Alex Proyas has a gift for making dread feel architectural. In Knowing, the director of Dark City turns a Boston-area elementary school into ground zero for a countdown, and for a while the machinery hums.
Trailer, via YouTube Movies.
The Time Capsule in Lexington
In October 1959, a Lexington elementary school buries a time capsule. Students draw what they think the future holds. Lucinda Embry fills her page with numbers instead, guided by whispering voices, until her teacher Miss Taylor takes the paper away. Lucinda scratches the last digits into a closet door with her fingernails.
Fifty years later, the capsule is dug up. The paper lands with Caleb Koestler, 9, whose father is John Koestler, a widowed MIT astrophysics professor played by Nicolas Cage.
What the Numbers Predict
John cracks the code. Lucinda’s numbers are dates, death tolls and geographical coordinates for disasters across 50 years: the Oklahoma City bombing, the September 11 attacks, Hurricane Katrina. Three entries are still ahead.
He visits Miss Taylor, now lost to Alzheimer’s, who tells him about the scratching on the door. The next day he watches a plane crash kill 81 people. That is the first future event on the list.
Two Disasters, One Widower
The film’s grip tightens here. Caleb starts hearing the same whispering voices that guided Lucinda. John tracks down Lucinda’s daughter Diana, played by Rose Byrne, and her granddaughter Abby in New York, then witnesses a train derailment caused by a faulty siding.
| Element | Detail |
|---|---|
| Director | Alex Proyas |
| Writer | Ryne Douglas Pearson, with Juliet Snowden and Stiles White |
| Lead | Nicolas Cage as John Koestler |
| Runtime | 121 minutes |
| Release | March 20, 2009 |
What happens when the numbers run out?
The Chariot in the Mobile Home
Diana and John drive to Lucinda’s abandoned mobile home. They find a copy of Matthäus Merian’s engraving of Ezekiel’s chariot vision, with a great Sun at its center.
Ben Mendelsohn appears as Phil Bergman. Chandler Canterbury plays Caleb. Lara Robinson carries the dual role of Lucinda Embry and Abby Wayland.
Where the Film Loses Its Nerve
The production history is tidy: conceived by Pearson, attached to directors at Columbia Pictures, placed in turnaround, picked up by Escape Artists, backed financially by Summit Entertainment, shot at Docklands Studios Melbourne standing in for the film’s Boston-area setting.
The film grossed $186.5 million worldwide plus $27.7 million in home video sales against a $50 million budget. Money was never the problem.
The problem is that Knowing stacks its disasters like dominoes and then asks a widowed astrophysicist to stop the last one. Proyas has an eye for the terrible image — the plane, the train, the fingernails on the door — but the script keeps reaching for a grand design it cannot support.
A Countdown Without a Payoff
The cast holds. Cage plays grief as exhaustion rather than theatrics. Byrne gives Diana a hardness the part needs. Mendelsohn is wasted, and that is a real loss.
What sinks Knowing is the ending. The film spends 121 minutes insisting the numbers mean something, then treats meaning as optional. The implausibilities pile up faster than the death tolls.
This is a thriller that mistakes scale for weight. The whispering voices, the Merian engraving, the scratched door — fine pieces, assembled into a machine that never quite fires.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
