Apple TV has renewed Imperfect Women for a second season, but the renewal comes with a catch: two of the show’s three leads are gone. Kerry Washington will return as Eleanor, but Elisabeth Moss is stepping away from the screen and Mara’s Nancy died at the end of the first season.
The news lands as a relief and a question at once. Washington’s return is the headline, and it is good news for anyone who liked her work as Eleanor. Moss’s exit is a loss, but the show is still in good hands with Washington leading the new story. Mara’s absence is the open question, because Nancy’s death leaves her character’s future unclear.
What the First Season Did
The first season of Imperfect Women followed the murder of a woman named Nancy, played by Kate Mara. Her two longtime friends, Eleanor and Mary, were played by Kerry Washington and Elisabeth Moss. As the season unfolded, secrets about the three women emerged.
The show was based on a book of the same name by Araminta Hall. It was a psychological thriller that kept viewers guessing until the final reveal. Now the series has been renewed, and the renewal comes with a significant change to the cast.
Washington Returns, Moss Steps Back
Washington will lead the second season as Eleanor. That is the good news. She reprised her role in the renewal announcement, and the show will follow an original story by co-showrunners Annie Weisman and Justin Hillian.
Moss will not be returning as Mary. Instead, she will be back behind the scenes as an executive producer. That is a notable shift. Moss was a major presence in the first season, and her departure from the screen changes the shape of the story. But her involvement as a producer means she will still have a hand in the creative process.
Mara’s Nancy Dies Without a Clear Plan
There is no indication that Mara will be involved in the new season, either on-screen or otherwise. Her character died at the end of the first season, but that has not stopped shows from bringing actors back when they want to. This time, there is no clear plan for Nancy’s return.
The comparison is worth making:
| Character | Season 1 Role | Season 2 Status |
|---|---|---|
| Eleanor (Kerry Washington) | Lead role | Returns as lead |
| Mary (Elisabeth Moss) | Lead role | Executive producer only |
| Nancy (Kate Mara) | Lead role | Dead; no indication of involvement |
The table shows how the renewal splits the trio. Washington keeps her lead role. Moss moves behind the scenes. Mara loses hers entirely.
Here is what the renewal means for each of the three leads:
- Washington returns as Eleanor, leading the new story.
- Moss steps back from the screen but stays on as an executive producer.
- Mara’s Nancy dies without a clear plan for her return.
What the Renewal Means for Fans
The renewal is a vote of confidence in the show. Apple TV saw enough interest in the first season to order more. The fact that the renewal comes with changes to the cast suggests the show is moving forward rather than doubling down on the same story.
Washington’s return is the anchor. Moss’s move to producer is a loss for the screen, but it keeps her connected to the project creatively. Mara’s Nancy dying without a clear plan is the open question.
Fans who fell in love with Nancy will likely wonder whether she can come back somehow. There is no clear plan for Nancy’s return. Shows have brought dead characters back before, but this renewal does not hint at a resurrection. Nancy’s story ends where the first season ended.
The renewal also raises questions about the direction of the show. The first season was a complete story with a killer revealed. The second season will need to stand on its own.
The Bottom Line
The renewal is a mixed bag, but the mix leans positive. Washington’s return is the headline, and it is a good one. Moss stepping back as a producer is a loss, but her continued involvement means the show will still benefit from her input. Mara’s Nancy dying without a clear plan is the open question, but it is the honest part.
The show has a solid foundation in Washington. It has a creative force in Moss behind the scenes. It has a dead character whose fate remains unresolved. That is a combination that fans will watch closely.
The renewal is a vote of confidence in the show. It is also a signal that the show is moving forward with a new story. Washington is the lead, and that is the most important fact here.
See the video the story is built around at The A.V. Club.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.