U.S. President Trump and Chinese leader Xi Jinping met face to face at the White House this week for the first time this year, trading red-carpet pomp and panda announcements as the two nations try to steady relations after months of tension.
The meeting marked the first time the two leaders have spoken in person since September, when they met in South Korea. Trump hosted Xi for a lavish state dinner with a red-carpet welcome, complete with a new helipad on the South Lawn, military flyovers, and a tour of construction projects. The pageantry was significant, according to Samm Sacks, senior fellow at New America, who said it created a “breathing space” amid rising tensions.
The agenda covered three topics: artificial intelligence, trade, and the Iran war. The two leaders also discussed information-sharing systems to alert each other about AI incidents affecting national security.
“Leave it exactly where it is.”
Trump said on Thursday morning that he wanted to “leave it exactly where it is” regarding AI, opposing regulation and wanting to beat China on the technology. The statement came hours after the two leaders had sat down together.
The Trade Extension That Took Two Months
The most concrete outcome was a two-month extension of the trade agreement established last year in South Korea. The U.S. announced the extension, which keeps the deal alive through November.
China is hosting the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in November, where Trump and Xi met on the sidelines last year. Trump is hosting the Group of Twenty (G20) summit in Miami in December, where Xi could potentially return.
The two leaders could meet two more times before the end of the year.
The AI Warning and the Helicopter Tour
The AI discussion was the most substantive of the three. Trump said he wanted to keep the technology unregulated while still beating China.
Trump met Xi on the tarmac when he arrived in Washington, showcasing the new helipad on the South Lawn. He then gave Xi a tour of construction projects on the White House grounds.
The information-sharing systems they discussed would allow each country to alert the other about AI incidents that could affect their respective national security.
Panda News From Atlanta
Xi announced two new Chinese pandas are coming to the zoo in Atlanta. The announcement was a light moment in an otherwise serious agenda, but it underscored the personal nature of the relationship between the two leaders.
Trump complained on Truth Social that TV networks didn’t show the “made-for-television” moments due to his ban on three media outlets. The complaint reflected his frustration that the grandeur of the event was not being broadcast.
What the Spectacle Achieved
The pageantry was not just for show. Sacks said the red-carpet welcome and the military flyovers created a “breathing space” that is stabilizing amid rising tensions.
The meeting was the first time the two leaders had spoken in person since September, when they met in South Korea.
The Limits of the Summit
The bar for major takeaways from the summit was low. The two leaders did not announce a breakthrough on any of the three issues they discussed.
The trade extension was the only concrete outcome, and even that was modest. A two-month extension is a stopgap, not a permanent solution.
The AI discussion was more symbolic than substantive. Trump’s “leave it exactly where it is” remark showed he opposes regulation.
The two leaders could meet two more times before the end of the year, at the APEC summit in November and the G20 summit in Miami in December.
The Bottom Line
The meeting was a success in terms of optics, but it produced little in the way of concrete results. Trump kept the trade deal alive for two months, announced the pandas, and warned about AI while rejecting regulation.
The APEC summit in November and the G20 summit in Miami in December will offer further opportunities for the two leaders to engage. Whether those meetings produce more than the current ones remains to be seen.
Where the paper stands
The paper backs the deal over the standoff and the steady hand of diplomacy over the spectacle of the red carpet, while remaining against any rule that hands the market to the incumbents. The red-carpet pomp was significant, but the substance behind it was thin.
Samm Sacks, senior fellow at New America, said the pageantry created a “breathing space” amid rising tensions. The military flyovers and the new helipad were indeed significant. But the two leaders did not announce a breakthrough on any of the three issues they discussed. The AI discussion was more symbolic than substantive, with Trump warning against regulation while still wanting to beat China.
The two leaders could meet two more times before the end of the year, at the APEC summit in November and the G20 summit in Miami in December. The paper wants those meetings to produce more than optics. It wants a steady hand of diplomacy, not a red-carpet spectacle.
Source material: “Trump and China's Xi discuss AI, trade and Iran war during state visit,” NPR.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.