Xi Jinping spent Wednesday in Washington trying to convince Donald Trump that the two countries can avoid a military collision, and the Chinese president laid out a specific plan to get there. During his White House summit, Xi cited the “Thucydides trap” as a risk of military collision between the two superpowers amid rising tensions over artificial intelligence, trade and Taiwan. He proposed strengthening communication, regular military dialogue and improved crisis communication mechanisms to prevent it.
The trap refers to the idea that when a rising power threatens to overtake a ruling power, war becomes almost inevitable. Xi invoked the phrase in his meeting with Trump in Beijing in May, asking the US president how he planned to avoid it. Now he is putting concrete terms behind the warning.
Xi’s Proposal for Peace
Xi said conditions for achieving the rejuvenation of China and making America great again “go hand in hand,” referencing Trump’s political catchphrase. He told Trump that China and the US are different in national conditions but can build mutual trust through candid dialogue. He urged peaceful coexistence, saying both militaries should maintain regular dialog and improve crisis communication mechanisms.
He also proposed inviting 100,000 young Americans to visit China on student exchanges. The gesture is symbolic, but it is also a practical attempt to build familiarity between the two peoples. Xi wants American students seeing China firsthand, rather than relying on media portrayals.
The trap “can be overcome” with the right conditions in place, Xi said. That is the core of his argument: the danger is not inevitable, but it requires constant effort to manage. His proposal includes strengthening communication, regular military dialogue and improved crisis communication mechanisms. Each element addresses a specific gap in the relationship.
Trump’s Trade Agenda
Trump welcomed Xi and his wife, Peng Liyuan, calling him the first Chinese leader to make a second state visit to the US. The previous visit occurred in 2015 under Barack Obama. Trump said he had forged “a truly great friendship” with Xi. He noted that teams have been working on a more balanced trading relationship, including new market access for American farmers and ranchers.
The trade angle is where the two presidents diverge. Xi wants to manage military risk; Trump wants better terms for American businesses. The two goals are not mutually exclusive, but they are not identical either.
Trump called AI “super intelligence,” a term he introduced in his UN speech. Xi said he and Trump have respect for each other and built personal rapport, staying in touch. He asked Trump to work together to steer the China-US relationship toward the future.
The White House ceremony included both countries’ national anthems and flanking by spouses.
The Dinner Guest List
Trump hosted a state dinner where tech leaders attended, including Nvidia’s Jensen Huang, Meta’s Mark Zuckerberg, Apple’s Tim Cook, Elon Musk and OpenAI’s Sam Altman. The list reads like a who’s who of the AI industry, and their presence underscores the stakes. These companies are building the technologies that could trigger the very conflict Xi is trying to prevent.
The dinner was a chance to put faces to names. It was also a chance to signal intent: the US is investing heavily in AI, and it wants China to know that. The presence of Musk adds a note of unpredictability to the proceedings.
The Truce That Expired
A truce agreed in South Korea last year expired in November but was extended until February, per US treasury secretary Scott Bessent. Analysts say the extension suggests Trump wants to keep pressure on Xi ahead of the G20 summit in Miami.
The extension is significant. It means the two sides are still talking, even as tensions rise. The truce was not renewed indefinitely; it has a specific end date.
The G20 summit in Miami is the next major test. Both presidents will be in the same room, facing each other directly.
The Numbers Behind the Diplomacy
- The truce agreed in South Korea last year expired in November but was extended until February.
- The previous visit occurred in 2015 under Barack Obama.
- The student exchange proposal would invite 100,000 young Americans to visit China.
- Chinese imports continue to surge into the US, with China on track for a $1tn trade deficit for the second year running.
The $1tn figure is striking. It shows that despite the trade war, Chinese goods keep coming. The deficit is not shrinking; it is holding steady at a massive level.
What This Means for the Future
The summit was a step. It was not a breakthrough, but it was a conversation. Xi offered terms for avoiding conflict, and Trump responded with trade demands. The two sides are talking, and that is more than can be said for many other disputes around the world.
The student exchange proposal is the clearest example of Xi’s soft-power approach. He is betting that personal connections will reduce the chances of war. Whether it works is another matter entirely.
The truce extension is a stopgap measure. It buys time, but the underlying tensions remain unresolved.
The two presidents spoke openly about their relationship and their goals. Trump emphasized trade and friendship; Xi emphasized mutual benefit and dialogue. Both leaders described a partnership that needs constant care.
The path forward is negotiation, not confrontation. The question is whether both sides can stay patient long enough to find it.
Where the paper stands
The paper backs neither side on the Thucydides trap framing, but on AI it backs narrow rules against direct harm and disclosure of hidden safety failures, while opposing federal licensing and slowdowns that would freeze today’s leaders in place and lock out challengers. The proposal for regular military dialogue and improved crisis communication mechanisms addresses real gaps in the relationship, but the paper would want any such arrangements to be voluntary, not imposed by regulation that favors the largest firms.
The dinner guest list shows who holds the stakes. Nvidia, Meta, Apple, Elon Musk and OpenAI are building the technologies that could trigger the very conflict Xi is trying to prevent. The paper wants those companies to operate without federal licensing or slowdowns that would freeze today’s leaders in place and lock out whoever would have challenged them. Instead, the paper supports narrow rules against direct harm, such as forcing companies to disclose safety failures they hid.
The paper would watch for any move toward federal licensing or slowdowns, which it opposes because they freeze today’s leaders in place and lock out challengers. The reader should also watch for signs that big companies are hiding safety failures, since the paper supports disclosure of those hidden failures.
Source material: “At Trump meeting, Xi Jinping lays out terms to avoid US-China military conflict,” The Guardian.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.