Phryne Fisher is a private detective who walks into a room and owns it. That much is clear from the first frame of Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries, the 2012 ABC series that brought Kerry Greenwood’s novels to television. Essie Davis plays Phryne as a woman who dresses like a fashion plate, wields a pearl-handled pistol, and talks like a woman who has never had to apologize for being herself. The show is a detective drama, but it treats the detective as a spectacle — and it mostly pulls it off.
The show follows Phryne through the jazz clubs and back lanes of late 1920s Melbourne. She fights injustice with her pistol and her wit, leaving a trail of admirers in her wake. The synopsis promises that she makes sure she enjoys every moment of her lucky life, and the show delivers on that promise. This is a show about a woman who knows exactly what she wants and rarely stops to explain why she wants it.
Trailer, via AcornMediaUS.
Phryne’s Past and the Missing Sister
The central wound of the show is the kidnapping and death of Phryne’s younger sister Janey. The two were watching a circus when Janey disappeared, and Phryne believes she should have done more to save her. That guilt runs through the first season, a constant shadow that the show never fully resolves. It gives Phryne a reason to fight, even when the cases themselves are purely professional.
The show handles the theme with a light touch. It is there, it is mentioned, and it shapes how Phryne approaches every investigation. She is not a cold professional — she is a woman who carries a personal loss with her everywhere she goes, and the show trusts the audience to feel that weight even when the camera focuses on a pearl-handled pistol.
The Cast and Their Companions
Essie Davis is the engine of the show. She plays Phryne with a mix of charm and steel that makes her impossible to ignore. Her performance carries the show through its lighter moments and its darker ones. Phryne is a woman who can be cruel and kind within the same conversation, and Davis sells both sides of her without ever losing the character’s essential spark.
Ashleigh Cummings plays Dorothy “Dot” Williams, Phryne’s assistant and loyal companion. Dot is the moral center of the show — she is the one who questions Phryne’s methods and the one who picks up the pieces when Phryne leaves a mess. Hugo Johnstone-Burt plays Hugh Collins, Phryne’s loyal friend and occasional ally. Together, the three form a triangle of loyalty that grounds Phryne’s more flamboyant adventures.
Nathan Page plays Detective John “Jack” Robinson. He is the official law enforcement presence, the man who shows up to clean up after Phryne’s work. His relationship with Phryne is tense — he disapproves of her methods, but he respects her instincts. The show uses their friction to keep the procedural elements grounded, even as it lets Phryne operate outside the law.
The World of 1920s Melbourne
The show is set in late 1920s Melbourne, a world of jazz clubs, corsets, and prohibition-era vice. The production design is meticulous — the streets look lived-in, the clubs look smoky, and the costumes look expensive. The show uses the period as more than just a backdrop. It is a world of class division, sexual freedom, and political unrest, and Phryne moves through it with ease.
The show also takes time to explore the city itself. The locations are used as characters — the back lanes, the jazz clubs, the grand houses of the wealthy. The show never lets the setting become static. It is a world that is alive, and Phryne is the one who knows its corners better than anyone else.
The Cases and Their Victims
The show is a murder mystery, and the mysteries are generally well constructed. The cases are varied — some involve theft, some involve blackmail, some involve murder. The show rarely repeats itself, and each case offers a new angle on the city and its inhabitants.
The victims are often women, and the show does not treat the crimes against them as trivial. It is a show about a woman who solves crimes, and it does not shy away from the violence done to its victims. The show balances the darkness of its investigations with the lightness of Phryne’s personality, and the contrast works in its favor.
The show also includes a running thread about Phryne’s past. The death of her sister Janey hangs over her, and the show returns to it periodically. It is a wound that never heals, and it shapes how Phryne approaches every case. The show uses this history to deepen her character without letting it define her.
The Comedy and Its Limits
The show is described as a detective comedy drama, and that label is accurate. There is humor in the show — Phryne’s wit, her disdain for authority, her relationships with her companions. The humor is not slapstick, and it is not mean-spirited. It is a show that knows when to laugh and when to be serious, and it manages that balance most of the time.
But the comedy is not always consistent. Some episodes lean harder into the lightness than others, and the show occasionally loses focus on the case at hand. The humor can also be dated — the show is full of jokes about gender roles and social norms, and some of them land better than others. The show is a product of its time, and that time is the early 2010s.
The show’s tone is also shaped by its lead. Phryne is a woman who is comfortable in her own skin, and that comfort is infectious. The show trusts the audience to enjoy her, and it rarely explains itself. The result is a show that is consistently entertaining, even when it is not at its best.
The Legacy and Its Spin-Off
Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries ran for three seasons, with 34 episodes in total. It first aired on 24 February 2012 and concluded on 22 December 2013. The show was created by Deb Cox and Fiona Eagger, and it is based on Kerry Greenwood’s historical mystery novels. The show has been bought by broadcasters in 120 countries and territories worldwide.
The show’s success led to a spin-off, Ms Fisher’s Modern Murder Mysteries, which aired in 2019. It also led to a feature film, Miss Fisher and the Crypt of Tears, released in February 2020. The franchise has grown beyond the original series.
| Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries | Ms Fisher’s Modern Murder Mysteries | |
|---|---|---|
| Setting | Late 1920s Melbourne | Contemporary Melbourne |
| Lead | Phryne Fisher | Phryne Fisher |
| Network | ABC | ABC |
| Status | Completed (3 seasons) | Ongoing |
Both extend the universe of the original show.
What Works Best
The show succeeds when it trusts its lead. Phryne is a character who demands attention, and the show gives her plenty of it. Essie Davis is the reason the show works — she plays Phryne with a mix of charm and steel that makes her impossible to ignore. The show’s best episodes are the ones where Phryne is at her most confident, and those episodes are frequent.
The show also succeeds when it balances its tones. It is a comedy-drama, and it knows when to be funny and when to be serious. The show never takes itself too seriously, and that lightness is part of what makes it watchable. The show is a guilty pleasure, and it is proud of that label.
The show also succeeds when it uses its setting. The world of late 1920s Melbourne is rich and detailed, and the show uses it to ground its mysteries. The show’s production design is meticulous, and the world feels lived-in. The show is a period piece that never becomes a museum exhibit.
What Needs Work
The show’s weakest moments come when it leans too heavily on its lightness. Some episodes are funnier than others, and the show occasionally loses focus on the case at hand. The humor can also be dated — the show is full of jokes about gender roles and social norms, and some of them land better than others. The show is a product of its time, and that time is the early 2010s.
The show’s weakest moments also come when it forgets its lead. Phryne is the reason the show works, and the show is at its best when it puts her front and center. The show occasionally lets other characters take the spotlight, and those episodes are less compelling. The show is a Phryne show, and it should remember that.
The show’s weakest moments also come when it forgets its world. The setting of late 1920s Melbourne is rich and detailed, and the show uses it to ground its mysteries. The show is at its best when it lets the world breathe. The show is a period piece, and it should remember that.
Ranking the Seasons
- The first season sets up the world and the characters — it introduces Phryne, Dot, Hugh, and Jack, and it establishes the show’s tone.
- The second season builds on the first — it deepens the characters and the mysteries, and it introduces new threats.
- The third season wraps up the show — it brings the story to a close, and it ties up loose ends.
The show is a product of its time, and it reflects that time in its themes and its jokes. The show is a period piece, and it should be judged as such. The show is a detective drama, and it should be judged as such. The show is a comedy-drama, and it should be judged as such.
The Verdict
Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries is a show that knows exactly what it is. It is a detective drama dressed up as a costume piece, and it is confident enough to let that contradiction play out. The show is not perfect — the humor is inconsistent, the pacing can drag, and the period trappings sometimes overwhelm the cases themselves. But it is consistently entertaining, and it features one of the most memorable leads in television history.
The show’s legacy is secure. It spawned a spin-off and a feature film. The show is a product of its time, and it wears that identity proudly. It is a show about a woman who refuses to be a damsel, and it is a show that rewards attention.
The show is a guilty pleasure, and it knows it. That is not a weakness — it is a strength. The show is unapologetic about its pleasures, and it asks nothing of the viewer except to enjoy them. That is a rare quality in television, and it is one that Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries earns.
The show is a reminder that entertainment can be smart and stylish without being grim. It is a show that celebrates its lead without diminishing her. It is a show that knows when to be funny and when to be serious, and it manages both with skill.
The show is not a masterpiece, but it is a success. It is a show that delivers what it promises, and it delivers it well. It is a show that is worth watching, and it is a show that is worth remembering.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
