47 Ronin arrives as a $151.8 million gamble that never pays off. Carl Rinsch directs this 2013 historical fantasy action film in his sole theatrical directorial effort, working from a script by Chris Morgan and Hossein Amini. The story is drawn from Chūshingura, the fictionalized account of the forty-seven rōnin — real masterless samurai in 18th-century Japan who avenged their lord Asano Naganori by battling his rival Kira Yoshinaka.
The film stars Keanu Reeves as Kai, alongside Hiroyuki Sanada, Tadanobu Asano, Rinko Kikuchi and Ko Shibasaki. It runs 119 minutes. It is a drama, an action picture and a fantasy, and it is bad at all three.
Trailer, via Universal Pictures UK.
Keanu Reeves as Kai
Kai is a teenage English-Japanese outcast, found in the woods near Wakkanai and adopted by Lord Asano, the benevolent ruler of the Akō Domain. He loves Asano’s daughter, Mika, despite the scorn the domain’s samurai hold for his mixed ancestry.
Reeves plays the part with the same stillness he has brought to better films. Here the stillness reads as absence. Kai is written as the outsider who sees what the samurai cannot, but the script gives him little to see and less to say.
The film’s tagline promises courage, loyalty and honor. It delivers a man standing near those things.
A Kirin, a Kitsune and a Golem
Lord Kira, the Shōgun’s master of ceremonies, wants Akō. He has help: Mizuki, a shapeshifting kitsune played by Rinko Kikuchi. She sends a kirin to kill Asano and his men on a hunting trip. Kai takes up a fallen sword and slays the monster. He then sees a white fox with different-colored eyes.
That detail matters later. When the Shōgun Tokugawa Tsunayoshi visits Akō, Kai spots a concubine with the same multi-colored eyes and knows her for an enchantress. He warns Asano’s principal counselor, Oishi. Oishi dismisses him.
Kira then arranges a duel for the Shōgun’s entertainment between his best warrior — a golem — and Asano’s chosen combatant. Mizuki uses magic to take the man down before the contest. Kai dons his armor and fights in his stead, but is unmasked during the duel. The Shōgun orders him severely beaten.
The fantasy elements are not woven into the revenge story. They are laid on top of it, and they smother it.
Lord Asano Performs Seppuku
That night, Mizuki bewitches Asano into believing Kira is raping Mika. Asano attacks the unarmed lord. He is sentenced to death and compelled to perform seppuku to preserve his honor.
The Shōgun gives Kira domain over Akō. He decrees that Mika must marry Kira, but grants her one year of mourning before the wedding. He brands Oishi and his men rōnin and forbids them from avenging Asano. Kira imprisons Oishi and sells Kai into slavery.
Nearly a year later, Oishi’s captors release him, believing him harmless. He has realized Kira used sorcery to frame Asano. Oishi and his son Chikara reunite the scattered rōnin and rescue Kai.
The cast includes:
- Hiroyuki Sanada as Kuranosuke Ôishi
- Ko Shibasaki as Mika
- Tadanobu Asano as Lord Kira
- Min Tanaka as Lord Asano
- Rinko Kikuchi as Witch
- Jin Akanishi as Chikara
- Masayoshi Haneda as Yasuno
- Hiroshi Sogabe as Hazama
- Takato Yonemoto as Basho
- Shû Nakajima as Horibe
- Hiroshi Yamada as Hara
That is a deep bench of Japanese talent. The film does not know what to do with most of it.
Budapest, Shepperton and the Reshoots
Development began in 2008. Rinsch, who had previously filmed “visual and stylish” commercials for various companies, signed on to direct the following year. Five Japanese actors were cast alongside Reeves between March and April 2011. Filming took place in Budapest that same month before moving to Shepperton Studios in England. Additional filming in Japan was planned. Reshoots took place in London in August 2012.
You can feel the seams. A production that moves from Hungary to England to planned work in Japan, then returns for reshoots more than a year later, rarely coheres. 47 Ronin does not.
The film premiered in Japan on December 6, 2013. Universal Pictures released it in the United States on December 25, 2013, in both 3D and 2D. It was panned by critics and grossed $151.8 million in total.
Little Resemblance to Its Basis
The source material is one of Japan’s most durable stories. Chūshingura has been adapted for the stage and screen for centuries because its core — loyalty, patience, a long wait before a just strike — needs no embellishment.
47 Ronin bears little resemblance to its historical basis compared to previous adaptations. It is instead a stylized interpretation set, in the film’s own framing, “in a world of witches and giants.”
That choice is the whole problem. The forty-seven rōnin are compelling because they are men who lose everything and wait a year to answer for it. Add a shapeshifting fox, a kirin and a golem, and the waiting stops meaning anything. The trials Kai and Oishi face are supernatural obstacles, not moral ones. A warrior who beats a monster has proved he can beat a monster. A warrior who starves for a year has proved something harder.
The film does not trust the second thing. So it reaches for the first, and the first is cheaper.
What $151.8 Million Bought
A global gross of $151.8 million against a production that shot on two continents and returned for reshoots is not a win. The reported figure is a total gross, not a profit, and the film’s own numbers do not suggest it made its money back.
The failure is not mysterious. 47 Ronin takes a story that has survived for centuries on the strength of its restraint and buries it under spectacle. Rinsch came from commercials, and the film often looks like one — composed, decorative, and empty at the center.
Reeves is the lead, but the film never decides what Kai is for. He is an outcast, then a monster-slayer, then a slave, then a rescuer. None of it accumulates. Sanada, a genuinely commanding actor, is given the emotional weight of the revenge plot and almost no room to carry it. Kikuchi’s Witch is the most interesting presence on screen, and the film treats her as a plot device.
The real question is why this story needed a fantasy frame at all. It did not. The rōnin’s loyalty was always the fantasy — men who gave up their names, their homes and their lives for a dead lord. That is stranger and stronger than any kirin.
47 Ronin is not the worst version of this story. It is the most expensive one, and the most confused. It has a witch, a golem and a white fox with different-colored eyes, and it has no idea what any of them are doing there.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
