“Vantage Point” wants to be Rashomon. It isn’t. This 2008 thriller follows the assassination of U.S. President Henry Ashton in Salamanca, Spain, told from eight different witnesses’ points of view. Each replay of the minutes before the fatal shot reveals new details, but the film never questions whether there is one truth. It just confirms it.
Trailer, via Sony Pictures Releasing UK.
The Setup
The President arrives at the Plaza Mayor for an international summit against terrorism. A GNN producer named Rex Brooks films the ceremony from a mobile studio. The mayor introduces Ashton, who is shot twice as he reaches the podium. Seconds later, an explosion outside the plaza happens. Then a second blast at the podium kills and injures many people.
Secret Service agent Thomas Barnes notices a curtain flutter in a supposedly empty building. He spots American tourist Howard Lewis filming the audience. After the shooting, Barnes tackles a man named Enrique rushing toward the podium. Later, Barnes barges into the GNN studio to look at their footage. He gets a call from another agent pursuing the suspected assassin, then starts at an image from GNN’s live feed.
The Witnesses
Each witness sees something different. Veronica, the girlfriend of Enrique, a Spanish police officer guarding the mayor, is embraced by a stranger and plans to meet later under an overpass. Enrique overhears this and confronts Veronica, who tells him she loves him as she hands him a bag. When the President is shot, Enrique rushes to protect the mayor but is stopped by Barnes. He watches Veronica throw the bag under the podium, which causes the second explosion.
Enrique escapes the Secret Service and meets an unseen person at the overpass. In the crowd, Howard Lewis chats with a man called Sam. A little girl named Anna bumps into him. Howard notices Barnes looking at the nearby window.
“8 strangers. 8 points of view. 1 truth.”
The Rashomon Comparison
“Vantage Point” is often compared unfavorably to Akira Kurosawa’s Rashomon. That comparison holds up badly. Rashomon uses multiple perspectives to question whether truth exists at all. “Vantage Point” uses the same device to confirm a single, fixed truth. The difference is the whole point.
The film’s tagline promises one truth. It delivers it. Every version of the story lines up, piece by piece, until the puzzle is complete. There is no ambiguity, no unreliable narrator, no room for doubt.
What Works and What Doesn’t
The film moves fast and stays tight to its 90-minute runtime. Pete Travis directs with energy, and the editing cuts between witnesses cleanly. But the story’s lack of mystery is the problem. By the halfway mark, most viewers will know who the assassin is and what the plan was. The rest is simply confirmation.
The cast is strong. Dennis Quaid plays Barnes with quiet intensity. Matthew Fox is solid as Kent Taylor. Forest Whitaker plays Howard Lewis with a nervous energy that sells the panic. Sigourney Weaver plays Rex Brooks with cool professionalism. William Hurt plays President Ashton with the weight of office. The supporting cast fills out the rest of the witnesses without much chance to stand out.
The film was co-produced by Relativity Media, Original Film, and Art In Motion. It began filming in Mexico City on June 18, 2006. It premiered in Salamanca on February 13, 2008, and reached U.S. theaters through Sony Pictures Releasing’s Columbia Pictures label on February 22. The score, composed by Atli Örvarsson, came out on Varèse Sarabande on February 26.
The Verdict
“Vantage Point” is a technically competent thriller that never earns its own stakes. The Rashomon comparison is accurate, but only in form. The film borrows the structure without borrowing the spirit. It sets up a mystery and then pulls the rug out from under itself by solving it too early.
The film grossed $151 million worldwide and received mixed reviews from critics. Our own reading of the film lands in the middle of that range: a solid, well-made picture that never quite becomes a great one. The premise is clever. The execution is tidy. The payoff is predictable.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
