Dead Space 3 arrived 13 years ago with a mountain of expectation on its back. Visceral Games had built one of the best horror series of the generation, and Electronic Arts wanted it bigger. The result is a game that works, often well, but one that keeps stepping away from the things that made Isaac Clarke’s story worth following.
Trailer, via Dead Space.
Tau Volantis and the frozen planet problem
The setup is strong. Isaac Clarke, the engineer who survived the USG Ishimura, is hiding on a colony on Earth’s moon when Sgt. John Carver and Robert Norton drag him into a search for Ellie Langford. The trail leads to Tau Volantis, a frozen planet assumed to be the Marker home world. The story follows Isaac and his allies as they explore that planet to discover the origins of the Necromorph threat.
Dead Space 3 is set in the 26th century. Humanity, short on resources, experimented with an alien artifact called the Black Marker. It triggered dementia and mental illness and turned corpses into monsters called Necromorphs. A religion called the Church of Unitology grew up around the Marker, worshipping it as a divine force that would lead humanity to a unified state called “Convergence.”
That backstory gives the game real weight. The problem is what Visceral does with it.
Isaac Clarke and the co-op split
The secondary protagonist is John Carver, an EarthGov soldier who survived a Necromorph outbreak that killed his family. In online cooperative sessions, a second player takes the role of Carver. That is the headline feature, and it changes the game in ways that are not all good.
Dead Space built its reputation on isolation. A second player standing next to Isaac cuts against that. The game tries to work around it — Carver has his own history, his own losses — but the tension that defined the first two games thins out when someone is talking in your ear.
The supporting cast is decent. Ellie Langford returns as a pilot and Isaac’s ex-girlfriend. Norton is an EarthGov officer and Ellie’s new boyfriend, which sets up friction. Jacob Danik leads a militant Unitologist group called the Circle. Researchers Jennifer Santos and Austin Buckell round out the crew.
Weapons, crafting and the microtransaction problem
The combat still runs on strategic dismemberment. Necromorphs can only be killed by severing their limbs. Isaac can carry two weapons, move into cover behind some objects, and use the Kinesis ability to move or pull objects and the Stasis ability to slow a target’s movement for a limited time.
The crafting bench is where the game splits its audience. Dead Space 3 lets players comb harsh environments for raw materials and scavenge parts to build customized weapons and survival tools. It is a real system with real depth. It is also where Electronic Arts introduced microtransactions, and that decision sits badly against everything else the game is doing.
Production on Dead Space 3 began in 2011 after Dead Space 2 shipped. The sequel was initially planned as a horror-focused experience. Demands from Electronic Arts pushed it toward action elements, a de-emphasis of horror themes, and the introduction of microtransactions. That is the whole argument about this game in one sentence.
What the ice planet gets right
Tau Volantis is a real setting, not a backdrop. Isaac rappels up and down vertical slopes with controls for sideways movement and dodging environmental threats. He climbs ladders to reach high platforms. Some sections take him into outer space with a limited supply of air, and some areas are weightless, with Isaac using his RIG suit to explore debris and spacecraft.
Avalanches, ice climbs and violent wilderness are part of the mission. The game wants you to feel the planet fighting back, and often it succeeds.
The interface remains one of the series’ best ideas. Almost all gameplay displays show in-game as diegetic holographic projections. Isaac’s health and energy meters sit on the back of his RIG suit. Ammunition counts show on the weapons. Opening the inventory does not pause the game. That last detail matters more than it sounds — it keeps you in the world at all times.
The exception is the crafting bench interface, which breaks the rule. It is a small thing, but it is the tell. The systems that came from the publisher’s demands are the ones that step outside the fiction.
The enemies and the three-way fights
Necromorphs are not the only threat. Isaac also encounters human enemies, and occasional three-way battles break out between Isaac, Necromorphs and human soldiers. Those fights are chaotic in a good way. They give the combat a texture the earlier games did not have.
The Unitologists are the reason. The Church of Unitology works to spread the Markers’ influence while EarthGov tries to contain the crisis and exploit the Markers for energy. Danik and the Circle turn that conflict into bullets. The game is better for having a human faction with a coherent belief system behind it.
The plot reaches back two centuries. A military team on Tau Volantis retrieved an artifact called the Codex. The team’s commander killed his remaining subordinate, erased the data on the Codex, and then killed himself. In the present, Isaac, Carver, Norton, Santos and Buckell travel to Tau Volantis’s moon, rescue Ellie, and investigate the derelict ship Terra Nova, where they find evidence of past Necromorph research and the recurring phrase “Turn it off.”
That phrase is the engine of the back half. It is also where the story starts to feel like a series finale rather than a story with its own shape.
What Dead Space 3 gets wrong
Three things hurt this game most, in order of damage.
- The microtransactions. A survival horror game about scarcity should not sell you resources. It undercuts the entire premise of scavenging.
- The de-emphasized horror. The first two games made you afraid of corners. This one makes you afraid of ammo counts.
- The co-op structure. Carver is a fine character. The problem is that the game cannot decide whether it wants company or solitude.
The action pivot is not automatically a failure. Visceral can build a firefight. The three-way battles with Unitologists and Necromorphs are genuinely good. But the series was never about firefights. It was about a man alone in a suit, listening to his own breathing.
Below is how the two halves of Dead Space 3 compare on the things that matter most.
| Element | Horror-focused design | Action-focused design |
|---|---|---|
| Enemy encounters | Necromorphs, strategic dismemberment | Three-way battles with human soldiers |
| Resource handling | Scavenging for survival tools | Crafting bench with microtransactions |
| Player presence | Isaac alone | Isaac and Carver in co-op |
| Atmosphere | Weightless sections, limited air | Avalanches, ice climbs, open combat |
The left column is the game Visceral wanted to make. The right column is the game Electronic Arts asked for. Dead Space 3 is what happens when those two things share a disc.
The score
Dead Space 3 is a good game carrying the weight of a great series. The production values hold up. Tau Volantis is a memorable setting, the RIG interface is still the best in the business, and the story does the work of closing out the Necromorph mysteries. Composers Jason Graves and James Hannigan wrote the score, and it does its job.
The downloadable episode Awakened, released in March 2013, was developed with more focus on horror elements. That tells you something. The team knew what had been lost.
Dead Space 3 is the third and final main entry in the series, and it plays like an ending that was negotiated rather than chosen. It is worth playing. It is also worth wondering what the version without the publisher’s demands would have looked like.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
