Three men find themselves working for bosses who make every day terrible. That is the whole premise of “Horrible Bosses,” and the film spends 93 minutes trying to prove that premise is enough. It is not.
The movie follows Mike (Jason Sudeikis), Nick (Jason Bateman), and Kurt (Charlie Day) as they get stuck in jobs that treat them like furniture. Their bosses are the worst kind of people: the tyrannical Mr. Harkness (Kevin Spacey), the sleazy Bobby Pellitt (Colin Farrell), and the smug Dale Arbus (Josh Peck). When things finally break down, the three friends plot revenge. It sounds like a setup for a sharp comedy. Instead, it plays out as a series of jokes that land with a thud.
Trailer, via Warner Bros..
The Coffee Shop Meeting
The film opens with the three friends meeting in a coffee shop, trading stories about their awful days. Mike is stuck with Mr. Harkness, a boss who treats him like a pet. Nick works for Bobby Pellitt, who thinks he can have anything he wants. Kurt is trapped under Dale Arbus, whose smarmy confidence masks a total lack of skill. The setup is simple and effective. It also gets better than the execution.
Each man’s boss is a caricature of a workplace bully. Mr. Harkness is the worst of the three, a man who sees his employees as nothing more than tools. Kevin Spacey plays him with a sneer that never lets up, and the performance is the best reason to see the film. Colin Farrell is less successful as Bobby Pellitt, a boss who is supposed to be a lecher but comes off more as a sad sack. Josh Peck is the weakest link, playing Dale Arbus as a smug fool who barely registers as a threat.
The setup should carry the film. It does not.
The Revenge Plan
The revenge plot is where “Horrible Bosses” goes wrong. The three friends decide to frame their bosses for a crime, hoping to ruin their lives. The scheme is elaborate and convoluted, involving fake evidence and a fake confession. It is meant to be clever. It feels like filler.
The problem is that the plan is built around a crime that is never fully explained. We are told that the bosses have done something bad, but we never learn what that something is. The film spends more time on the mechanics of the scheme than on why it matters. This leaves the audience lost, wondering what exactly the friends are trying to punish.
“We’re going to make you pay.”
That line, spoken by one of the friends, sums up the entire plot. It is a promise of vengeance that never lands with weight. The film never explains why the bosses deserve it, beyond being unpleasant people. That is not enough to sustain a revenge comedy.
The Tone Problem
“Horrible Bosses” tries to be a comedy, but it never settles on a tone. Some scenes play the workplace drama straight, while others descend into crude humor. The shift happens without warning, leaving the film feeling scattered. There is no rhythm to it, no sense of where the story is going.
The film also leans heavily on physical comedy, with the three friends getting into scrapes and pratfalls. None of it lands. The gags are tired, the timing is off, and the jokes often depend on seeing something happen twice so the audience can laugh at the repetition.
The Three Friends
The cast is the film’s strongest asset. Jason Sudeikis brings a desperate energy to Mike, the friend who is the most beaten down. Jason Bateman plays Nick as a man who has lost his sense of self to his job. Charlie Day is the comic engine, delivering lines with a manic speed that carries the weaker scenes. Together, they sell the friendship even when the script does not.
Kevin Spacey is the standout. He plays Mr. Harkness with a cold precision that makes him genuinely frightening. The scene where he dismisses Mike is one of the few moments in the film that feels like a genuine threat. Colin Farrell is less effective, playing Bobby Pellitt as a cartoonish villain who never quite clicks. Josh Peck is the weakest of the three bosses, a character who exists mostly to be mocked rather than feared.
The supporting cast includes Jennifer Aniston as Kate, the woman Nick is pursuing, and Jamie Foxx as Tully, a former criminal who helps the friends with their scheme. Neither adds much. Aniston’s role is thin, and Foxx is wasted in a part that asks him to be a sidekick.
The Climax
The ending of “Horrible Bosses” is a letdown. After building up the revenge plan for so long, the film rushes through the climax. The bosses are punished, but the punishment feels hollow. The film ends on a note of triumph that feels earned neither by the characters nor by the audience.
The final scene is meant to be a victory lap. It is a shrug.
What Works
There are moments in “Horrible Bosses” that work. The setup is strong. The performances from the leads are solid. A few jokes land, particularly those that focus on the absurdity of the workplace rather than the gross-out humor. These are small victories in a film that never finds its footing.
The film is at its best when it is simply about three friends trapped in bad jobs. The middle stretch, where the revenge plot takes over, is where it falls apart. The scheme is too complicated for its own good, and the film loses sight of what made the setup compelling.
“Horrible Bosses” is a film that knows what it wants to say but cannot figure out how to say it. It is a comedy that is too serious to be funny and too silly to be taken seriously. The result is a movie that feels like a missed opportunity.
Key Facts
- Title: Horrible Bosses
- Director: Seth Gordon
- Release Year: 2011
- Runtime: 93 minutes
- Score: 5.7/10
The film is not a disaster, but it is not a success either. It is a middling attempt at a workplace comedy that fails to deliver on its promise. The premise is strong, the cast is capable, and the jokes are plentiful. None of that matters when the execution falls apart.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
