Sen. Roger Marshall (R-Kan.) has been the GOP’s safest Senate seat for years. Kansas has elected Republicans to the Senate for nearly a century. Marshall won his first term in 2020 by 11 points while Republicans took hits as Trump’s first term ended.
Now that seat looks less safe. The race against Pastor Adam Hamilton (D) has tightened as Election Day nears. Marshall’s senior advisor, Brent Robertson, said, “As voters continue to learn more about Democrat Adam Hamilton, they are realizing his views are just a carbon copy of every other woke liberal in Washington.” But Hamilton’s message has found purchase in a state that has never sent a Democrat to the Senate in living memory.
The Race That Moved
The Cook Political Report recently downgraded the race from “Likely Republican” to “Lean Republican.” Fox News also moved it in its election power rankings. Sen. Tim Scott (R-S.C.), the Senate GOP’s campaign chief, acknowledged the race is close but remained confident Marshall would hold on.
Marshall was first elected to the Senate in 2020, winning by 11 points while Republicans took hits as Trump’s first term ended. He has since aligned himself with Trump but recently distanced himself, including pushing for ICE to coordinate with local law enforcement and fighting for Bombardier jobs amid Trump’s trade wars.
Hamilton is a political newcomer who was previously registered as a Republican and now runs a centrist-aligned campaign. He delivered sermons on Black Lives Matter and climate change to Kansas’ largest United Methodist congregation. Six years ago, during a sermon, Hamilton called on his congregation to repent for eating and producing beef, noting that Kansas is the third-largest cattle producer in the country.
Marshall’s Record Against His Opponent
Marshall’s opponent has attacked him directly. The criticism focuses on Marshall’s record on health care, the war in Iran, and the economy:
- Marshall has voted to slash health care funding.
- He supports the war in Iran, which critics say has led to skyrocketing gas and grocery prices.
- Marshall has spent the past 18 months hiding from his constituents.
Tyson Brody, a spokesperson for Hamilton, said, “No one should be surprised that Adam’s message of leading from the middle and working together is resonating across Kansas.”
The Outside Money Pouring In
Vice President JD Vance rallied for Marshall earlier this month, calling for supporters to “stand for Doc Marshall and send the crazy people packing.” Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-S.D.) told Fox News Digital he planned to travel to Kansas and said, “Of course we are,” when asked if Republicans would keep the majority.
The race has become a test case for the GOP’s ability to hold a competitive seat in a red state. Marshall’s path is narrower than it looked a few weeks ago.
What Hamilton Brings to the Race
Hamilton’s background is unusual for a Senate candidate. He is a pastor who has built a national profile through his sermons. The race has also drawn attention to the mechanics of Senate campaigns. The race was recently downgraded from “Likely Republican” to “Lean Republican” by the Cook Political Report and in Fox News’ election power rankings.
The Stakes for Both Sides
A Marshall win would be a straightforward victory for the GOP. A Hamilton upset would be a historic one for Democrats. Kansas has not sent a Democrat to the Senate in nearly a century.
The race has also become a proxy for the broader question facing the GOP heading into the midterms: can the party hold competitive seats in states that have reliably voted Republican for decades? Marshall’s campaign has tried to paint Hamilton as a left-wing outsider who is out of step with Kansas voters.
The outcome will likely determine whether the Senate remains narrowly controlled by the GOP or flips to Democratic hands.
The Road to Election Day
The race is close enough that both sides are treating it as a genuine contest. Marshall’s campaign is emphasizing his record on health care, jobs, and the war. Hamilton’s campaign is highlighting his message of working together.
The next few weeks will determine whether Kansas sends its first Democrat to the Senate in nearly a century.
The Bottom Line
The race is a reminder that even safe seats can be vulnerable. Marshall has held the seat since 2020, but Hamilton has shown he can compete in a state that has never sent a Democrat to the Senate.
Key Facts Box
– Marshall won his first term in 2020 by 11 points
– Kansas has elected Republicans to the Senate for nearly a century
– The race was downgraded from “Likely Republican” to “Lean Republican”
– Hamilton delivered sermons on Black Lives Matter and climate change
– Marshall has spent the past 18 months hiding from his constituents, voting to slash health care
The race is a reminder that even safe seats can be vulnerable. Marshall has held the seat since 2020, but Hamilton has shown he can compete in a state that has never sent a Democrat to the Senate.
Where the paper stands
The paper backs neither candidate outright but judges the race by its north star: individual freedom, small business, and avoiding concentrations of power, and finds no evidence here that either side has offered a platform worthy of endorsement. Marshall’s record includes votes to slash health care funding and support for a war in Iran blamed for soaring gas and grocery prices. Hamilton, a pastor running as a political newcomer, has attacked those same positions.
Neither campaign has made a case that advances any of the paper’s core principles. Marshall’s attacks on Hamilton focus on his past career and his sermons rather than on policy. Hamilton’s own record — including a sermon calling on his congregation to repent for eating beef in Kansas, the third-largest cattle producer in the country — shows a candidate who has built his profile through religion rather than through work on behalf of small business or individual liberty.
The race has become a test case for the GOP’s ability to hold a competitive seat in a red state. Marshall’s path is narrower than it looked a few weeks ago. The paper will watch the final stretch for any sign that either side offers a platform that respects individual freedom, supports small business, and avoids concentrations of power — and will endorse accordingly.
Source material: “Sleeper Senate race emerges as unexpected headache for Republicans ahead of midterms,” Fox News.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.