Robert Zemeckis built a career on pushing animation into new territory, and A Christmas Carol is where that push stopped paying off. The 2009 film, released by Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, is the fourth such motion-capture feature from ImageMovers, after The Polar Express (2004), Monster House (2006) and Beowulf (2007). It is also the first project from ImageMovers Digital — and one of only two the studio ever finished before Disney shut it down over poor box-office results.
Trailer, via Rotten Tomatoes Classic Trailers.
Jim Carrey Plays Scrooge and Every Ghost
Carrey takes the lead as Ebenezer Scrooge, the penny-pinching miser who despises Christmas. He also voices all three spirits: the Ghost of Christmas Past, an androgynous figure with a flickering flame for a head who speaks with an Irish accent; the Ghost of Christmas Present, a towering red-haired man in a green ermine robe with a Yorkshire accent; and the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come, rendered as a hooded shadow.
Gary Oldman does triple duty as Bob Cratchit, Jacob Marley, and the motion-capture for Tiny Tim. Colin Firth plays Fred, Scrooge’s cheerful nephew. Robin Wright Penn is Belle, the fiancée Scrooge neglected, and provides motion-capture for Fan, his late sister. Bob Hoskins plays both the benevolent Mr. Fezziwig and Old Joe, the fence who buys the dead Scrooge’s belongings. Cary Elwes and Fionnula Flanagan fill out the rest.
That is a serious cast. The film rarely lets them act.
A Story You Already Know, Told at Length
The plot follows Dickens closely enough. Marley dies on Christmas Eve 1836. Seven years later, Scrooge refuses Fred’s dinner invitation, dismisses two gentlemen collecting for the poor, and grudgingly gives Cratchit Christmas Day off. Marley’s ghost arrives in chains, warning that three spirits will visit.
The Ghost of Christmas Past shows Scrooge’s lonely boarding school days, his apprenticeship under Fezziwig, and how his hunger for wealth drove Belle away. The Ghost of Christmas Present shows Bob’s family content with a meagre dinner, and Tiny Tim, who may not live to see another Christmas. Fred’s guests toast Scrooge anyway. Before that Ghost dies, he shows Scrooge the evils of “Ignorance” and “Want.” The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come shows a hypothetical future.
Every beat lands where you expect it. The film runs 96 minutes and feels longer, because motion-capture spectacle keeps interrupting a story that works best when it is small.
The Motion-Capture Problem
Zemeckis animated the film through motion-capture, the same technique behind The Polar Express, Monster House, and Beowulf. Alan Silvestri returned to compose the score, as he had on Zemeckis’s previous films.
The technique is the whole argument here. Carrey’s Scrooge has weight and movement, but the face stays waxy, caught between performance and puppet. Oldman’s Cratchit suffers most — a warm, underpaid clerk rendered as a smooth mask. When the Ghost of Christmas Present laughs, you see the rig, not the joy.
The 3D formats Disney pushed, including IMAX 3D, made this worse. The film premiered in London on November 3, 2009, timed to the switching-on of the Oxford Street and Regent Street Christmas lights, then opened in the United States on November 6. It was built to be an event. It plays like a demo reel.
Here is the release schedule, for anyone mapping the rollout:
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| November 3, 2009 | World premiere, London |
| November 6, 2009 | US release, Disney Digital 3D, RealD 3D, IMAX 3D |
What the Film Gets Right
Not everything fails. The Ghost of Christmas Past design — candle body, flame head — is the one image that sticks. The Ignorance and Want sequence, shown by the dying Ghost of Christmas Present, carries real dread. Hoskins’s Fezziwig brings the only unforced warmth in the movie.
And the source material is durable. Dickens’s structure survives even this treatment: the miser, the wasted youth, the cruel present, the fate awaiting him. The tagline promises that “It only takes one night to change your life.” The film takes 96 minutes and rarely earns that night.
Where It Leaves Dickens
A Christmas Carol is Disney’s third adaptation of the novel, after Mickey’s Christmas Carol in 1983 and The Muppet Christmas Carol in 1992. Those films understood something this one forgets: the story is about people, not technology. The 1992 version had puppets and more soul than this.
The motion-capture experiment here is the real subject, and it is a dead end. ImageMovers Digital produced this film and Mars Needs Moms, then Disney closed the studio over poor box-office results. The film itself was a box office disappointment. That outcome is not surprising. Zemeckis spent a decade chasing a format that made actors less expressive, not more, and A Christmas Carol is the clearest evidence.
Carrey and Oldman are doing real work under all that rendering. You just cannot see it. The film is faithful, expensive, and cold — a faithful adaptation with no pulse.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
