The tale of a customer who flew into a rage at a Five Guys over the meaning of “plain” has found a wide audience on Reddit. The story earned well over 22,000 upvotes and came close to reaching 3,700 reactions on r/mildlyinfuriating.
User 50calTaco posted a description of an order that took an unexpected turn, shared 17 hours ago. The customer requested “a plain, regular cheeseburger.”. The employee understood the request as a burger with no toppings, following standard fast food convention.
Minutes later, the man returned to the counter visibly annoyed, holding the burger. “You made my food wrong. There’s nothing on it,” he reportedly said. When the employee explained he’d made a plain cheeseburger as requested, the customer replied, “I did. Do you not know what that means? Like a McDonald’s burger.”
A customer was served an incorrect order at a McDonald’s restaurant, and the employee apologized by saying, “Ok I’m sorry about that sir, we’ll remake that for you. What exactly did you want on it?”. They then made a fresh order for the man and asked him to state his actual preferences. The customer responded with annoyance, naming three items: ketchup, lettuce and pickles. None of those ingredients appear on a standard McDonald’s cheeseburger.
The Customer’s Complaint
There was a customer who wanted a plain burger, which is to say no toppings at all. He grew angry when there were no toppings on it, even though he had specifically requested none. When questioned further, he explained that what he wanted was a burger like those served at McDonald’s.
The staff member apologized and prepared a fresh order for the customer. The complaint centered on a burger missing its toppings, and the new version contained all those items, just as the customer had specified.
What Fast Food Workers Know
Thousands of people who used to work at or still work at fast food restaurants found the story resonated deeply with their own lives. Commenters after the post shared accounts that were nearly identical to one another. Among the top responses was one that recounted a customer who insisted a “cheeseburger with no cheese” was fundamentally different from a hamburger, even though the two items are practically the same.
A reader remembered a client who decided to order a “bacon double cheeseburger with no bacon” instead of just requesting the double cheeseburger that was already listed on the menu.
Plain Is an Industry Term
A number of people have noted that “plain” has been around for years as a standard way to describe a meal. Usually it covers just the patty, cheese and bun, with nothing else added. Some people guessed that some customers may think “plain” means “whatever comes standard on the burger,” even though that doesn’t line up with how the word works in any other part of food service.
A reader offered a remark, which began with these words: “The problem is businesses in America cater to this stupidity. OP apologized and made the burger again for free. Here in Spain they would tell you if you want a different burger you need to order and pay for a new one. They definitely would not give you another meal because you didn’t order correctly.”
Comparing What Customers Actually Want
| Order | What the Customer Asked For | What the Customer Said He Wanted |
|---|---|---|
| Plain cheeseburger | No toppings | A McDonald’s burger |
The Key Facts
- More than 22,000 upvotes on Reddit
- Nearly 3,700 comments on r/mildlyinfuriating
- Shared 17 hours ago by user 50calTaco
- The customer wanted ketchup, lettuce and pickles on a plain burger
- The customer referenced a McDonald’s burger in his complaint
The joke holds up well, yet it draws attention to a real problem. Buyers tend to think a simple request for a burger carries no extra meaning, while the business world reads plain as a precise command: nothing added on top. These two ideas don’t match up, and the customer here wanted more than what his own order called for.
He wanted a burger with no toppings. He complained anyway.
The post’s popularity shows that people enjoy seeing other people’s mistakes — especially when those mistakes are as simple as ordering a plain burger and then demanding it be anything but plain.
Source material: “Five Guys Employee Says a Customer Ordered a “Plain” Cheeseburger — Then Got Angry Because “There’s Nothing on It”,” The Daily Dot.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.