Peacock canceled “Poker Face” in November 2025, two seasons and 22 episodes after it first aired. That is the fact that hangs over any honest review of the show now. Rian Johnson created it, Natasha Lyonne carried it as Charlie Cale, and it will not continue on the streaming service that launched it.
It is still the best case-of-the-week mystery television has produced in years. Our score is 9.7 out of 10.
Trailer, via Peacock.
Charlie Cale and the 1969 Plymouth Barracuda
The pitch is simple. Charlie Cale can tell when someone is lying. Not read minds, not see the future — just hear a lie and know it. She travels across the United States in a 1969 Plymouth Barracuda, on the run from a casino boss after a suspicious death, and at every stop she runs into a homicide she cannot leave alone.
Johnson built the show as an inverted detective story, the format Columbo popularized. The audience often sees the killing before Charlie does. The pleasure is not whodunit. It is watching Charlie walk into a room full of people lying to her and pick the one thread that pulls the whole thing apart.
Lyonne was approached by Johnson about working on a procedural together, with her as the lead. He has said the role was “completely cut to measure for her.” That is not flattery. Charlie is a drifter with a gift she did not ask for and a mouth that gets her into trouble, and Lyonne plays her as a woman who has made peace with both.
The Inverted Mystery, Week After Week
The show’s structure is its engine. Johnson wanted each guest star to be the star of the episode, an idea he took from the number of actors who passed through Columbo. That is why the guest roster reads like a casting director’s dream.
Season 2 alone added:
- Giancarlo Esposito, Katie Holmes, Gaby Hoffmann, Kumail Nanjiani, Kathrine Narducci, Ben Marshall, Kevin Corrigan and Sherry Cola
- Cynthia Erivo, Margo Martindale and B. J. Novak
- John Mulaney, Ego Nwodim and Sam Richardson
That is a lot of talent cycling through a case-of-the-week show, and it works because none of them are asked to carry the show. They arrive, they lie, Charlie catches them, they leave. The format keeps the show from sagging under any single guest.
Benjamin Bratt joined in April 2022 as Cliff, the head of security at the casino where Charlie works. His character recurs rather than guests, and when Charlie escapes the casino, Cliff goes after her. Bratt called him “a ticking clock for the show.” That clock is what gives the drift a spine. Without Cliff, Charlie is just a woman in a car. With him, she is a woman in a car with something behind her.
What Poker Face Does Better Than Columbo
The obvious comparison is Columbo, and the show invites it. But the writers made one choice that separates Charlie from the detective at the center of that show: she works outside the law.
| Columbo | Charlie Cale | |
|---|---|---|
| Position | Detective | Drifter, no badge |
| Method | Builds a case, gathers evidence | Detects lies on the spot |
| Authority | Can arrest, can compel | Can only walk away or stay |
| Format | Inverted mystery | Inverted mystery |
| Lead | A network procedural lead | Natasha Lyonne |
That last row matters less than the third. The detective at the center of Columbo has the weight of the state behind him. Charlie has a car and a gut feeling she cannot turn off. Every episode she solves a murder she has no standing to solve, and the show never pretends that is easy. She is a witness who keeps becoming a suspect.
It is also funny. The show is billed as crime comedy-drama, and it earns the middle word. Charlie’s ability is a burden, not a superpower, and Lyonne plays the exhaustion of always knowing when someone is lying without ever letting it become a tic.
Two Seasons, 22 Episodes, One Emmy Nomination
The first season ran 10 episodes and debuted on January 26, 2023. Peacock renewed it in February 2023. The second season premiered on May 8, 2025, and ran through July 10, 2025, and consisted of 12 episodes. Lyonne was nominated for Outstanding Lead Actress in a Comedy Series at the 75th Primetime Emmy Awards.
The show drew critical acclaim across both seasons, and the 9.7 Tomatometer score reflects that. It is a rare number for a procedural, a genre that usually gets respect rather than enthusiasm.
Then, in November 2025, Peacock canceled it. Johnson is pitching the show to other networks, hoping for a two-season agreement to continue it. Lyonne will not return as Cale. There are plans for Peter Dinklage to take over the role.
That is where this gets complicated. A show built entirely around one performer’s specific gift — Johnson’s phrase, “cut to measure” — cannot simply swap the lead and stay the same show. Dinklage is a fine actor, and a two-season commitment from a new network would be a real win for everyone who worked on “Poker Face.” But Charlie Cale is not a costume. She is the premise. The lie-detecting drifter in the Barracuda is the whole idea, and recasting her turns a character-driven mystery into a format-driven one.
The format is strong enough to survive that, maybe. The inverted mystery is durable, and the guest-star engine does not depend on who is asking the questions. But the reason “Poker Face” worked — the reason it earned that 9.7 — was Lyonne finding something weary and warm in a woman who can never be lied to and never quite belongs anywhere. That is not a slot to fill. It is a performance.
What the Cancellation Actually Costs
Two seasons is a short run for a show this good, and the numbers say so. Twenty-two episodes, 10 in the first season and 12 in the second, is barely enough to establish a rhythm, let alone wear it out. “Poker Face” never got the chance to have a bad season. It went out clean.
The pitch to other networks is worth watching, but not because a third season is likely. It is worth watching because it tests whether a streaming-era procedural can move between buyers at all. If Johnson lands a two-season deal elsewhere, that is a story about the business. If he does not, that is a story about what gets canceled even when it works.
Either way, the two seasons that exist are close to flawless. “Poker Face” took a format older than most of its viewers and made it feel like it had just been invented. It gave Lyonne the role she was built for and then took it away. That is the trade this industry keeps making.
Our score: 9.7 out of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.