Chuck and Larry are firefighters, and they are meant to be best friends who will do anything for each other. That is the premise of “I Now Pronounce You Chuck & Larry,” a 2007 buddy comedy directed by Dennis Dugan from a screenplay by Barry Fanaro, Alexander Payne, and Jim Taylor. The movie stars Adam Sandler as Chuck Levine and Kevin James as Larry Valentine, two New York City firefighters who pretend to be a same-sex couple so Larry can secure domestic partner benefits for his two children.
The setup is simple and potentially touching. Larry is a widower whose wife died, and he cannot name his children as primary beneficiaries on his life insurance policy. He turns to Chuck, his closest friend, to pose as his lover. Chuck agrees out of loyalty. The trouble starts when a bureaucrat investigates the sudden partnership, and the two men are forced to fake domestic bliss to prove they are really together.
Trailer, via Universal Pictures.
The Setup Works, Then It Doesn’t
The early scenes establish the bond between Chuck and Larry. They are the pride of their Brooklyn firehouse, Engine 506/Ladder 223. During a sweep of a burned building, a floor collapses on Chuck, and Larry rescues him. Chuck vows to repay him. Larry, experiencing an epiphany from the incident, tries to increase his life insurance but finds that a paperwork lapse after his wife Paula’s death one year earlier prevents him from naming his children, Eric and Tori, as primary beneficiaries.
The insurance company representative suggests Larry find a new spouse. Inspired by a newspaper article about domestic partnerships, Larry asks Chuck to enter a civil union with him. Chuck is reminded of his debt to Larry and agrees. They enter a domestic partnership, and Chuck becomes Larry’s primary beneficiary. The plan works until investigators inquire about the abrupt partnership, suspecting fraud.
At that point, the movie should pivot into a sharp comedy about identity, loyalty, and the absurdity of bureaucratic suspicion. Instead, it leans into broad physical humor and crude jokes about being gay, and the tone shifts from a clever premise to a predictable one.
The Wedding Trip to Niagara Falls
To prove their commitment, lawyer Alex McDonough, played by Jessica Biel, suggests they have a formal wedding ceremony. The pair travel to Niagara Falls, Ontario, Canada, for a quick same-sex marriage at a wedding chapel. Chuck moves in with Larry and his children. Alex invites the couple to a gay benefit costume party.
The party scene is where the movie’s central problem becomes visible. Chuck is provoked into punching the leader of a group of homophobic protesters, and the local news picks up the incident. Suddenly, their apparent homosexuality and marriage are revealed. Chuck and Larry are heckled, their fellow FDNY firefighters abandon them, and their captain, Phineas J. Tucker, refuses to protect them.
The Problem With the Jokes
The film’s humor is built on a narrow foundation: Chuck and Larry are straight, and everyone around them assumes they are gay. That is funny once. It is less funny when the movie repeats it across an entire runtime, especially when the jokes about being gay are delivered in a way that feels mean-spirited rather than clever.
The film also leans heavily on physical comedy, with Chuck and Larry pretending to be a loving couple in public. This includes awkward embraces, fake caresses, and exaggerated displays of affection. The jokes about being gay are often delivered through these physical gestures, which can come across as mocking rather than humorous.
Supporting Cast, Mixed Results
The supporting cast is solid. Dan Aykroyd plays Captain Tucker, and Ving Rhames plays Fred G. Duncan, an angry firefighter who surprises Chuck by admitting he has not felt comfortable discussing the issue with him. Steve Buscemi plays Clinton Fitzer, and Nicholas Turturro plays Renaldo Pinera. Allen Covert plays Steve, and Rachel Dratch plays the Benefits Supervisor. Richard Chamberlain plays Councilman Banks, and Nick Swardson plays Kevin McDonough. Jamie Chung makes her film debut in a minor role.
The film’s weakest link is its treatment of the gay community. The party scene is a parade of stereotypes, with guests dressed in flamboyant outfits and behaving in exaggerated ways. The protesters outside the party are portrayed as ridiculous and easily defeated. The film fails to engage with the real-world issues faced by gay individuals, instead treating their lives as a series of punchlines.
The Numbers Tell the Story
“I Now Pronounce You Chuck & Larry” was released in the United States on July 20, 2007, as Sandler’s first role in a Universal Pictures film since Bulletproof in 1996. It grossed $187 million against an $85 million budget, which suggests the film was a commercial success despite its critical reception.
The film received generally negative reviews from critics. Its score reflects the disappointment many viewers felt at a premise that could have been sharp and clever but instead became broad and unfunny.
What Went Wrong
The problem is not the premise. The problem is the execution. “I Now Pronounce You Chuck & Larry” treats being gay as a joke rather than a lived experience. It is a film about two straight men pretending to be gay, but it never stops to consider what it means to actually be gay. The jokes about being gay are delivered through physical comedy and crude humor, and they land flat.
The film also suffers from a lack of character development. Chuck and Larry are introduced as loyal friends, but the movie spends little time exploring what makes them that way. Their relationship is defined by the insurance scheme rather than by who they are as individuals.
Comparison Table
| Element | Strength | Weakness |
|---|---|---|
| Premise | Clever and relatable | Premise is wasted on broad, unfunny execution |
| Humor | Physical comedy, timing | Relies too heavily on crude jokes about being gay |
| Character development | Limited | Chuck and Larry feel like props rather than people |
| Supporting cast | Solid performances | Party scene relies on stereotypes |
| Overall tone | Begins promisingly | Loses focus and momentum |
Key Facts Box
- Title: I Now Pronounce You Chuck & Larry
- Director: Dennis Dugan
- Screenplay: Barry Fanaro, Alexander Payne, Jim Taylor
- Starring: Adam Sandler, Kevin James, Jessica Biel
- Release date: July 20, 2007
- Runtime: 115 minutes
- Budget: $85 million
- Box office: $187 million
- Critical score: generally negative
The film’s score reflects a movie that had a great idea but failed to deliver on it. The premise of two straight men pretending to be gay to secure benefits is a sharp one, but the execution is broad and unfunny. The jokes about being gay are delivered through physical comedy and crude humor, and they land flat.
“I Now Pronounce You Chuck & Larry” is a missed opportunity. It has a premise that could have been sharp and clever, but instead it became broad and unfunny. The film’s score is accurate.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
