Mulholland Drive opens as a dream, a young woman waking in Los Angeles with amnesia and a Hollywood address she doesn’t recognize. The film’s first hour is pure pleasure, a noir romance with a blonde star named Betty and a dark-haired girl named Rita who can’t remember her own name. The second hour shatters that pleasure into pieces, revealing the earlier scenes as a fiction constructed by a broken actress named Diane. The film asks viewers to hold both versions in mind at once, and the shift is as cruel as it is brilliant.
David Lynch directs with a precision that matches his reputation for chaos. The first half moves at a steady pace, building a bond between Betty and Rita that feels genuine even as the plot grows stranger. The Winkie Donuts scene, a surreal sequence where Betty sings a torch song to a waitress, is pure Lynch: absurd, tender, and utterly unforgettable. The film’s technical craft is impeccable, from the neon-lit streets of Hollywood to the shadowy apartments where Rita hides. The score, composed by Angelo Badalamenti, drifts through the film like a ghost, shifting from romantic ballad to unsettling drone without warning.
Trailer, via StudiocanalUK.
Diane’s Story
The second half of Mulholland Drive is where the film earns its reputation for cruelty. The truth turns out to be worse than the fantasy. Diane, a failed actress played by Naomi Watts, has created the world of Betty and Rita as a way to cope with failure. The film’s final stretch is a slow, brutal reveal, showing Diane’s descent into despair and the people she hurt along the way. This section is not easy viewing. It demands patience and trust in the filmmaker, and some viewers will find the payoff hollow compared to the warmth of the first hour.
Naomi Watts carries the weight of both halves. She plays Betty as wide-eyed and hopeful, then transforms into Diane as bitter and exhausted. Laura Harring, as Rita, is less given to change, and her performance relies on presence rather than speech. Both actors deliver the film’s central mystery with restraint, never overplaying the confusion that drives the plot forward.
The Dream Sequence
Mulholland Drive is built around a single lie, and the film spends its entire runtime exposing it. The opening hour is a dream, a wish fulfillment constructed by Diane to escape her own life. When the film finally breaks the illusion, it does so with a suddenness that feels earned rather than cheap. The revelation lands because the setup was so carefully constructed, and the audience has spent an hour trusting a version of events that the film itself tells us is false.
The film’s central question — what is real? — is not answered cleanly. The ending suggests a resolution, but the ambiguity leaves room for interpretation. Some viewers will find this frustrating; others will find it freeing. The film trusts its audience to hold two contradictory truths in their head at once, and that trust is part of what makes the experience rewarding.
The Final Stretch
The last twenty minutes of Mulholland Drive are a masterclass in tension. Diane’s confrontation with her friend Camilla, played by Ann Sward, is a slow-motion disaster that builds to a climax that feels inevitable. The film’s final image, a man driving along Mulholland Drive, is a return to the film’s title, but the meaning shifts depending on which version of the story you believe. The ambiguity is deliberate, and it rewards careful attention.
The film’s themes are as dark as its visual style. It explores the cost of fame, the loneliness of ambition, and the way people shape themselves to fit the roles society expects. The characters are not saints, and the film does not pretend otherwise. Diane’s manipulation of Rita is cruel, but the film also shows the desperation that drove her to it. The result is a portrait of Hollywood that is both seductive and terrifying.
Key Facts
- Title: Mulholland Drive
- Director: David Lynch
- Year: 2001
- Runtime: 146 minutes
- Score: 8.7/10
Mulholland Drive is a film that rewards multiple viewings. Each watch reveals new details, new connections, new ways of understanding the story. The film’s refusal to explain everything is not a flaw; it is a strength. It trusts the audience to fill in the gaps, and that trust creates a relationship between viewer and screen that few films achieve.
The film is not for everyone. Its dark turn in the second half will repel some viewers, and the ending may feel unsatisfying to those who want closure. But for those willing to engage with its complexity, Mulholland Drive offers a rare experience: a film that is both deeply entertaining and deeply disturbing, often within the same shot. It is a masterpiece of genre-bending, and it holds up as one of the best films of its decade.
8.7 of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
