Sid Meier’s Civilization V asks a simple question: after four previous versions, can the series still surprise? The answer is yes, but only partly. The 2010 release for Linux, PC and Mac trades the stacked units of past games for a new system built around hexes, and that change carries the whole experience. Whether it improves on what came before depends on which part of the game you are playing.
Trailer, via Gamehelper.
The New Look of War
The biggest change in Sid Meier’s Civilization V is how battles unfold. Units now sit side by side across a hex grid rather than stacking atop one another. This looks cleaner on screen and forces players to think about flanking and positioning in a way earlier games did not demand. The result is combat that feels less like a button press and more like a tactical puzzle.
The change also affects city management. Cities now occupy a single hex, which means building a city near water or mountains changes its growth potential. Players who want a strong economy need to plan ahead, placing cities in spots that offer food, production and trade bonuses. This shift moves the game away from pure conquest and toward careful planning.
Not everyone agrees the change was for the better. Some longtime fans miss the old stacking system, saying it made battles feel more chaotic and rewarding. That debate continues, but the hex system is the defining feature of this version, and it shapes almost every decision a player makes.
Building a City
Building a city in Sid Meier’s Civilization V requires a different kind of thought than in earlier games. Each city occupies a single hex, so placement matters more than it did before. A city built next to a river gains food and trade, while one near hills gains production. The game rewards players who study the terrain before committing to a location.
The city interface itself is cleaner than in past entries. Icons are larger, and menus are easier to navigate. That matters during the middle and late game, when managing dozens of cities becomes the main task. The game does not make the transition easy, but it does make it clearer.
City improvements are also simpler to manage. Players can build wonders, military buildings and economic structures without juggling multiple screens. This streamlining helps keep the pace of play steady, even as the game grows more complex over time.
The World Beyond Your Empire
The world map in Sid Meier’s Civilization V is dense with details. Rivers, forests, deserts and mountains all exist, and each offers a different strategic value. Players who understand the landscape can find shortcuts, choke points and resource-rich areas that give them an edge. Those who ignore it often pay the price.
Diplomacy has been improved, though not revolutionized. Leaders of rival empires now have distinct personalities, and their reactions to your actions are more varied than in earlier games. This makes alliances feel more meaningful, since a leader’s response to a request for help can depend on how you treated them in the past. It adds a layer of uncertainty that was missing from some older entries in the series.
Trade routes have also been expanded. Players can now build roads between cities, creating chains of commerce that boost production and income. Managing these routes becomes a second job alongside military strategy, and it rewards players who are willing to plan ahead.
The Pace of Play
Sid Meier’s Civilization V plays faster than its predecessors in some ways, slower in others. Early game turns move quickly, thanks to the cleaner city interface and the streamlined unit system. Later turns, especially those involving large empires, can slow down considerably as the number of cities and units increases.
This is a common complaint among longtime players. The game’s difficulty curve is steep, and the late game can feel overwhelming. Some players find themselves spending hours managing dozens of cities, wondering if the payoff is worth the effort.
The game does offer a solution to this problem. A new “end-game” feature allows players to speed up turns once the game enters its final stages, compressing the remaining rounds into a shorter window. This helps keep the late game from dragging, though it does not fix the underlying complexity.
What Works Well
Several features stand out as clear improvements over past games in the series:
- The hex-based combat system, which forces players to think tactically about positioning
- The single-hex city model, which rewards careful planning of settlement locations
- The improved diplomacy system, with leaders who react more realistically to player actions
- The streamlined city interface, which makes managing multiple cities less cumbersome
These changes add up to a game that feels fresh in many respects, even for players who have spent hundreds of hours on earlier entries. The core loop remains the same: build, explore, conquer, wonder. But the details of how that loop operates have shifted significantly, and for the most part, that shift is for the better.
What Falls Short
Not everything in Sid Meier’s Civilization V succeeds. The game’s AI can be uneven, sometimes making decisions that feel random rather than strategic. This is a persistent problem across the series, and this entry does not fully escape it. Multiplayer support is solid, but it is not the focus of the game, and some players may find the online experience lacking compared to other strategy titles.
The campaign itself can feel repetitive at times, especially on higher difficulties, where the game demands a relentless focus on production and research that can grow tedious. Some players may also find the late game overwhelming, with too many systems demanding attention at once. These issues are not fatal, but they do mean the game is not perfect.
The game rewards players who study the terrain before committing to a location.
How It Compares
Sid Meier’s Civilization V sits between two other major entries in the series. It borrows ideas from both, but it also breaks from them in significant ways. The hex system is the clearest example of this. By moving away from stacked units, the game changes how combat unfolds and how cities are placed, and that shift carries through the entire design.
The comparison is useful for anyone considering whether to pick up this version or stick with an older one. The core systems have changed enough that a player familiar with earlier games will notice the differences immediately. Whether those differences improve the experience is a matter of personal taste.
Final Word
Sid Meier’s Civilization V is a solid entry in a long-running series. It improves on several aspects of its predecessors while leaving others largely untouched. The hex-based combat system is a standout feature, and the single-hex city model adds a layer of planning that was absent from earlier games. The game is not without flaws, but its strengths outweigh its weaknesses.
For players who have followed the series from the beginning, this version offers a fresh way to approach the familiar task of building an empire. For newcomers, it provides a strong introduction to the genre, with a clean interface and a clear path forward. The game is not perfect, but it is a worthy addition to the library of any strategy gamer.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
