The Sierra Nevada brewery is attempting to restore its standing with a fresh “hype brewery” series even as it ventures into hard seltzers and radlers. The approach carries risk, since it puts the California operation in direct competition with far larger rivals.
Sierra Nevada confronts a predicament common to first-generation craft breweries: its Pale Ale is instantly recognizable, beloved by many, and rarely purchased.
The Packaging Refresh
A range of core portfolio brands, with the Pale Ale among them, are set to receive refreshed packaging in fall 2027, following a period of about five or six years during which the company has battled a “perception of being ‘grocery store craft,'”, according to Kyle Ingram, senior director of innovation at Sierra Nevada.
“Our portfolio had developed over such a long period of time that it didn’t look coherent on display, and I think some of it had aged and we needed to shake the dust off,” Sierra Nevada chief executive Pryce Greenow explained to Brewbound.
A Strong Starting Point
The company enters this move with a strong foundation, according to Circana data. Through September 6, Sierra Nevada’s portfolio rose 1.9 percent in dollars and 0.2 percent in case volume year-to-date, outpacing both the falling category and the craft segment within it, which is shrinking at an even faster rate.
The expansion allows the firm the freedom to try new things, according to “When you have a healthy core, it allows you to innovate in a way where we’re not dependent on that [new] thing being big and successful right out of the gate,” who made the remark.
Crafted By Sierra Nevada
Crafted By Sierra Nevada marks the firm’s first major foray into the “beyond beer” space since it spun up and wound down also-ran entrants Tea West and Strainge Beast earlier this decade. The line features “spiked agave seltzer” Agua Azul and “beer soda” Shred.
Already on shelves in test markets, the new fermentables come with subordinated branding from the mothership. Ingram had to pitch founder Ken Grossman on a beer soda called Shred, and “I remember thinking distinctly, this might be my last pitch,” he tells Hop Take, laughing.
The Hype Brewery Line
The Hidden Scroll series is a different beast. It is composed of honest-to-goodness beers, but it aims for the cachet of small, dynamic “hype breweries.” That means capturing the customer who pays $25 for a four-pack of something local and buzzy.
“That guy who is paying 25 bucks for a four-pack, he’s looking for some of the more local, the more ‘hype’ kind of breweries in that space,” says Ingram. “We’re certainly capable and credible from a brewing standpoint, but maybe that’s not the area of the shelf or the cooler where people are looking for Sierra Nevada.”
The Market Environment
It is not yet known whether Crafted By Sierra Nevada’s products will thrive or merely survive in a lucrative-but-tricky flavored malt beverage pseudosegment dominated by scaled flavor-chasers like Mark Anthony Group, Anheuser-Busch InBev, and BBC.
| Brand | Category | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Agua Azul | Hard seltzer | On shelves |
| Shred | Radler | On shelves |
| Hidden Scroll series | Beers | Unannounced timing |
What We Make of It
This thesis covers a column about Crafted By’s entry into flavored malt beverages is sound, per Hop Take, a company that is advancing quickly while sitting on a solid foundation.
There is genuine danger involved. The rivals are many and strong. Yet the goal remains plain to see.
The Sierra Nevada strategy splits into two paths: one built around hard seltzers and radlers, the other chasing the energy of smaller, trendier breweries. The open question is whether both can carry the company forward together.
Source material: “The Bull Case for Sierra Nevada’s Under-the-Radar ‘Hype Brewery’ Line,” VinePair.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.