Tennessee halted the execution of Tony Carruthers in May after a physician failed to place a central line in his chest. Now doctors and nurses are fighting back, calling the execution a botched attempt that should never happen again.
Dozens of Tennessee doctors and nurses wrote a letter to Governor Bill Lee, saying the execution was “horrifyingly botched” and should never happen again. The letter calls for a moratorium on the death penalty and a new execution method.
Quinn’s Warning
Dr. Robert Quinn said healthcare professionals willing to take part in executions are setting aside their professional ethics. Dr. John Greer signed the letter and said healthcare workers should not participate in legally authorized executions.
What Went Wrong
Tennessee’s protocol involves nurses or paramedics placing IVs in a prisoner’s arms. If they fail, a doctor inserts a central line in a deeper vein. In Carruthers’ execution, the doctor said what he experienced was torturous. The IV team tried arms, hands, feet, chest, and shoulder before failing.
Attorney Maria DeLiberato said blood was oozing from Carruthers’ puncture wounds and that he was moaning and groaning in pain throughout. Dr. Mark Fowler, the physician involved, hadn’t placed a central line in 13 years according to legal records.
Fowler told NPR he only declares the time of death and declined further comment.
Senate Support
The letter’s authors argue that lethal injection requires medical expertise that conflicts with ethical duties to patients. They want Tennessee to stop using healthcare workers for executions altogether.
Some Republican state senators also called for a moratorium and an overhaul. Carruthers received a one-year reprieve when the governor ordered the execution stopped.
The Next Execution
Tennessee is scheduled to execute Christa Pike on September 30. Her lawyers say she has a blood disorder likely requiring a central line.
Governor Lee, whose term ends in January, rejected a moratorium at a press conference. He said the Department of Correction did exactly what they should.
The Ethics Paradox
The letter raises a question that cuts through politics: can healthcare workers ethically be asked to inflict harm?
Doctors and nurses have a duty to heal. Executions ask them to do the opposite.
A Stronger Case
The letter’s authors have made a stronger case: that lethal injection is incompatible with healthcare ethics.
The execution of Carruthers was botched. The question now is whether Tennessee will learn from it.
- Nurses and paramedics placed IVs in arms, hands, feet, chest, and shoulder
- Fowler hadn’t placed a central line in 13 years
- DeLiberato described Carruthers as moaning and groaning in pain
- The letter calls for a moratorium on the death penalty
- Pike’s lawyers say she needs a central line
The fight over executions in Tennessee is far from over. But the voices of healthcare workers have been heard, and they are demanding change.
Source material: “Tennessee's failed execution ignites a medical ethics debate,” NPR.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.