ROBLOX. VIDEO GAMES. MOVIES. ORIGINAL ANIMATIONS.
CLAY TRIBUNE.
Advertisement

3 Body Problem Review: A Confident, Intelligent Start With Room to Grow

Netflix's 3 Body Problem, from the Game of Thrones showrunners, adapts Liu Cixin's novels. Our review of its cast, ambition, Emmys and renewal.

By mitch·7 min read
Three figures stand apart beneath a starlit sky, each lost in thought of a loved one gone.

Netflix’s 3 Body Problem arrives with the weight of two careers behind it. David Benioff and D. B. Weiss, who ran Game of Thrones to its finish in 2019, built this one with Alexander Woo. It is their first television project since that show ended. The eight-episode first season landed on March 21, 2024. It is a big swing, and for most of its run it connects.

The show adapts Liu Cixin’s novel series Remembrance of Earth’s Past. Liu is a former computer engineer. This is the third adaptation of his books, after the animated The Three-Body Problem in Minecraft and the live-action Three-Body, both of which were made in Mandarin. Netflix’s version is mostly in English, with some Mandarin left in. It moves the story’s center of gravity out of China and into the United Kingdom, adding characters and locations the novels did not have.

Trailer, via Netflix.

Advertisement

Ye Wenjie and the Choice That Starts Everything

The series opens in the Cultural Revolution. Ye Wenjie, a Chinese astrophysicist played by Rosalind Chao, watches her father die during a struggle session. She runs into trouble with the authorities. Because of her scientific background, she is sent to a secret military base. There, during the Cold War, she races other countries to make first contact with aliens.

While at that base, she makes a choice. That choice shapes humanity’s future, and the show treats it as the hinge on which everything else turns. Chao carries those scenes without pushing. The part is the spine of the season, and the show knows it.

The premise is enormous, but the series handles the handoff well. It does not ask the audience to absorb a century of history and a first-contact plot in the same breath. It gives Ye Wenjie her own space, then pulls the timeline forward.

The Oxford Five and the Suicides in London

In the present day, the story moves to London. A string of mysterious suicides and unexplained phenomena pull a government investigator and a group of friends into a mystery of extraterrestrial origin. The friends are called the “Oxford Five.” The show uses them as the audience’s way in, and mostly that works.

Jovan Adepo plays Saul Durand. Eiza González is Auggie Salazar. Jess Hong is Jin Cheng. Alex Sharp is Will Downing. Saamer Usmani is Raj Varma. That is a lot of names to establish, and the season spends real time on each of them. The ensemble is the show’s best asset and, at moments, its biggest problem.

Benedict Wong plays Detective Clarence “Da” Shi. He is the government investigator on the case, and he gives the London thread its gravity. Wong is very good at playing a man who has seen enough to stop being surprised and not enough to stop being careful. Liam Cunningham is Thomas Wade, and Marlo Kelly is Tatiana Haas. Sea Shimooka plays Sophon. Lan Xiya also appears.

What Benioff, Weiss and Woo Actually Built

The series is ambitious in a way that television rarely attempts. It spans continents and decades. It puts a physics problem at the center of its title and expects viewers to follow. The title comes from the first volume of Liu’s series, The Three-Body Problem, named after a classical physics problem dealing with Newton’s laws of motion and gravitation.

That is a lot of intellectual furniture for a Netflix drama. The show does not dumb it down. It also does not always dramatize it. There are stretches where characters explain the science to each other, and the scenes are well-acted but static. The production values hold up throughout, and the scale is real rather than implied.

Where the show is strongest is in the collision between the personal and the cosmic. Ye Wenjie’s decision is not abstract. It comes from grief and from a specific historical crime. The present-day characters are dealing with the consequences of something they did not do, which is the right shape for this story.

The series centers on a diverse group of characters, mainly scientists, who encounter an extraterrestrial civilization, triggering numerous threats and profound changes for humanity.

The Cast Is the Reason to Stay

Adepo is the standout among the younger cast. Saul Durand could be a passive role, and Adepo keeps him from going slack. González has the harder job, playing a character whose arc bends toward dread, and she holds it. Hong gives Jin Cheng a sharpness that the script needs.

Sharp’s Will Downing is the emotional center of the back half, and the show earns that. Cunningham is doing a version of the hard-edged official he has played before, but he does it well. Wong is the most purely watchable presence in the London scenes.

The show’s weakness is that it has too many people to serve. With eight episodes, some of the Oxford Five get less room than they need. The season resolves enough to feel complete, but the show is clearly built as the first chapter of something larger.

The Reviews and the Renewal

3 Body Problem received positive reviews, with praise for its cast, ambition, and production values. It earned six Primetime Emmy Award nominations, including Outstanding Drama Series. That is a real signal. Genre shows rarely get that kind of recognition, and the nomination for Outstanding Drama Series puts it in the top tier of the year’s television.

In May 2024, Netflix renewed the series for a second and third season. The second season is set to premiere in 2026. That is a vote of confidence in a show that is not cheap and not simple. It also means the story is being told on the schedule the creators want, rather than being compressed.

The second season will add Claudia Doumit, Ellie de Lange, Alfie Allen, David Yip, and Jordan Sunshine. Casting news that early suggests the production is moving. It also suggests the show is expanding rather than narrowing.

Where the Season Lands

The first season is a strong adaptation and an imperfect one. It carries the weight of Liu’s ideas without flinching, and it makes the Cultural Revolution sections feel like the foundation of the story rather than a prologue. The choice to move the present-day action to the United Kingdom gives the show a different texture than the earlier Mandarin adaptations, and that is mostly to its credit.

The problems are structural. Eight episodes is not enough for this many characters and this much exposition. Some scenes exist to move information rather than to move people. The show is at its best when it trusts its actors to carry a moment without explanation, and at its weakest when it does not.

Still, the ambition is the point. This is a series that asks its audience to think about physics, history, and extinction in the same hour, and it mostly earns the ask. Benioff and Weiss have made a show that is more interested in consequences than in spectacle, which is the right call for this material.

The Emmy nominations and the two-season renewal are not accidents. Netflix has a show that critics took seriously and that has a clear path forward. The second season will be the test. If the show can keep its characters in focus as the scale grows, it will be one of the better science fiction series of the decade. If it loses them, the ideas will not be enough on their own.

What matters most in this first season is Ye Wenjie. Rosalind Chao’s performance is the thing the show will be remembered for, and the choice her character makes is the engine of everything that follows. The Oxford Five are the show’s present. Ye Wenjie is its cause. The series understands that, and it builds toward it.

The production values are high, the cast is deep, and the writing is more disciplined than the premise suggests. What holds it back is the same thing that holds back most first seasons of this size: too much to set up, and not quite enough time to let it breathe. The renewal solves that problem going forward. For now, 3 Body Problem is a confident, intelligent start with room to grow.

The Notebook

Get the Notebook.

The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.

We send one note to confirm. Every issue has a one-click way out.

Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

As an Amazon Associate, Clay Tribune earns from qualifying purchases.