“Black Sails” is a pirate drama that trades romance for grit. Set before the events of Robert Louis Stevenson’s Treasure Island, it follows Captain Flint and his crew on the island of New Providence. The show is not subtle about its violence or its sex. That honesty is also its biggest strength.
Trailer, via STARZ.
Captain Flint and the Cast
Sam Strike plays Flint as a man who knows exactly what he wants and takes it. His crew, led by Jack Rackham, are loyal to a fault, even as they scheme behind his back. The performances hold the show together. The writing, less so.
Violence Over Character
The show is at its best when it lets the violence breathe. Sword fights, executions, and ship battles are staged with confidence. When it tries to build tension through dialogue, the script often fails to deliver. The pacing drags in the middle episodes, and some character arcs feel rushed.
New Providence’s Setting
The island itself becomes a character. The mud, the heat, and the constant threat of disease and starvation give the show a lived-in sense of place that few period dramas achieve. This is a world where the pirates are not heroes, but survivors.
Where It Falls Short
The show leans too heavily on spectacle. Some episodes feel like set pieces designed to wow rather than serve the story. The emotional stakes are there, but the show rarely finds the patience to let them land.
Final Score
“Black Sails” is a competent, often thrilling prequel that never quite reaches the heights of its ambitions. It is a worthy watch for fans of the genre, but it asks for patience the show does not fully earn.
Key Facts
- Title: Black Sails
- Year: 2014
- Network: Starz
- Creator: Michael Bayley
- Score: 6.5 of 10
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
