“Burn After Reading” wants to be a Coen brothers comedy about identity theft, corporate espionage, and a man who speaks only in gibberish. It mostly succeeds, but the seams show.
The plot starts with Linda Mayhew (Frances McDormand) and Sherry Purdy (Frances McDormand again) finding a computer disk full of classified information at a gym. They think it contains their life stories. Instead, it holds stolen government secrets, and the chase pulls in everyone from Osment’s gibberish-spouting ex-husband to a British spy who cannot pronounce Washington. The movie’s premise is clever, and the setup moves fast.
Trailer, via Focus Features.
The Disk
The disk itself is the engine of the story. Linda and Sherry believe it belongs to a stranger named Chad Feldheimer, played by George Clooney. They want his life story, not the secrets he has sold. Their confusion drives the early scenes with real energy.
“The disk is not ours.”
That line captures the whole film. Everyone thinks they know what they are looking at, and nobody does.
Frances McDormand
Frances McDormand plays both Linda and Sherry, and the film depends on her ability to make them distinct. She does, mostly. One is sharp and calculating; the other is dim and desperate. The performance carries the middle stretch when the jokes slow.
Clooney’s Chad is less successful. He is meant to be a smooth operator, but the script gives him lines about a “fucking squirrel” that undercut his menace. The character’s arc runs from confident to baffled, and the transition is not always smooth.
Osment’s Gibberish
Tim Blake Nelson’s performance as Osment’s ex-husband is the film’s most committed choice. He speaks in nonsense, and the scene where he explains why is genuinely funny. It also raises the question of whether the film is mocking him or celebrating him. That ambiguity is intentional, and it works more often than it fails.
The Spy
John Malkovich plays the British spy, and his accent is a running joke. He cannot say “Washington,” which becomes a recurring gag. The device is simple, but it lands because the movie commits to it fully.
Plot Holes
The film asks viewers to accept that a disk containing national security secrets can be found at a gym, read by two women who have no idea what it is, and then passed around the city without anyone calling the police. That suspension of disbelief is the movie’s biggest weakness. The story works better as a farce than as a thriller.
Running Order
| Scene | Time |
|---|---|
| Linda and Sherry find the disk | Opening |
| Chad enters the frame | Middle |
| Osment’s ex-husband appears | Late |
| The spy arrives | Late |
| The chase peaks | Climax |
The structure is loose. The movie jumps between characters without always explaining how they got there, and some threads are dropped entirely.
Final Word
“Burn After Reading” is a Coen brothers film, and that means it is smart, cynical, and visually inventive. It also means it is uneven, with jokes that land and jokes that fall flat within the same scene. The film’s best moments come from its cast, especially Frances McDormand’s double performance and Tim Blake Nelson’s committed gibberish. Its worst moments come from a plot that cannot quite support its own ambitions.
The film earns a score of 6.3 out of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
