Princess Peach has spent most of her time as the prize at the end of someone else’s level. In Princess Peach: Showtime!, Nintendo finally hands her the keys to the theater. The result is a game that understands exactly how charming its star can be, and never quite figures out what to do with her.
Good-Feel developed Princess Peach: Showtime! and Nintendo published it for the Nintendo Switch on March 22, 2024. It is the first game to put Peach in the lead role since Super Princess Peach in 2005. That nineteen-year gap is the whole story of the character in one number.
The setup is a flyer. One of Peach’s Toads picks up an advertisement for plays at the Sparkle Theater, and Peach decides to attend with two Toads in tow. They arrive, and the wicked sorceress Grape and her henchmen, the Sour Bunch, storm the building. The audience and performers are trapped inside. Peach loses her crown in the commotion.
That detail matters more than it looks. Stripped of the crown, Peach meets Stella, the theater’s guardian, and agrees to help take the building back. She is not a princess here. She is a performer who has to earn the stage.
Trailer, via Nintendo of America.
Stella, the Sentient Ribbon
The core hook is Stella. The player controls Peach, and Stella is a sentient ribbon who lets her interact with objects and characters. Stand on a circular platform and Peach takes on an ability suited to that play’s setting.
It is a clean, legible system. The circular platforms read instantly. Stella is a constant companion who talks, points and pulls. Good-Feel built a side-view action game around a stage metaphor, and the metaphor holds up because the mechanics are literal: you step onto the mark, the spotlight finds you, and you become someone else.
Peach’s transformations are the whole game. Here is the full roster:
- Swordfighter Peach
- Patissiere Peach
- Ninja Peach
- Cowgirl Peach
- Figure Skater Peach
- Detective Peach
- Dashing Thief Peach
- Mighty Peach
- Mermaid Peach
- Kung Fu Peach
Ten roles, each with unique abilities. Swordfighter Peach fences the Sour Bunch. Detective Peach puts on a hat to solve a whodunnit in a museum. Patissiere Peach works a kitchen. Kung Fu Peach fights. The spread from swordplay to pastry is the game’s best joke and its best argument: Peach can be anything, and the game is not embarrassed about it.
Five Hearts and a Heart Charm
Peach’s health is measured in five hearts. An optional power-up called the Heart Charm grants three additional hearts for an easier difficulty. That is the entire difficulty conversation: a toggle that makes the game softer, available to anyone who wants it.
Good-Feel also hides collectibles. Rescue a Theet named Ribboner in each level, clear a “Rehearsal” challenge, or spend Sparkle Gems, the game’s currency, and you unlock skins called Ribbons for Peach and Stella. It is a familiar loop, dressed in theater velvet.
The structure is single-player, side-view, and split between hack-and-slash combat and adventure. Each play is a self-contained set piece. You learn a role, you use it, you move to the next stage.
Grape Takes the Sparkle Theater
The plot runs on a simple engine. Peach and Stella move through the theater’s plays to rescue the Sparklas, the stars of each production, from the Sour Bunch. Every rescued Sparkla is a step back toward the building’s rightful owners.
When all the Sparklas are free, Peach takes the form of Radiant Peach and confronts Grape on the theater’s bottom floor. Grape is reduced to nothing more than her mask. Then she regains power, transforms into a giant version of herself, and destroys the theater.
That is the game’s sharpest turn. The villain does not lose when she is beaten. She loses, then gets up bigger, and the building comes down anyway. Peach and Stella fight on with support from the Theets, defeat Grape, and restore the theater. In the credits, Peach performs with the Sparklas and reunites with the Toads, who give her crown back.
She gets the crown back after the show, not before it. The game knows the difference.
What the Ten Roles Actually Deliver
Here is where Princess Peach: Showtime! starts to wobble. Ten transformations is a generous number. It is also a promise the game struggles to keep.
Each role arrives with a distinct look, a distinct verb and a distinct set of animations. The problem is repetition. A role that is fun for two minutes is asked to carry a full play, and the plays do not escalate enough to justify the length. The swordfighter swings. The ninja sneaks. The figure skater glides. You will do each of these things more times than the idea supports.
The difficulty is the other half of that problem. Five hearts, plus three more if you equip the Heart Charm, is a lot of cushion for combat that rarely punishes. Reviewers also flagged technical issues, and they cut into the polish. A game this committed to theatrical timing cannot afford stumbles.
None of this is fatal. It is the difference between a game that delights you for six hours and one that delights you for three and then asks you to keep clapping.
A Soundtrack Worth the Ticket
The parts that work, work loudly. The visuals are the strongest argument for the whole project. Good-Feel treats each play as a designed set: backdrops, costumes, lighting, and a Peach who looks genuinely delighted to be there. The Sparkle Theater is a real place with a lobby, a stage and a basement, and the art team sells the fantasy.
The soundtrack carries it. The story lands too, at least in outline. Grape is a satisfying villain because she is permitted a second act, and Stella is the rare companion character who earns her place in the mechanics rather than the dialogue.
Peach herself is the reason to play. She has spent decades as a plot device, and Princess Peach: Showtime! gives her range. Here is what the ten roles add up to:
- Swordfighter Peach
- Patissiere Peach
- Ninja Peach
- Cowgirl Peach
- Figure Skater Peach
- Detective Peach
- Dashing Thief Peach
- Mighty Peach
- Mermaid Peach
- Kung Fu Peach
That list is the review. Nintendo looked at its most famous supporting character and asked what she could be if nobody was waiting to rescue her.
The answer is: almost anything, as long as the level is short.
Where It Ranks Against Super Princess Peach
The comparison to Super Princess Peach is unavoidable, and it cuts both ways. That 2005 game was a handheld oddity that put Peach in the lead role and then never got a follow-up. Princess Peach: Showtime! is a cleaner idea, better animated, and far more confident about its lead.
It is also not a reinvention. Good-Feel built a solid action-adventure with a strong central gimmick and a short list of things it does not want to do. It does not want to be hard. It does not want to be long on one idea. It does not want Peach to fail in any way that stings.
Those are choices, and they cost the game. A role-playing structure with ten parts needs escalation, and this one plateaus early. The Heart Charm exists because the designers knew the combat was light and decided to let players opt out entirely rather than tune it up.
The Score
Princess Peach: Showtime! reviewed as a mixed bag, and the published critical aggregate sits at 7.5/10 across six outlets. That number is fair, and it is the number this review lands on.
The case for it: a gorgeous production, a soundtrack that earns its keep, a story with a villain who gets a real second act, and a lead performance from a character who has waited nineteen years for the spotlight. The case against: repetitive play structure, shallow combat, low difficulty, and technical stumbles that undercut the stagecraft.
Ranked against what it is trying to be, the game succeeds at charm and fails at depth. Ranked against what Peach deserved after nineteen years in the wings, it is a good first show and not a great one. The theater is beautiful. The plays are short. The star is ready for a longer run.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
