Spider-Man: Web of Shadows puts the wall-crawler back on the ground, and that is the whole point. This 2008 action-adventure from Treyarch trades the high-flying acrobatics of earlier Spider-Man titles for a grounded, open-world crawl through Manhattan, and it mostly works. The result is a dark, morally messy game that rewards curiosity over quick reflexes.
The game splits into three versions: a full 3D adventure for PS3, PC and Xbox 360, plus a 2.5D beat-’em-up for PSP and PS2, and a Metroidvania-style platformer for the Nintendo DS. We are reviewing the main version here, the one that lets you walk the streets of New York City and make real choices about who lives and who dies. That version is the best argument for why Spider-Man needed this kind of treatment.
Trailer, via Activision.
A Dark Turn in Manhattan
The story leans heavily on the symbiote invasion, a threat that forces Spider-Man to team up with unlikely allies to save Manhattan. It is darker than most previous Spider-Man games, and the tone sticks. Boss fights are brutal, and the game trusts you to make calls that change how the story ends.
That moral system is the headline feature. Your choices matter, and the game tracks them across the city. Some players will love the weight of those decisions. Others will find the system limited, since the choices are tied to a handful of encounters rather than every street corner.
Walking the Streets
The open-world design is where Web of Shadows succeeds most. Manhattan is dense and busy, and you can swing between buildings, climb walls, or simply walk down the sidewalk. The game rewards exploration, and side quests pop up often enough to keep you moving.
Combat is the weakest link. Enemies swarm, and the camera struggles to keep up, especially in tight spots. The boss fights are the highlight, though. They demand patience and timing, and the game’s best set pieces happen when Spider-Man faces off against larger foes.
Allies and Abilities
Summoning allies during fights is a fun twist. It adds depth to the combat, even if the system is simple. The game also lets you upgrade your gear and abilities, giving you a reason to return to old areas after unlocking new powers.
The pacing drags in the middle stretch. Some missions feel like filler, and the game’s difficulty dips and spikes without warning. That said, the core loop of swinging, fighting and exploring remains strong throughout.
The Moral System’s Limits
The moral choices are the most talked-about part of Web of Shadows, and they deserve scrutiny. The game asks you to make hard calls, but the consequences are sometimes vague. Some players will find that frustrating. Others will appreciate the attempt.
The game also suffers from poor execution in places. Story pacing is uneven, and the camera gets lost in narrow corridors. These are not fatal flaws, but they keep the game from greatness.
A Mixed Reception
Critics at the time split on the game. Some praised the boss fights, the destructive combat, the original story and the open-ended nature. Others took issue with the moral system’s limitations and the poor execution of the storyline. The critical reception was generally mixed to positive, and that holds up today.
Web of Shadows is a solid, ambitious Spider-Man game that pushes the series in a new direction. It is not without faults, but the strengths outweigh the weaknesses.
Key Facts
- Title: Spider-Man: Web of Shadows
- Developer: Treyarch
- Publisher: Activision
- Platforms: PS3, PC (Microsoft Windows), Xbox 360
- Genres: Fighting, Platform, Hack and slash/Beat ’em up, Adventure
- Themes: Action, Open world
- Modes: Single player
- Perspective: Third person
- Release: October 2008
The game was later de-listed and removed from all digital storefronts on January 1, 2014, when most games published by Activision that used the Marvel license were pulled. That move removed the game from online shops, but it did not erase the mark it made on the series.
What stands out now is how Web of Shadows tried to treat Spider-Man as a character with real stakes, not just a guy who swings. The moral system, the open world, the boss fights — all of it points toward a game that wanted to be more than a simple arcade thrill. It succeeded in parts and fell short in others, but it never forgot what made the character worth playing in the first place.
We score Spider-Man: Web of Shadows at 7 of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
