The New York Giants and Minnesota Vikings have reached an agreement on a trade that will send J.J. McCarthy to the Big Apple in exchange for a mid-round 2027 draft pick. McCarthy, who was the 2024 first-round selection, was recently demoted to third string by the Vikings.
McCarthy’s Fall in Minnesota
He came aboard late in the previous campaign, then squared off against Kyler Murray for the starting job during training camp. McCarthy lost that competition, and his fall continued into the regular season, when he was demoted to third string.
The Vikings kept changing their starting quarterback. After Murray missed time because he suffered a concussion in the season-opener, the team turned to Carson Wentz. McCarthy stayed as the backup.
The signal meant the Vikings had given up on him. The franchise has been one of the most successful at lifting up quarterbacks in recent years, bringing back Sam Darnold’s career among its achievements. McCarthy, though, was an exception — too often injured and too inconsistent when he played.
The Vikings won’t say this publicly. They’ll say they wish McCarthy the best with his new team. But the truth is they’ve moved on because he has been too-often injured and too inconsistent when he has been able to play or practice.
Why the Giants Took Him
Coach John Harbaugh’s Giants sit at 2-1, and he is working to get them back in the win column. The team has a clear need for depth at quarterback, with Jameis Winston serving as the starter and Jaxson Dart ruled out for the rest of the season after suffering a likely season-ending knee injury in Week 2. McCarthy steps into that role as a backup option.
The Giants expect McCarthy to join the team and work on learning the system. He may eventually unseat Jake Haener as the backup this season. The best-case scenario for the team is that McCarthy could be worth considering as a starter later this season if Winston gets hurt or his play declines.
It’s not a matter of the Giants replacing Dart with McCarthy. The team remains committed to Dart and his growth. McCarthy, meanwhile, functions as a temporary addition through 2027, still under his rookie contract.
The Upside and the Risk
Should McCarthy actually live up to his 2024 Jim Harbaugh billing, that would be great! His brother John Harbaugh would reap the benefits and appear to be a genius.
But the Giants are taking a gamble. McCarthy has a long injury history, and he hasn’t shown consistency on the field. If he continues being what he’s been, this ain’t going to salvage the season for the Giants.
The exchange carries with it an effort to escape shame. The Vikings are trading McCarthy for a fifth-round selection in 2027, just three years after taking him in the first round. The attempt did not work, and they do not think they can fix him now.
What McCarthy Has to Show
The Giants need McCarthy to show he can avoid injuries and play at a steady level. If Winston is not available, the team will be depending on him to step in. For the Vikings, the trade means accepting a selection they sent away for a player they decided was no longer worth keeping.
Here’s the order of events that got McCarthy to New York:
- McCarthy starts at the end of last season for the Vikings.
- He fights Kyler Murray for the job in training camp and loses.
- He drops to third string when the regular season begins.
- The Vikings turn to Carson Wentz when Murray misses time after a concussion.
- McCarthy remains a backup throughout the early season.
- The Vikings trade him to the Giants for a mid-round 2027 pick.
| Team | Role | Trade Value |
|---|---|---|
| Vikings | Demoted quarterback | Mid-round 2027 pick |
| Giants | Backup | 2024 first-round pick |
It is ironic that the very coach who once called McCarthy the greatest quarterback ever is now the one getting his brother’s team a backup with a long injury history. That’s the whole point.
New York is wagering on a signal-caller whose history raises doubts. John Harbaugh is making every effort to secure victory. The question of whether McCarthy can produce results remains unanswered.
The Giants have taken over a rental with a chance to turn it into something more. They are hoping McCarthy rediscovered the form his brother praised back in 2024. The Vikings have moved on from him, leaving the quarterback for the Giants instead.
McCarthy arrives with a roster that lacks depth at quarterback. The Giants stand at 2-1, and the trade is complete. Now comes the wait to see how it plays out.
Source material: “Harbaugh brothers really love J.J. McCarthy and that's one reason he's going to the New York Giants in a trade,” Fox News.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.