The Killing premiered on AMC on April 3, 2011, and ended on Netflix on August 1, 2014. Veena Sud developed the American version from the Danish series Forbrydelsen. It follows two Seattle homicide detectives, Sarah Linden and Stephen Holder, across four seasons and 44 episodes. It earns 8.4/10.
Trailer, via Netflix.
Mireille Enos and Joel Kinnaman
The pairing is the engine. Linden works the case like a wound she will not let close. Holder works it like a man proving something to people who are not in the room. Mireille Enos plays Linden with a stillness that reads as pressure, not calm. Joel Kinnaman gives Holder a jitter that could be nerves or could be method.
Seattle is not backdrop. Rain, water, gray light — the city is a place where evidence gets wet and witnesses get tired.
One Investigation, Held Open
The first season builds around a single murder and refuses to cut it loose. That is the show’s gamble. It asks you to sit in the same room for hours while a family grieves and a department scrambles.
The gamble mostly pays. Crime drama usually solves. The Killing lingers. The cost is real: the middle stretch of season one can feel like a hallway with no doors.
Two Cancellations and a Rescue
AMC cancelled the series in July 2012. It then picked the show up for a third season after renegotiation with Fox Television Studios and Netflix. AMC cancelled it again in September 2013. Netflix ordered a fourth season of six episodes in November 2013 to close it out. The complete fourth season went up on Netflix on August 1, 2014.
That history is not trivia. A show cancelled twice learns to write like it might not get another hour.
Gregg Henry and Joan Allen in the Wings
- Gregg Henry as Carl Reddick
- Joan Allen as Margaret O’Neal
- Sterling Beaumon as Lincoln Knopf
- Levi Meaden as AJ Fielding
- Morten Hauch-Fausbøll as Jarl Frevert
- Rowan Longworth as Adrian Seward
The supporting cast does work procedurals usually hand to exposition. Reddick is a department problem. O’Neal is a different kind of pressure. These are not decorative names.
Forbrydelsen, Moved to Seattle
Forbrydelsen translates literally as The Crime, though it is widely known internationally as The Killing. The American version keeps the spine — one death, many suspects, a detective who cannot walk away — and moves it to Seattle, Washington.
The transplant works because Sud does not treat the original as a script to copy. She treats it as a temperature.
The Case for 8.4
The Killing is a slow show that earns its slowness more often than it wastes it. The Linden-Holder relationship is the reason to stay. Two people who do not like each other much, working a job that requires them to trust each other completely.
The noise is the plot mechanics. Too many suspects, too many turns, too many episodes where the case advances by coincidence. The signal is the two leads and the city.
Netflix’s six-episode final season is the cleanest argument for the show. Given a fixed end, it stops stalling. That is the version of The Killing that deserved a longer life.
The Numbers
- Score: 8.4/10
- Metacritic: 84/100
- Premiered: April 3, 2011, on AMC
- Final season released: August 1, 2014, on Netflix
- Seasons: 4
- Episodes: 44
- Created by: Veena Sud
- Based on: Forbrydelsen
The Killing is not a perfect crime drama. It is a patient one, and patience is rarer. Two cancellations and a Netflix rescue produced a show that knew, by the end, exactly what it was. That is worth 8.4/10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.