The Grinch is a big-budget animated remake of Dr. Seuss’s beloved tale, and it fails to capture the spirit that made the original special. The movie is loud, bright, and entirely forgettable. It is the kind of family entertainment that exists to fill seats during holiday weekends, not to leave any lasting impression.
The premise is simple: the Grinch, a bitter creature who lives alone atop a mountain, hates Christmas. He schemes to ruin the holiday for the cheerful citizens of Whoville below. The live-action version from 2000, starring Jim Carrey, remains the definitive adaptation. This new version, voiced by Benedict Cumberbatch, is a pale imitation.
Trailer, via Illumination.
The Problem With Big Voices
The biggest mistake is the casting. Cumberbatch is a fine actor, but he is miscast here. His Grinch is a gruff, growling presence, and the performance feels forced. The voice is too deep, too theatrical, and it clashes with the cartoonish world around him. In a story about a small, green creature who lives alone atop a mountain, a voice that sounds like it belongs to a grown man comes across as unintentionally comical.
The supporting cast fares better. Pharrell Williams voices the dog Max, and he brings genuine warmth to a character that could have been a prop. The Mayor of Whoville, voiced by Kenan Thompson, is a buffoonish presence, and the movie leans on him for comic relief. It works in small doses, but it also exposes the shallow writing beneath.
A Holiday That Misses Its Mark
The plot follows the Grinch’s plan to steal Christmas. He dresses up as Santa Claus, sneaks into town, and collects all the presents and decorations. The townspeople are unaware of his scheme until the very last moment.
There are a few clever moments, mostly involving the Grinch’s attempts to blend in. He disguises himself as a reindeer, a snowman, and a tree. These sequences are visually busy, but they lack the wit of the original story. The humor is broad, slapstick, and aimed squarely at children. It is the kind of humor that can work in a live-action comedy, where a physical comedian like Jim Carrey can make the audience feel the Grinch’s desperation, but it falls flat when delivered through a cartoon character whose body language is limited to exaggerated digital expressions.
The climax is predictable. The Grinch discovers that Christmas means more than gifts, and he changes his heart. The message is sincere, but it is delivered with such obviousness that it feels hollow. The movie does not earn its ending. It simply states it.
Music That Overstays Its Welcome
Pharrell Williams also provides the soundtrack. The songs are poppy, catchy, and utterly forgettable. They exist to fill time, not to advance the story. The Grinch sings about being green, about feeling left out, and about wanting love. None of it lands. The songs are pleasant, but they are forgettable in the way that background music is forgettable — pleasant to hear while you watch, gone from memory as soon as the credits roll.
The score, composed by Brian Tyler, is bombastic and overbearing. It swells at every emotional beat, drowning out the dialogue and the action. The music is meant to make you feel something, but it only makes you wince. It is the kind of score that tells you exactly how to feel at every moment, leaving little room for your own emotional response.
A World Built For Bright Screens
The animation is the one area where the movie excels. The characters are expressive, the colors are vibrant, and the backgrounds are lush. The Whos look like living dolls, and their movements are fluid. The Grinch’s fur is a marvel of detail, and his eyes convey emotion in ways the voice performance cannot.
The problem is that the visuals are too clean. There is no grit, no texture, no sense of lived-in space. The world of Whoville looks like a toy store, not a real place. The movie is so polished that it loses its soul. It is beautiful to look at, but it never feels like a real place, and that distance between the viewer and the world makes it harder to care about what happens there.
A Tale That Should Have Stopped Early
The runtime is 86 minutes, which is short by modern standards. But the movie could have used even more trimming. The middle section drags, with the Grinch wandering around Whoville and stealing things that are not particularly interesting. The pacing is uneven, and the film loses momentum halfway through.
The humor is also uneven. Some jokes land, others fall flat. There are a few genuinely funny moments, but they are buried under a mountain of unfunny ones. The movie tries too hard to be funny, and it ends up being merely silly. The unfunny moments pile up faster than the funny ones, and by the end the movie feels like a long stretch of filler punctuated by occasional laughs.
Comparing Two Versions Of The Same Story
The 2000 live-action version, directed by Ron Howard, is a far superior film. Carrey’s Grinch is a physical comedian, and his performance is both grotesque and sympathetic. The movie is darker, funnier, and more honest about the character’s pain.
The 1966 animated TV special, directed by Chuck Jones, is the purest adaptation. It is simple, charming, and faithful to the book. The Grinch is voiced by Boris Karloff, and his narration is a masterpiece of deadpan delivery. It is a short, simple story told with restraint, and it remains the version that most people think of when they imagine the Grinch.
This new version sits somewhere in between, but it fails to capture the magic of either predecessor. It is a competent, occasionally amusing, ultimately pointless addition to the franchise.
A Final Word On The Grinch
The Grinch is a missed opportunity. It has all the ingredients for a great holiday movie: a memorable villain, a heartfelt message, and a timeless story. But the execution is weak, and the result is a hollow, forgettable experience.
The movie is not terrible. It is just unremarkable. It will entertain children for a few hours, and it will make some money for its studio. But it will not be remembered, and it will not inspire anyone.
Here is what works:
- Pharrell Williams’ Max is a warm presence
- The animation is technically impressive
- The Grinch’s disguise sequences are cleverly staged
And here is what does not:
- Benedict Cumberbatch’s voice is too deep for the character
- The songs are bland and forgettable
- The humor is uneven and often misses its mark
The Grinch is a reminder that remakes are not always necessary. Sometimes, the original is enough. The 2000 version is the definitive Grinch, and this one should have stayed on the shelf.
The Grinch is a middling animated feature that fails to honor its source material. It is pleasant, but it is not memorable. It is a product, not a work of art. The final score is 5.1 out of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
