Arnold Schwarzenegger plays three roles in “Last Action Hero,” and the film spends its entire 131 minutes trying to prove that none of them should exist. It is a satire of the action genre, a fantasy comedy, and a failed attempt to win back a franchise audience that had grown tired of the same formula. It fails at all three.
Trailer, via Sony Pictures Entertainment.
The Double World
The film’s premise is simple: 10-year-old Danny Madigan, a boy from a crime-ridden area of New York City, finds solace in watching action movies. After his father’s death, he becomes obsessed with a series about Los Angeles cop Jack Slater, played by Schwarzenegger. Nick, the theater’s owner and projectionist, gives Danny a golden ticket once owned by Harry Houdini. During an early screening of Jack Slater IV, the ticket stub transports Danny into the fictional world, interrupting Slater during a car chase.
The film’s central joke is that the fictional world and our world are the same world, just viewed from different perspectives. The audience watches Danny’s journey into the movie, while the characters within the movie watch Danny as an outsider. This should be a clever conceit. It is not.
Benedict’s Escape
The main antagonist of Jack Slater IV, Mr. Benedict, is a ruthless assassin played by Charles Dance. He escapes into the real world, and the plot revolves around his attempt to murder the rival mob with a lethal gas. The twist is that Danny, the boy from the audience, knows more about the film’s plot than Slater himself. Danny guides Slater to Vivaldi’s mansion, recognizing it from the start of the movie.
This is the film’s most promising idea. It could have been a sharp commentary on how audiences know films better than the people in them. Instead, it becomes a mess of exposition and a running gag about a cartoon cat detective named Whiskers who appears in the fictional world as a sidekick.
Slapstick and Silliness
The film tries to be a comedy first, a satire second, and an action movie third. It fails at all three. The jokes are broad and unfunny, with a running gag about Tony Vivaldi’s butchering of common phrases. Vivaldi is played by Anthony Quinn, and the film leans on his accent and mannerisms for comic relief.
There are also extended sequences of physical comedy, including a chase scene where Danny is chased by hired guns in the real world while Slater is chased by fictional villains in the movie world. The staging is often clumsy, and the jokes fall flat. The film’s attempts at cleverness are undermined by its own excess.
Cast and Carney
The cast is as large as the film’s ambitions. Arnold Schwarzenegger plays Detective Jack Slater, the fictional LAPD officer, and also plays himself as the actor portraying Jack Slater. F. Murray Abraham plays John Practice, Jack’s friend, who is revealed to be a traitor. Robert Prosky plays Nick, the projectionist. Tom Noonan plays the Ripper, the main antagonist of Jack Slater III, and also appears as himself at the Jack Slater IV premiere.
Bridgette Wilson plays Whitney, Slater’s daughter, and also plays Meredith Caprice, the actress who plays Whitney in the Slater films. Mercedes Ruehl plays Irene Madigan, Danny’s mother. Art Carney plays Frank Slater, Jack’s second cousin, and this is Carney’s final film role.
The film’s attempt to juggle all these roles is exhausting. It asks the audience to keep track of who is in the movie and who is in the audience, and it never quite settles on which perspective matters.
The Cult Following
Since its release, “Last Action Hero” has gained a cult following. Some have noted it as underrated in Schwarzenegger’s catalogue. That is generous. The film is a disappointment, both critical and commercial, and its reputation should reflect that.
It is not a good movie, but it is not entirely without merit. The premise is clever, the cast is game, and there are moments where the satire lands. But they are moments, not a structure. The film never commits to its own ideas.
The Verdict
The film’s failure is not a flaw. It is a feature. It is a movie that could not decide what it wanted to be and failed to commit to any of its promises. It is not a good satire of action movies, not a good comedy, and not a good action film. It is a film that tried to be all three and became none of them.
The film’s attempt to bridge the gap between the audience and the screen is a genuine idea. It is just badly executed. The jokes are broad, the action is silly, and the stakes are never earned.
The film has a reputation for cult status, and that reputation is built on a film that failed at everything it tried. That is not a compliment. It is a warning. The movie is not good, but it is not without its moments.
| Element | Strength | Weakness |
|---|---|---|
| Premise | Clever concept of a boy entering a film world | Unearned stakes and lazy exposition |
| Cast | Game performances across the board | Overstuffed cast dilutes focus |
| Comedy | Broad gags about Vivaldi’s butchering of phrases | Rarely land and feel forced |
| Action | Chase sequences mixing real and fictional worlds | Clumsy staging and unfunny |
| Tone | Confused between satire, comedy, and action | Never commits to a single sensibility |
The film’s best moments are its most human ones. Danny’s relationship with his mother, Irene, played by Mercedes Ruehl, is the most grounded part of the film. The scenes between Danny and Slater, where the boy’s knowledge of the film’s plot clashes with the detective’s ignorance, are the most promising. But these moments are buried under a mountain of excess.
This is a film that failed to commit. It tried to be a satire, a comedy, and an action movie, and it succeeded at none of them. It is a movie that is best remembered for its failures, not its successes. It is not a good movie, and it is not worth your time.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
