Colin Farrell disappears into the role of Oz Cobb in The Penguin, and the result is the best thing HBO has put on screen since Succession ended. The series, created by Lauren LeFranc, does not merely extend the story of Matt Reeves’ The Batman. It builds its own brutal, grimy empire of a show, one that stands entirely on its own.
Set in the flooded, power-vacuumed streets of Gotham, the show tracks Oz’s bloody climb from mid-level hustler to would-be kingpin. It is a crime saga in the classic mold, but it is shot and written with a modern, unflinching edge. The show takes its time, but it never wastes a minute.
Trailer, via HBO Max.
Oz Cobb’s Hungry Climb
Farrell is unrecognizable. Under layers of prosthetics and a thick New York accent, he plays Oz as a man of bottomless ambition and fragile ego. This is not a cartoon villain. He is pathetic, funny, terrifying, and strangely sympathetic, often within the same scene. His limp is a constant reminder of a world that has always pushed him down, and his hunger to rise is the engine of the entire series.
The writing gives him a rich inner life, but it never excuses his actions. He lies, cheats, and murders his way forward, and the show is clear-eyed about the cost. The supporting cast is just as strong. Cristin Milioti delivers a career-best performance as Sofia Falcone, the newly freed daughter of the late crime boss. Her arc is a slow-burn fuse that leads to some of the most shocking moments in the series.
Gotham’s Broken Streets
The show’s Gotham is a character in itself. It is wet, dark, and crumbling, a city where the lights flicker and the power lines sag. The production design is meticulous, from the dingy bars to the opulent but decaying Falcone mansion. The series uses the flood from The Batman as a constant backdrop, a physical reminder of the old order’s collapse.
The plot is a chess game of shifting alliances. Oz plays the Maronis against the Falcones, and the show tracks every betrayal with precision. It is a dense narrative, but the script keeps the threads clear. Each episode builds to a set piece, and the direction is consistently sharp, favoring tension over cheap action.
Sofia’s Slow-Burn War
Milioti’s Sofia is the show’s secret weapon. She returns from Arkham Asylum, branded a serial killer, and the world expects her to be a monster. The show slowly reveals the truth of her past, and it is far more tragic and complex than the rumors suggest. Her relationship with Oz is the core of the series, a dance of mutual suspicion and grudging respect that curdles into open war.
Her story is a tragedy of inheritance. She is a woman in a world of men who see her as a pawn, and her rage is a controlled, precise thing. The show gives her a full arc, from broken daughter to ruthless don, and Milioti sells every step. She matches Farrell scene for scene, and their confrontations are the series’ highest points.
Patience That Pays Off
The Penguin is not a fast show. It is a patient, deliberate study of power. The first few episodes set the board, introducing the players and their motives. Some viewers may find the pacing slow, but the show is building a foundation for a spectacular collapse. The middle episodes are where the tension ratchets up, and the final stretch is a masterclass in payoff.
Every betrayal lands. Every secret is revealed at the worst possible moment. The show trusts its audience to follow the threads, and it rewards that trust with a finale that is both brutal and emotionally resonant. It is a complete story, with a beginning, middle, and end that feels earned.
Violence Without Glamour
The series is unapologetically grim. It is a story about terrible people doing terrible things, and it does not flinch from the consequences. The violence is sudden and ugly, never stylized for fun. It serves the story, reminding the viewer of the stakes in every scene.
The show also has a dark sense of humor. Oz is a talker, a man who spins stories to get what he wants, and his patter is often funny. The humor never undercuts the tension; it makes the characters feel more human, which makes their cruelty all the more unsettling.
A Spin-Off That Stands Alone
The show is a spin-off, but it rarely feels like one. It references the events of The Batman without being trapped by them. The Batman himself is a distant, off-screen presence, a symbol of a justice that does not touch these streets. This is Oz’s story, and the show is confident enough to tell it without a caped cameo.
It expands the world of Reeves’ Gotham in a meaningful way. It shows the city from the ground level, where the real power is fought over in back rooms and alleyways. It is a crime epic that uses its source material as a springboard, not a crutch.
The Score
The show is a triumph of casting, writing, and direction. It takes a familiar genre and finds new angles, delivering a story that is both classic and fresh. The performances are uniformly excellent, with Farrell and Milioti giving two of the best performances of the year.
| Show | Lead Performance | Pacing | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Penguin | Farrell’s transformation is total | Patient, deliberate build | A masterclass in crime drama |
| The Batman | Pattinson’s brooding detective | Long, atmospheric | A strong foundation for the world |
It is a demanding show, one that asks for patience and attention. It earns both. The final episode ties everything together with a bow of blood and irony, leaving the door open for more without feeling incomplete. It is a rare thing: a spin-off that outshines its source material.
The show is a must-watch for fans of the genre and a high-water mark for comic book television.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
