Nancy Drew is a mystery series that never quite settles on what kind of mystery it wants to be. The CW’s adaptation of the classic books follows a young woman trying to leave her small town, only to get pulled into a supernatural murder investigation instead. That premise sounds like a winning hand: a clever protagonist, a spooky setup, and a network built for teen dramas. What arrives is a show that struggles to balance its tone, often spending whole episodes on mundane domestic drama before remembering it promised something supernatural.
The series premiered on October 9, 2019, with Kennedy McMann playing the title character. It ran for four seasons across 62 episodes, ending its run on August 23, 2023. Created by Noga Landau, Stephanie Savage, and Josh Schwartz, the show was produced by CBS Studios in association with Fake Empire. It is the third Nancy Drew television series, coming after The Hardy Boys/Nancy Drew Mysteries (1977–1979) and a 1995 Canadian-American version.
Trailer, via TV Promos.
The Town of Horseshoe Bay
The show is set in Horseshoe Bay, a small coastal town where everyone knows everyone else’s business. Nancy Drew is eighteen years old and working at the Claw, a local restaurant. She has put off applying to Columbia University to deal with the loss of her mother, and the show opens with her getting entangled in the investigation of Tiffany Hudson’s murder.
Tiffany Hudson is a town socialite, and her death sets the entire story in motion. Nancy and her coworkers — prickly manager George Fan, worldly waitress Bess Marvin, laidback dishwasher Ace, and mechanic Ned “Nick” Nickerson, who Nancy is having a no-strings-attached fling with — reluctantly ally to clear their names of suspicion. The show keeps returning to the idea that these characters have secrets they want to keep hidden, and Nancy is determined to uncover them.
“She unearths a connection to Tiffany’s homicide to a decade-long cold case turned urban legend.”
That line captures the show’s core promise: a decades-old mystery tied to the present-day murder. The problem is that the show spends far more time on the present-day characters’ personal conflicts than it does on the actual case. The supernatural elements exist mostly as a backdrop, and the show leans heavily on the relationships between Nancy and her friends to carry the weight of each episode.
The Ensemble Cast
The ensemble cast is the show’s strongest asset. Kennedy McMann plays Nancy Drew with a confident energy that grounds the show’s more outlandish moments. Leah Lewis brings a sharp wit to George Fan, and Maddison Jaizani gives Bess Marvin a warmth that balances the pricklier edges of the group. Tunji Kasim plays Ned “Nick” Nickerson as a laidback mechanic who is genuinely funny, and Alex Saxon brings a quiet presence to Ace, the dishwasher who becomes Nancy’s closest friend.
Scott Wolf plays Nancy’s father, Carson Drew, with a restrained dignity that fits the show’s tone. He is a wealthy lawyer who supports his daughter’s investigations while remaining somewhat distant from her personal life. The show also introduces new characters like Ryan Hudson, played by Riley Smith, who adds a romantic complication to Nancy’s life.
The show also includes Alvina August as a new character, though her role is less developed than the main cast members. The show’s creators reimagined the characters from the books for this version, and the ensemble chemistry is strong enough to carry the show through its weaker stretches.
The Supernatural Case
The supernatural elements are where the show stumbles. The premise promises a mystery tied to a decade-long cold case turned urban legend, but the show rarely delivers on that promise. Instead, it spends most of its runtime on Nancy’s relationship with Nick, her friendship with Bess and George, and her job at the Claw.
When the show does dip into the supernatural, it often feels tacked-on rather than woven into the fabric of the story. The mystery is there, but it is buried under layers of teenage angst and workplace drama. The result is a show that feels episodic and incomplete, with the central case feeling like a loose collection of clues rather than a tightly constructed puzzle.
The show’s best episodes are the ones that lean into the mystery. When Nancy is tracking down a lead or piecing together a clue, the show can be genuinely engaging. Those moments are few and far between, however, and they are often overshadowed by the show’s focus on its characters’ personal lives.
The Spinoff and Final Season
The show spawned a spinoff, Tom Swift, which premiered in 2022 on the CW and ran for one season. That spinoff followed a new character from the original series, though details about its plot and reception are limited.
The show’s fourth and final season premiered on May 31, 2023. The series finale aired on August 23, 2023, bringing the show’s run to a close. The final season attempted to wrap up the central mystery, but the show’s episodic nature made it difficult to resolve everything cleanly. The finale felt rushed, tying up some threads while leaving others dangling.
The show’s development history is notable. CBS ordered a television pilot in 2015, but later passed on the project. It was then redeveloped for NBC until 2018, when the project moved to the CW, where the series was ordered for a pilot. The show received a series order in May 2019.
The Verdict
Nancy Drew is a show with a good idea and a weak execution. The characters are engaging, the setting is atmospheric, and the premise is promising. But the show never commits fully to its supernatural elements, and the mystery is underdeveloped compared to the show’s other strands.
The show is at its best when it focuses on Nancy’s sleuthing. Those moments are sharp, tense, and genuinely engaging. The show is at its worst when it devotes an entire episode to a character’s romantic struggle or a workplace conflict. Those episodes feel like filler, diluting the show’s central promise.
| Element | Strength | Weakness |
|---|---|---|
| Characters | Engaging ensemble | Overreliance on personal drama |
| Premise | Promising supernatural mystery | Underdeveloped central case |
| Tone | Atmospheric small-town setting | Inconsistent genre balance |
| Execution | Sharp sleuthing moments | Rushed finale |
The show’s final season tried to tie everything together, but the pacing issues that plagued earlier episodes followed it to the end. The finale felt rushed, tying up some threads while leaving others unresolved. The show ended with a whimper rather than a bang.
Nancy Drew is a show worth watching for its characters and its occasional moments of genuine mystery. But it is a show that fails to live up to its own premise. The supernatural elements that drew viewers in are underdeveloped, and the show’s episodic nature means the central mystery never feels resolved.
The show is a mixed bag, and its strengths are real even as its weaknesses are significant. It is a show that is fun to watch in short bursts but frustrating over long stretches. It is a show that is worth your time if you are interested in the characters, but it is not a show that rewards binge-watching.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
