Two children, a cook, a wreck, an island. That is the whole premise of The Blue Lagoon (1980), and it should have been enough. Instead, director Randal Kleiser and writer Douglas Day Stewart spent their 104-minute runtime turning a simple survival story into a slow-motion disaster.
The setup is sound. Emmeline and Richard, two cousins, and the ship’s cook Paddy Button survive a wreck on a tropical island in the South Pacific. Paddy dies after a binge, leaving the children alone. They grow up on the island, build a home, and learn to live off it. Then the film decides to spend the rest of its length on their growing feelings for each other.
Trailer, via Eurekaentertainment.
Emmeline and Richard
Brooke Shields plays Emmeline and Christopher Atkins plays Richard. Together they carry the film’s weight, and neither is equipped for it. Their chemistry is thin. Their reactions are forced. The film asks them to play pubescent curiosity and adult longing at once, and neither actor can manage either.
The supporting cast does better. Leo McKern plays Paddy Button with a worn, paternal presence. William Daniels plays Arthur Lestrange with a quiet menace. Gus Mercurio and Alan Hopgood fill out the ship’s crew. None of it lifts the film above its own ambitions.
The Island
The island itself is the film’s strongest asset. The cinematography captures the green, blue, sunlit beauty of the location. The camera lingers on trees, water, and light in ways the story never matches. This is a film that looks beautiful while saying almost nothing.
The Ship’s Crew
| Character | Role |
|---|---|
| Paddy Button | Ship’s cook |
| Arthur Lestrange | Uncle |
| Captain | N/A |
| Officer | N/A |
The captain and officer exist only to deliver exposition about the wreck. They are window dressing for a plot that cannot sustain itself otherwise.
What Works
There is one scene where Emmeline and Richard swim naked in the sea. It is awkward, obvious, and strangely affecting. It works because it is the rare moment where the film stops trying to be something it is not.
What Does Not Work
Everything else. The dialogue is stiff. The pacing is slow. The central conflict — Emmeline refusing to light a signal fire when a ship passes — feels arbitrary and cruel rather than tragic. The film spends its final stretch punishing its own characters for reasons the script never explains.
Reception
The film was a box office hit, grossing $58.8 million on a $4.5 million budget. It became the ninth-highest-grossing film of 1980 in North America. It also earned a Golden Raspberry Award for Worst Picture and Worst Screenplay, and Shields won Worst Actress.
Verdict
The Blue Lagoon is a failure of ambition. It takes a simple story of survival and ruins it by making everything about sex. The result is a film that is visually pleasing and emotionally hollow.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
