The Grinch stole Christmas, and Jim Carrey stole the movie. That is the problem. Carrey’s manic energy is the only thing worth seeing in this adaptation of Dr. Seuss’s tale, and even he cannot save the mess around him.
Trailer, via YouTube Movies.
Carrey’s Performance
Carrey plays the Grinch with a desperate, unhinged glee that carries scenes the script cannot. He commits fully to the role without relying on dated comparisons. The physical comedy is sharp. When the movie works, it works because Carrey is doing his best work.
The Rest of the Film
Everything else falls apart. The plot is thin, the jokes land flat, and the supporting cast is wasted. Taylor Momsen is fine as Cindy Lou Who, but she is buried under a script that treats her like a side note rather than the girl who changes the Grinch’s heart. The songs are forgettable, and the villainous Mayor of Whoville is a toothless cartoon.
“We don’t need a reason to celebrate.”
That line sums up the film’s problem. It wants to be a festive sing-along, but it never earns the joy it promises.
What Works
The opening sequence is the strongest stretch. Carrey’s expressions sell the Grinch’s disgust with the holiday, and the chase through Whoville is a genuine thrill. These moments are few and far between, but they show what the film could have been.
What Doesn’t Work
The middle section drags. The Grinch’s plan to steal Christmas is explained poorly, and the townspeople’s reaction to his scheme is underwritten. The film tries to build tension, but it never gets there. The resolution is rushed, and the emotional payoff feels hollow.
The Verdict
Jim Carrey’s performance is the highlight, but the film around him is a mess. It is a pale imitation of the original story, and it fails to capture the warmth and wonder that made the book beloved.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
