Grand Theft Auto VI isn’t out yet, and Marvel’s Wolverine is already out and getting hammered. That is the strange state of video games in 2026, according to a new piece from Collider, and the fan reaction to both titles exposes a deeper problem than either game’s actual quality.
The piece, titled “The Intense Reaction to 2026’s Biggest Games Exposes an Even Bigger Problem,” argues that gamers are more critical than ever. It points to two specific examples: Marvel’s Wolverine, which launched this year to mixed reviews, and Grand Theft Auto VI, which hasn’t shipped but is already the subject of intense scrutiny. Both have been heavily criticized by the gaming community, and the piece wonders whether the outrage is deserved.
What Marvel’s Wolverine Actually Is
Marvel’s Wolverine is Insomniac Games’ latest entry in the superhero genre. It was announced in 2021 and took five years to arrive. The game follows the titular character, voiced by Liam McIntyre, who loses his memories and joins Team X. He eventually bonds with a group of mutants as they fight against the injustices committed against them.
The combat is described as visceral, fast-paced, and engaging. The piece calls it “absolutely engrossing.” But the reception has been mixed, and the game has become Insomniac’s lowest-rated title in recent memory. The company has a strong track record, with several of its earlier titles ranking among the best games of the 2010s. Their most recent release, however, has underwhelmed.
What Grand Theft Auto VI Isn’t
Grand Theft Auto VI is still unannounced, and that is the whole point. The game is set in Vice City and follows a Bonnie and Clyde-style relationship between Jason Duval and Lucia Caminos. The voice actors have not been officially confirmed. Over a decade has passed since Grand Theft Auto V was released, and Rockstar’s last major release, Red Dead Redemption 2, arrived eight years ago.
The anticipation is enormous. Fans know the gameplay will include a dense city to explore, detailed gunplay, mini-games, and random activities. The graphics are expected to be hyper-realistic. But the trailers and extended looks have faced intense scrutiny, with fans picking apart every frame for flaws.
Why the Hate Exists
The controversy surrounding these games is rooted in expectation. Marvel’s Wolverine was highly anticipated, and now that it has arrived, fans are judging it harshly. The game’s low rating reflects that disappointment. Meanwhile, Grand Theft Auto VI is the most hyped game of all time, and that comes with pressure. Fans are analyzing everything from awkward animations to the fact that Jason doesn’t seem masculine enough.
There are also practical complaints. The physical-disc controversy has been raised, and the pricing has been questioned. Fans have noted a trailer showing a character reaching into a fridge and grabbing an invisible beer, which has drawn attention. The piece describes this as “overanalyzing everything about Grand Theft Auto VI.”
The Combat and the Handholding
The piece spends considerable time on the design choices that have drawn ire. Marvel’s Wolverine’s combat is praised. It lets players learn combos naturally, which is a strength. But the game’s guidance system has been criticized. There are scent trails that lead players directly to where they need to go, which seems redundant for a linear game. Characters constantly tell players what to do, and collectibles have bright icons that notify them.
The narrative is harder to critique. Some fans love the changed origin story, while others hate the revamped differences. The subjectivity of storytelling means there is no consensus on the plot. The guidance system, however, is a structural issue that affects everyone who plays it.
The Expectation Machine
The piece argues that the outrage is partly a product of the hype machine. Games that are heavily promoted tend to face more scrutiny when they ship. Marvel’s Wolverine was expected to be great, and it fell short. Grand Theft Auto VI is expected to be the biggest game of 2026, and every trailer is examined for flaws.
The comparison between the two games is instructive. Marvel’s Wolverine is a good game that failed to meet expectations. Grand Theft Auto VI is a game that hasn’t shipped yet, but fans are treating it as though it has. The piece wonders whether the outrage is deserved, and the answer is complicated.
The Bigger Problem
The piece suggests that the criticism extends beyond the games themselves. The gaming community has become more critical than most fans in other mediums. The outrage is expanding beyond the industry and finding its way into the culture of the fans. The piece frames this as an “all-time high in 2026.”
Key Facts Box
- Marvel’s Wolverine: Announced in 2021, released this year
- Grand Theft Auto VI: Set in Vice City, not out yet
- Red Dead Redemption 2: Released eight years ago
- Insomniac’s track record: Several titles among the best games of the 2010s
- Marvel’s Wolverine’s reception: Lowest-rated title in a while, per the piece
Release Timeline
| Game | Status |
|---|---|
| Marvel’s Wolverine | Out now |
| Grand Theft Auto VI | Not out yet |
The Verdict
The piece’s central question is whether the outrage is deserved. The answer is that it depends. Marvel’s Wolverine is a good game that failed to live up to expectations, and the criticism of it is fair. Grand Theft Auto VI is a game that hasn’t shipped yet, and the criticism of it is premature.
The bigger problem, according to the piece, is the culture of outrage itself. Gamers are more critical than ever, and that criticism is spreading beyond the industry. The piece argues that this is a symptom of a larger shift in how fans consume media.
The irony is that the most anticipated game of all time hasn’t even shipped, and it is already the subject of intense scrutiny. The fans are ready, and they are not patient.
Source material: “The Intense Reaction to 2026's Biggest Games Exposes an Even Bigger Problem,” Collider.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.