufus Sewell as Murdoch, William Hurt as Inspector Frank Bumstead, Kiefer Sutherland as Schreber, and Jennifer Connelly as Murdoch’s wife, Emma. It runs 101 minutes and trades on a premise so strange that the film spends half its runtime explaining itself. The tagline promises a nightmare world with no sun, run by beings with telekinetic powers who hunt human souls. That is the whole movie.
Trailer, via Warner Bros. Rewind.
Waking Up in the Hotel
Murdoch finds a dead woman in his hotel room, a bloody knife, and a phone call telling him to leave. He runs, and the Strangers catch him. Inspector Bumstead, investigating murdered prostitutes, puts Murdoch on the suspect list. Murdoch follows clues back to his name and his wife. The Strangers, it turns out, are not human. They are aliens living inside human bodies, sharing a hive mind, and they have been rearranging the city’s population for years.
The Power of Tuning
The Strangers can alter reality. They call it tuning. When the clock strikes twelve, everyone else falls asleep and the city shifts around them. The Strangers move buildings, change streets, and inject new memories into people’s heads. Murdoch discovers he shares this power. He uses it to escape. The film spends considerable time establishing these rules, then leans on them heavily for the rest of the runtime.
The Cast
Sewell carries the film. He plays Murdoch as a man losing his grip on reality, and the amnesia sells. Hurt is solid as Bumstead, a man who sees something wrong with the city and cannot prove it. Sutherland is the film’s true oddity as Schreber, a doctor who may or may not be working for the Strangers. Connelly gets less to do than the others, but her presence anchors Murdoch’s search for his wife.
The supporting cast is strong. Richard O’Brien plays Mr. Hand, a bald, androgynous Stranger who carries a copy of Murdoch’s memories. Ian Richardson plays Mr. Book, a high-ranking Stranger. Bruce Spence plays Mr. Wall, and Colin Friels plays Det. Eddie Walenski. Melissa George plays May, and Frank Gallacher plays Chief Inspector Stromboli. Anita Kelsey provides the singing voice of Emma Murdoch in the theatrical cut.
The Problems
Dark City is a film that wants to be confusing. It achieves that easily. The narrative is opaque, and the final act asks the audience to accept a lot of hand-waving about the Strangers’ motives. The film is also visually dense. Fox Studios Australia is the primary shooting location, and the production design is impressive, but the sheer amount of information crammed into each frame can overwhelm the story.
The film’s biggest flaw is pacing. The middle stretch drags as Murdoch wanders the city, searching for answers that the film has already given. The voice-over added by Proyas at New Line’s request does not help. It explains the mystery instead of letting the images do the work.
The Legacy
Dark City was nominated for the Hugo Award for Best Dramatic Presentation and six Saturn Awards. Some critics later noted its similarities to and influence on the Matrix film series, whose first installment came out a year later. The film is now widely considered a sci-fi cult classic.
That reputation is earned. The film’s ambition is real, and its visual style, particularly the nightmarish cityscape, remains striking. The premise is genuinely unsettling, and the idea of a city reshaped by unseen forces is still effective today.
- The premise is genuinely unsettling
- The visual style is striking
- The supporting cast is uniformly excellent
- The pacing drags in the middle stretch
- The explanation comes too late
| Element | Detail |
|---|---|
| Director | Alex Proyas |
| Writers | Proyas, Lem Dobbs, David S. Goyer |
| Lead | Rufus Sewell |
| Supporting | William Hurt, Kiefer Sutherland, Jennifer Connelly |
| Length | 101 minutes |
| Year | 1998 |
The film’s strengths are substantial. Its vision is unique, and the performances are uniformly excellent. But the script is too loose, and the explanation of the mystery is too late. Dark City is a flawed masterpiece, a film that understands its own strangeness even as it loses control of its own story.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
