The Iowa statehouse approved a $1.36 billion package of tax incentives Friday for a foreign-owned steel plant in a swing district, a deal that has drawn protesters carrying signs reading “No Steel Steal!” and split Republicans over whether the state should be handing out such largesse.
The package, which includes roughly $777,000 in credits per permanent job over 10 years, passed the Iowa House 75-17 and the Senate 28-19. Governor Kim Reynolds signed it into law Friday night. The plant is proposed for Iowa’s first congressional district, where Rep. Mariannette Miller-Meeks is defending a GOP at-risk seat in November’s midterm elections.
The Deal Behind the Sign
The project is owned by Mesabi Metallics, a company controlled by the India-based Essar Group. The incentives are meant to support a new steel plant in Lee County, Iowa.
President Trump announced Monday that the largest steel plant in U.S. history will be built in Iowa, promising $15 billion, 1,750 permanent jobs and roughly 6,000 construction jobs. The plant would sit in a district where Miller-Meeks beat Democrat Christina Bohannan by just 798 votes in a 2024 recount.
Sabato’s Crystal Ball recently moved the race from “toss up” to “leans Democratic,” tightening the contest ahead of November.
Essar’s Record in Minnesota
The proposal carries baggage. Essar announced a $1.6 billion iron ore mine and steel plant in Nashwauk, Minnesota, in 2008, promising more than 700 permanent jobs. Those steel mill plans were dropped in 2015, and Essar Steel Minnesota filed for bankruptcy in 2016.
The company was renamed Mesabi Metallics under new owners before coming back under Essar’s control. Local media have reported that Essar has received billions of dollars in loans from the Russian state-owned bank VTB.
The Vote and Its Critics
Republicans on the Iowa Senate split sharply on the measure. Senator Kevin Alons called the pressure to vote “breathtaking” but voted yes. Senator Dave Sires voted no, complaining the process was rushed.
Senator Dan Dawson called it “the largest corporate giveaway in the state of Iowa’s history.” Senator Jeff Taylor voted against the bill, raising concerns about the state’s budget crunch.
Taylor was swapped off the Senate Ways and Means Committee at the last minute to ensure the bill would pass committee. It passed 10-8 with six Republican senators voting against it.
What the Candidates Say
Republican gubernatorial candidate Zach Lahn, who has campaigned against corporate handouts, called the idea of an Iowa steel plant a “once in a lifetime” exception. Democratic nominee Rob Sand, current state auditor, called the plant “a promising idea for Lee County” but wanted more details first.
Sand warned of past deals, saying “You look at these data center deals that this administration has done over the last few years and we gave away the farm.”
Iowa Senate Democratic Leader Janice Weiner said she wants good-paying jobs but balked at the rapid timeline, telling CBS News “If we were doing this the right way, we would be waiting until after the election.”
The Timeline
The vote comes less than two weeks before early voting starts on Oct. 14. The plant proposal is now official, but the company’s record in Minnesota remains part of the public record.
| Event | Date |
|---|---|
| Essar announces Nashwauk, MN plant | 2008 |
| Steel mill plans dropped | 2015 |
| Essar Steel Minnesota files for bankruptcy | 2016 |
| Company renamed Mesabi Metallics | Under new owners |
| Returned under Essar control | Current |
| Senate vote | Friday |
| Early voting begins | Oct. 14 |
The Sign’s Message
Protesters at the Iowa statehouse Friday carried signs reading “No Steel Steal!” The phrase echoes a familiar pattern of corporate giveaways that leave taxpayers holding the bill while companies collect the checks.
The deal also arrives in a district where the margin of victory was measured in hundreds of votes. Every vote counts in a race that could flip the seat from red to blue.
Our View
Clay Tribune has a side in this story, and it is the side of the taxpayer. The paper leans toward less concentration of power in government and corporations, and a light touch on technology.
The steel plant’s promise rests on a company with a record of broken promises. The decision was made with little time for review.
The protesters at the statehouse had it right. This is a steel steal, and Iowans deserve better.
Where the paper stands
The paper backs no one here, and opposes the concentration of power in the hands of any single office, whatever its size or reach. The Essar Group is a foreign-controlled company with a history of failed projects and questionable dealings, including alleged loans from a Russian state bank. A $1.36 billion package of tax incentives for a steel plant in a swing district is exactly the kind of giveaway that concentrates power in the hands of one office — in this case, the governor’s office — at the expense of the people whose money is being spent.
The vote came fast, the company’s record in Minnesota remains part of the public record, and the protesters who gathered at the statehouse with signs reading “No Steel Steal!” understood the stakes. The plant sits in a district where a Republican holds an at-risk seat won by a margin of 798 votes in a 2024 recount. The vote was split among Republicans themselves, with senators like Kevin Alons calling the pressure to vote “breathtaking” even as they voted yes, and senators like Dave Sires, Dan Dawson, and Jeff Taylor voting no.
The paper would want Iowans to know the full record before any vote is taken. The Essar Group’s record in Minnesota — dropped steel mill plans, a bankruptcy filing, and alleged loans from a Russian state bank — should not be swept under the rug because the governor has signed the bill into law. The protesters at the statehouse had it right, and Iowans deserve better than a deal that hands over nearly $800,000 in credits per permanent job over 10 years without giving the public time to weigh the cost.
Source material: “Iowa approves pricy foreign-owned steel plant project in swing district,” CBS News.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.