Disney+ has a new fantasy hit on its hands, and it is beating the MCU’s best show to take the platform’s Top 10 TV Shows crown. Coven Academy, the teen-witch drama that premiered on Freeform before moving to Disney+ and Hulu, has arrived with a perfect Rotten Tomatoes score and is currently sitting at #1 on the platform’s charts.
The show has unseated American Horror Story and Loki, two titles that typically dominate the rankings. It is also positioned as the strongest rival to Wednesday, the Netflix fantasy series that has been the dominant entry in recent years.
The Rise Of Coven Academy
Coven Academy premiered on October 1, 2026, as part of Freeform’s 31 Nights of Halloween programming. The next day, the full first season became available to stream on Disney+ and Hulu. At the time of writing, the entire 10-episode season is now on Disney+, and it holds a perfect Tomatoes score.
The show was created by Tim Federle, who developed it as an original story rather than adapting existing source material. That distinguishes it from some of Disney+’s other fantasy hits, which lean on licensed properties like Percy Jackson and the Olympians.
The premise follows Briar Roberts, played by Malina Weissman, a young woman from Brooklyn who is sent to Crescent Veil Academy, an elite boarding school for witches and warlocks in New Orleans. Briar has advanced telekinetic abilities but struggles with anger issues, forcing her to learn control throughout the season.
A Love Triangle And A School Under Threat
Briar arrives at the academy and quickly makes friends. Sasha, played by Jordan Leftwich, has mind-manipulation powers. Tegan, played by Ora Duplass, has time-bending abilities. Together, the three form a core group that navigates the school’s social dynamics.
Briar also has a love triangle, one that threatens not just her personal life but the wider coven and the rest of the school. That tension drives the show’s central drama, with the witches protecting each other while also exploring their individual powers.
Critics have praised the show’s emotional depth, its themes of sisterhood and community, and its blend of magic, mystery, and teenage drama. The tone has been described as reminiscent of 2000s teen horror and drama stories.
Why Coven Academy Surpassed Loki
Loki often ranks high on Disney+’s Top 10, sometimes above new releases, and American Horror Story is one of the most anticipated TV releases of the year. To beat both of them in the first week of availability is a notable achievement.
At the time of writing, Coven Academy sits at #1 on Disney+’s Top 10 TV Shows via FlixPatrol. The show has not been out for a week, yet it has already surpassed titles that typically anchor the chart.
What Happens In The Season Finale
Coven Academy packs a complete story into its 10 episodes. The season finale delivers a satisfying conclusion to its main conflict while also setting up a second season.
Without spoiling the ending, Briar manages to use her powers for good and learns an unexpected truth about her family. Her love triangle remains unresolved, leaving plenty of room for a second season to explore.
Renewal Status And The Road Ahead
At the time of writing, Coven Academy has not been renewed for a second season. However, with its strong critical reception and its #1 spot on the Top 10, cancellation after just 10 episodes seems unlikely.
The show can already boast beating Loki and American Horror Story. If it returns for a second season, it will be positioned as Wednesday’s biggest competitor in the fantasy space.
The Cast Behind The Show
The show’s cast includes:
- Malina Weissman as Briar Roberts
- Jordan Leftwich as Sasha
- Ora Duplass as Tegan
- Louis Thresher
- Tiffani Thiessen
- Shane Dean
- Devon Sawa
- Brandon McEwan
- Swayam Bhatia
- Brendon Tremblay
- Nathaniel Logan McIntyre
- Malachi Barton
Comparing The Fantasy Competition
- Coven Academy — #1 on Disney+’s Top 10
- Wednesday — Netflix, preparing for season 3
- Loki — MCU’s best show on Disney+’s charts
- American Horror Story — anticipated release
The Verdict On Coven Academy
Coven Academy has arrived with a bang. Its perfect Tomatoes score, its #1 ranking on Disney+’s Top 10, and its victory over two major competitors make it a significant entry in the fantasy genre.
The show has proven popular with general audiences as well as critics. Its mix of supernatural elements, teenage drama, and character-driven storytelling has clearly resonated.
Whether it can sustain that momentum depends on a second season. For now, it has established itself as the show to watch in the fantasy space, and it has already surpassed the MCU’s best show on Disney+’s charts.
See the video the story is built around at Screen Rant.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.