Disney spent $140 million on Treasure Planet, making it the most expensive traditionally animated film to date. It earned $109.6 million. That gap is the whole story of the 2002 release, and it is worth sitting with before anyone talks about the movie’s reputation.
Trailer, via Disney.
A Solar Sail on Stevenson’s Hull
Ron Clements and John Musker directed, and wrote the script with Rob Edwards. The film adapts Robert Louis Stevenson’s Treasure Island (1883) — the third Disney pass at the novel, after Treasure Island (1950) and Muppet Treasure Island (1996). The setting swaps rigging for solar sails: spaceships here look like 18th-century sailing vessels, and the conceit holds together better than it sounds.
Clements and Musker pitched the idea during production of The Little Mermaid (1989). Development started after Hercules (1997). The technique is hand-drawn 2D animation laid over 3D computer work, and it still looks like nothing else Disney was making at the time.
Jim Hawkins, John Silver, and a Map in a Sphere
On the planet Montressor, Jim Hawkins runs an inn with his mother, Sarah. Billy Bones crashes nearby, hands Jim a sphere, and warns him to “beware the cyborg.” Pirates destroy the inn hunting for it. Jim flees with Sarah and Dr. Delbert Doppler, an astrophysicist.
The sphere holds a holographic star map to an intergalactic “loot of a thousand worlds,” hidden by the pirate Captain Flint. Doppler commissions the RLS Legacy, commanded by Captain Amelia with stone-skinned first mate Mr. Arrow. The crew seems heavily influenced by the ship’s cook, John Silver — which is why Jim suspects Silver is the cyborg Bones warned him about. He is.
The Father-Son Problem at the Center
Silver supervises Jim in the galley, alongside his shape-shifting pet Morph. The two build a tenuous father-son bond, and that relationship is the film’s best material. It is also the safest.
The voyage hits a supernova collapsing into a black hole. Jim secures the crew’s lifelines; Scroop, a ruthless arachnid crewman, secretly cuts Arrow’s line and sends him into the black hole. Scroop then blames Jim. Silver, knowing the truth, comforts him.
That is a real scene, and it lands. The movie around it keeps reaching for a grandeur its 96 minutes cannot carry.
The Voice Cast Disney Built the Roles Around
Casting director Ruth Lambert ran auditions in New York, Los Angeles and London, but two parts were written for specific actors. Dr. Doppler was conceived with David Hyde Pierce in mind; Pierce got the script and preliminary sketches in 1997 while working on Pixar’s A Bug’s Life (1998). Jeff Goldblum and Hugh Grant were considered before he took it.
Captain Amelia was developed for Emma Thompson. “We offered it to her and she was really excited,” Clements said. Musker added that it was her first action-adventure character and that she was pregnant during several sessions.
Joseph Gordon-Levitt voiced Jim after months of auditions. Musker said he “combined enough vulnerability and intelligence and a combination of youthfulness but incompleteness.” Brian Murray played Silver. Patrick McGoohan voiced Billy Bones in his final role.
The Release Disney Stacked Against Itself
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 1989 | Clements and Musker pitch the concept during The Little Mermaid |
| 1997 | Development begins after Hercules; Pierce receives the script |
| November 6, 2002 | Paris premiere |
| November 27, 2002 | U.S. release by Walt Disney Pictures |
| 2002 | First film released simultaneously in regular and IMAX theaters |
That IMAX first is a genuine milestone. It did not save the run.
What the $140 Million Bought
A 6.0 out of 10 is the right score, and the reason is not the animation. The solar-sail world is coherent, the black hole sequence is genuinely tense, and the Silver-Jim thread gives the film an emotional spine most Disney adventures of that era lack.
The problem is proportion. Treasure Planet spends its budget on scale and its runtime on a plot that keeps moving the map around — the “map” turns out to be Morph in disguise, with the real map elsewhere. A mutiny erupts once they reach the planet, and Jim returns onboard to retrieve the map. Silver lets the group escape because he has grown attached to the boy; a pirate shoots down the lifeboat and injures Amelia anyway. Every beat is functional. Few are surprising.
James Newton Howard composed the score; John Rzeznik wrote and performed the songs. Both do their jobs. Neither becomes the thing you remember.
What this paper makes of it: Treasure Planet is a better film than its box office suggests and a lesser one than its defenders claim. The $140 million is visible on screen, and that is exactly the trouble — you can see the money instead of the story. The father-son material earns its place. The rest is a handsome, expensive machine that never finds the emotional gravity its own black hole sequence manages in five minutes.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
