WRITTEN IN PLAIN AMERICAN ENGLISH.
About
CLAY TRIBUNE.
ShopCartAccount
Advertisement

Eleven Years On, Merlí Still Turns Its Classroom Into The Smartest Show On TV

A retired inspector teaches philosophy in Barcelona, solving crimes by watching and listening, not by force.

By mitch·7 min read
A man in a suit stands quietly on a sunny street, watching others pass by.

Merlí is a Spanish crime drama that runs on logic, not violence. It follows a retired police inspector who now teaches philosophy to troubled students at a Barcelona high school. The show is slow, deliberate, and often quiet, but it builds a case for patience. It premiered in 2015 and ran for six seasons, with a seventh currently airing.

The core trick of Merlí is that it makes a teacher the central investigator. Merlí, played by Eduard Fernández, solves crimes by reading people. He watches how they move, what they say, and what they don’t say. His classroom becomes a kind of crime lab, and his students become his assistants. The show is less about the crimes themselves than about the people committing them, and it trusts the audience to follow the threads.

Trailer, via Crisàlide.

Advertisement

Case Files

Each season of Merlí focuses on a different case, but the cases are rarely the point. The show spends more time on character than on plot. The cases are there to reveal the characters, not to be solved for their own sake. The best episodes are the ones where Merlí sits with a student, listens to their story, and pieces together what happened behind closed doors.

The first season introduces Merlí’s method through a murder investigation. The second season deals with a kidnapping. The third season looks at corruption within the police force. The fourth season involves a missing person case. The fifth season centers on a suicide. The sixth season explores a political scandal. Each case is a vehicle for the show to examine power, family, and the way people hide who they really are.

The show’s approach to storytelling is structural. It presents evidence in fragments, then lets Merlí assemble it later. The audience sees the pieces first, and then watches him put them together. This means the show can be frustrating at times. Episodes often end with a cliffhanger that feels unresolved. But the payoff comes in the next episode, where Merlí ties everything together with a single observation.

“The truth is always hidden in plain sight.”

That line, spoken by Merlí himself, sums up the show’s philosophy. Nothing is hidden, he insists. Everything is visible, but we are not always looking in the right direction.

Eduard Fernández’s Performance

Eduard Fernández is the heart of Merlí. He plays the inspector with a calm, almost paternal presence. He is sharp, observant, and patient. He never raises his voice or raises his hand. He waits, watches, and then speaks. His performance carries the show through its slower stretches.

Fernández brings a sense of dignity to the role. Merlí is not a hero in the traditional sense. He is a man who sees clearly, and that clarity makes him dangerous. He is also deeply human. He has his own demons, his own regrets, and his own vulnerabilities. The show never pretends he is perfect. It shows him making mistakes, and then correcting them.

The supporting cast is strong too. The students Merlí teaches are not stereotypes. They are complicated young people with their own histories. Some are brilliant. Some are troubled. Some are both. The show gives each of them room to breathe, and it treats their stories with the same care it treats the adult plots.

Philosophy Lessons

Merlí is a philosophy teacher, and the show takes its lessons seriously. It is full of quotes from philosophers, references to existentialism, and discussions of morality. But the show never feels preachy. It uses philosophy as a tool, not a lecture. Merlí applies his ideas to real problems, and the students respond in ways that feel honest.

The show’s philosophical moments are woven into the plot, not placed on top of it. A discussion of determinism might lead directly into a decision about guilt. A talk about free will might shape a character’s choice. The show trusts the audience to see the connection, and it rewards that trust.

The show also touches on politics, religion, and social issues. It handles these topics with care, and it avoids easy answers. It presents problems without offering simple solutions. This can be frustrating for viewers who want closure. But it is also faithful to the show’s worldview. Merlí does not solve problems by force. He solves them by understanding.

Slow Pace

Merlí moves slowly, and that pace is deliberate. The show is not interested in spectacle. It is interested in process. It wants the audience to sit with the characters, to watch them think, and to see the world through their eyes. This means the show is not for everyone. It requires patience, and it rewards it.

The pacing can test attention spans. Some episodes drag, especially those that build toward a confrontation. But the show is careful about its rhythm. It knows when to hold back and when to push forward. The tension is built in the details, not in the action.

The show also repeats itself. It returns to the same themes, the same questions, and the same characters. This can feel repetitive to some viewers. But repetition is a technique here. It reinforces the idea that truths repeat, and that the same patterns appear again and again. The show is saying something about the nature of reality, and it does so by doing the same things over and over.

Visual Style

Merlí has a distinctive visual style. It is shot in Barcelona, and the city is a character in its own right. The show uses wide shots of the streets, the sea, and the buildings. It favors natural light and practical locations. It feels lived-in, not staged.

The cinematography is clean and controlled. It does not rely on flashy techniques. It relies on composition and color. The show uses color to signal mood. It is rare to hear a scene that is too loud. Most scenes are quiet, and that quiet is intentional.

The show also uses music sparingly. Its score is minimal, and it often lets silence do the work. This fits the tone. The show is about listening, and it models that listening in its sound design.

Seventh Season

The seventh season of Merlí is currently airing, and it continues the show’s tradition of political engagement. It deals with corruption, and it puts Merlí in direct conflict with powerful people. The show has always been political, but this season makes that politics explicit. It asks what happens when the law fails, and it offers no easy answers.

The season is still ongoing, so it is impossible to judge it fully. But the early episodes suggest a show that is reaching for something larger. It is asking big questions about justice, truth, and the limits of knowledge. It is doing so in the same way it has always done: through observation, patience, and quiet thought.

Legacy

Merlí has been influential in Spain and beyond. It has been praised for its writing, its performances, and its vision. It has also faced criticism for its slow pace and its repetitive structure. But its influence is undeniable.

The show has changed how crime dramas are made in Spain. It has shown that a crime story can be character-driven and intellectual. It has proven that a detective does not need a gun to be compelling. It has opened space for thoughtful, slow-paced television.

Merlí is a show that rewards attention. It is not a show for casual viewers. It is a show for people who want to think. It is a show that respects its audience. It is a show that trusts its own method.

Verdict

Merlí is a masterclass in slow television. It is a show that understands the value of observation. It is a show that trusts its audience to keep up. It is a show that rewards patience.

It is not perfect. It is repetitive, and it can be slow to a fault. But its strengths outweigh its weaknesses. It is a show that is worth watching, even when it tests the patience. It is a show that stays with you after you finish it.

The show’s final season is still unfolding, and it is shaping up to be the most ambitious yet. It is a fitting conclusion to a long-running story. It is a story about seeing, about understanding, and about the truth that is always hidden in plain sight.

Merlí earns its reputation. It is a show that deserves its praise. It is a show that stands tall among the best of its kind.

The Notebook

Get the Notebook.

The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.

We send one note to confirm. Every issue has a one-click way out.

TV reviews
Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

As an Amazon Associate, Clay Tribune earns from qualifying purchases.