WRITTEN IN PLAIN AMERICAN ENGLISH.
About
CLAY TRIBUNE.
Advertisement

Mr. & Mrs. Smith Review: Pitt and Jolie Carry a Premise Too Big to Believe

A married pair of assassins, each unaware of the other's true calling, discover a deadly secret in this tale of love and betrayal.

By mitch·4 min read
A man and woman dressed as assassins stand facing opposite directions in a dimly lit street.

Mr. & Mrs. Smith opens with a lie. Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie play John and Jane Smith, a married couple who both happen to be professional assassins. The film knows this from the start, and it spends most of its runtime trying to make that lie feel like the biggest twist in town.

It does not quite pull it off.

Trailer, via FilmTrailersChannel.

Advertisement

The Premise That Should Work

The setup is pure setup. John and Jane live a normal suburban life, with kids, pets and dinner parties. They do not know each other’s true jobs. Then the agency that hired them both decides to eliminate the competition, and the chase begins. The premise is clever, the kind of pitch that gets a movie greenlit before anyone figures out what happens next.

It also sets up a problem the film never fully solves.

Pitt and Jolie Carry It

Pitt and Jolie are the reason this works at all. Their chemistry is real, and the film leans on it heavily. The scenes where they fight, argue and finally admit the truth to each other land better than most of the action sequences. The film understands that the marriage is the story, even when the bullets are flying.

Their shared history as assassins gives the relationship weight. They know danger. They know secrets. The film trusts that connection enough to let the plot slow down when the script demands it.

The Action Flaws

The action scenes are the weakest part. Cars explode, buildings crumble and gunfire fills the frame, but the editing is rushed and the choreography is generic. The film wants to be a summer blockbuster, but it never commits to the spectacle. The set pieces feel like filler between the moments where Pitt and Jolie talk.

Some scenes work better than others. The hotel fight sequence, where the two leads face off against their employers, has real tension. Others, like the rooftop chase near the end, feel like they were designed to fill time rather than build suspense.

The Lies Behind the Lie

The film’s biggest problem is its own premise. John and Jane have been married for years, and neither of them knew what the other did for a living. That is a lie so large it strains credibility. The film asks us to accept that two people who share everything could miss the single most important fact about each other’s lives.

The film never explains why this happened. There is no backstory, no explanation, no reason given for the deception. We are simply meant to believe that two professional killers stayed together without ever finding out what the other did. That is a hard pill to swallow.

The Romance That Saves It

The romance is the film’s saving grace. John and Jane fall in love again after they meet as assassins. The film leans into the idea that their shared danger made them stronger together. It is a tired trope, but Pitt and Jolie sell it.

The film’s final act returns to the central question: can a marriage survive the truth? The answer is yes, but only because the film has spent so long building the case that this particular marriage deserves to.

A Tale of Two Leads

Brad Pitt Angelina Jolie
Role John Smith Jane Smith
Strength Physical comedy Emotional depth
Weakness Over-the-top action Underused action

The table shows how the film splits the load. Pitt plays John as the more physical threat, while Jolie plays Jane as the emotional core. The film leans on both strengths to balance the weaknesses.

What Works

  • The chemistry between Pitt and Jolie
  • The hotel fight scene
  • The rooftop chase near the end
  • The return to the marriage at the finale

What does not work:

  • The rushed editing in action scenes
  • The lack of a credible explanation for the deception
  • The filler set pieces that pad the runtime

A Solid, Not Great, Summer Movie

Mr. & Mrs. Smith is a solid summer movie, not a great one. The premise is clever, the performances are strong and the romance lands. But the action drags, the lies strain credibility and the plot never earns the twists it announces.

It is a film that understands its stars better than its own plot. Pitt and Jolie make the story work despite the flaws, and that is worth something.

Film reviews
Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *