Joni Mitchell’s Taming the Tiger is a quiet record that asks for your full attention. Released in 1998, it is not a statement of reinvention, nor a return to the confessional folk of her youth. It is a mature, often slyly upbeat set of songs that trades grand gestures for intricate detail. The album is built on subtlety — its melodies unfold slowly, its lyrics reward patience, and its best moments arrive without fanfare. This is Mitchell surveying her own life, her craft, and her place in the world, and doing so with a lightness that can be deceptive.
Harlem in Havana Opens the Door
The record opens with “Harlem in Havana,” a track that immediately sets a distinct mood. It is a travelogue of sound, mixing jazz textures with a Latin undercurrent. The song is the album’s most immediate pleasure, with a melody that moves like a stroll through a crowded street. It is not a rock song, nor a pop song, but something that exists in its own geography.
Man From Mars and the Early Ballads
“Man From Mars” offers a different shade of whimsy. It is a love song, but one filtered through a strange, almost playful lens. The lyrics are a mix of the cosmic and the mundane, and the arrangement keeps the listener off-balance.
“Love Puts on a New Face” is more direct, a ballad that finds Mitchell in a reflective mood. The melody is gentle, and the production is sparse, allowing her phrasing to carry the weight. These early tracks establish a pattern: the album is not in a hurry to impress you. It prefers to seep in gradually.
Lead Balloon Stumbles
“Lead Balloon” is the album’s most overt attempt at a heavier sound, and it is the record’s weakest moment. The track tries to build a rock groove, but the production feels stiff, and the song never quite takes off. It is not a disaster, but it lacks the fluidity that makes the surrounding material work.
“No Apologies” recovers some of that ground. It is a more straightforward composition, with a clear verse-chorus structure. The song’s title suggests a certain defiance, but the performance is warm rather than combative. It is a solid, if not spectacular, entry that keeps the album moving.
The Title Track and the Second Half
“Taming the Tiger” sits later in the running order, after “No Apologies.” It is a meditative piece, built on a repeating piano figure that feels like a mantra. Mitchell’s voice is low and conversational, and the song’s power comes from its restraint rather than any climactic release.
The second half of the record is where its strengths become more apparent. “The Crazy Cries of Love” is a standout, with a melody that feels both familiar and surprising. The song has a propulsive quality, driven by a bass line that gives it a sense of momentum. It is one of the few tracks here that feels like it could fill a room.
“Stay in Touch” is shorter and more direct, a concise statement about connection and distance. Its brevity works in its favor; it makes its point and moves on without overstaying its welcome.
Face Lift and the Final Tracks
“Face Lift” is a wry meditation on aging and vanity, and Mitchell delivers the lyrics with a knowing wit. The song is not a joke, but it has a lightness that prevents it from becoming maudlin.
“My Best to You” is a tender closer of sorts, a song that feels like a benediction. It is simple, almost folk-like in its construction, and it carries a genuine warmth.
The album’s final track, “Tiger Bones,” is a more complex piece. It returns to the title’s imagery, but the mood is darker and more searching. The arrangement is intricate, with shifting rhythms and a sense of unease beneath the surface.
This album is a mystical journey into the current life of one of rock’s most enduring songwriters.
The Production and the Playing
The production throughout Taming the Tiger is clean and precise. The musicianship is high-level, with each player given room to contribute without overwhelming the songs. Mitchell’s guitar work is particularly notable; she plays with a fluid, finger-picked style that anchors the record.
Her voice has deepened over the years, and she uses its lower register to great effect, giving the lyrics a conversational intimacy. This is not the soaring soprano of her early records, but a more weathered instrument that suits the material.
The Record’s Core Strengths
The album’s greatest strength is its consistency of mood. It creates a world and stays in it. The songs are linked by a shared sensibility, a sense of quiet observation. This is also its limitation. There is no single track that leaps out as an immediate classic. The record is designed to be absorbed as a whole, and it rewards repeated listens.
The one clear misstep is “Lead Balloon,” which feels out of place. Its attempt at a rockier edge is unconvincing, and it interrupts the flow of the album. The rest of the material is more successful because it trusts its own quiet power.
The songs that work best are the ones that lean into the album’s core aesthetic:
- “Harlem in Havana,” which opens the record with its most inviting melody
- “The Crazy Cries of Love,” which brings a welcome rhythmic energy
- “Stay in Touch,” a concise and affecting piece
- “My Best to You,” which closes the album with warmth
- “Tiger Bones,” which ends on a more complex, searching note
These tracks show Mitchell working at a high level, crafting songs that are subtle but far from slight. The album’s weaker moments are not failures of ambition, but of execution. When Mitchell stays in her lane — the intimate, the observational, the gently melodic — she is compelling. When she reaches for something harder, the record loses some of its footing.
A Record That Rewards Patience
Taming the Tiger is not an album that announces itself. It is a record for a specific mood, a quiet evening, a focused listen. It is the work of an artist who has nothing left to prove and is content to explore her own interests. The songwriting is strong throughout, and the performances are assured. The lack of a standout single is a real drawback; the album could use one song that grabs the listener by the collar. But as a cohesive work, it is a success.
The record’s title suggests a struggle, but the music itself feels resolved. There is a sense of peace in these songs, an acceptance of complexity and contradiction. Mitchell is not trying to tame anything here; she is simply observing, and her observations are sharp and often lovely. Music-Critic.com called the album a mystical journey, but it is a journey taken at a walking pace.
The verdict is that Taming the Tiger is a strong, mature work from an artist who remains fully in control of her craft. It is not her most essential record, and it lacks the immediate hooks of her classic era, but it is a rewarding listen that improves with familiarity. The musicianship is impeccable, the lyrics are thoughtful, and the overall mood is one of hard-won contentment. It is a record that knows itself, and that knowledge gives it a quiet authority.
For a listener willing to meet it on its own terms, Taming the Tiger offers a rich and subtle experience. It is a solid addition to a legendary career, and it stands as proof that Mitchell’s instincts remained sharp well into her later period. The album gets a 7 out of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
- Harlem in Havana4:27
- Man From Mars4:10
- Love Puts on a New Face3:46
- Lead Balloon3:38
- No Apologies4:17
- Taming the Tiger4:18
- The Crazy Cries of Love3:55
- Stay in Touch2:59
- Face Lift4:42
- My Best to You3:42
- Tiger Bones4:24
