Janice, a manager, confronted an employee who reported her to HR after she called her stupid. A TikTok video posted by @productivitywork documents the exchange, and it has attracted over 157,500 likes and thousands of comments from viewers weighing in on whether firing someone for reporting harassment counts as illegal retaliation. The video includes an overlay that says, “My manager found out I reported her to HR for calling me stupid.”.
The Confrontation
The video shows Janice facing the employee who was making the recording of her. The manager learned that the employee had gone to HR with a complaint about harassment. The employee admits to reporting Janice herself, and that she had submitted a transcript of the meeting where the name-calling took place, because she felt bad about being called stupid in front of her coworkers.
Janice argues that the employee should have handled the issue herself rather than reporting it to HR. She says that by opting to report the incident, the employee is showing that she is still behaving the same way that prompted the original criticism in the first place. Then Janice told her that she would be fired.
The Employee’s Response
The employee argues that doing so would be illegal retaliation for filing an HR complaint. She says she has the right to raise valid complaints, and warns that the dismissal will also be reported to HR. If Janice refuses to yield, the employee has said she can seek advice from an employment attorney.
The Video’s Reach
Thousands of viewers have been drawn into a discussion about workplace complaints and the vague role of human resources, or HR, by the video. Commenters have proposed a range of solutions. One commenter suggested that any future conversations with Janice should be recorded and shared with HR. A second commenter believed the employee should have first spoken to Janice before taking steps to escalate the dispute.
The video has drawn attention to what employees can do when they feel harassed, and what happens when they report it.
The EEOC on Retaliation
The federal agency charged with enforcing anti-discrimination laws in the workplace says its rules against retaliation generally protect employees who act in a certain way. Employees may report or oppose discrimination or harassment that falls under federal equal employment opportunity laws, or participate in an investigation even when the company objects. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, or EEOC, makes this point in describing its federal anti-retaliation protections.
Just because someone files an HR complaint does not protect them from being disciplined or dismissed. The EEOC states that employers may still discipline or dismiss workers for legitimate, non-discriminatory reasons, including substandard performance or misconduct. What determines whether an action counts as unlawful retaliation is whether the action is connected to protected activity.
What the Law Actually Says
Federal anti-discrimination laws typically require harassment to be tied to a protected characteristic or a protected activity, and to meet the relevant legal standard. Minor, one-off incidents generally do not violate federal harassment law.
Not all rude or inappropriate workplace behavior crosses the line into illegal harassment.
A Complicated Legal Picture
What the video describes may be oversimplified. The EEOC’s guidance covers only harassment based on protected characteristics or protected activity, and it does not apply to isolated incidents.
| Step | Action | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Harassment | The employee feels called stupid | Not specified in the video |
| Complaint | The employee reports Janice to HR | Not specified in the video |
| Discovery | Janice learns of the complaint | Not specified in the video |
| Confrontation | Janice tells the employee she will be fired | Not specified in the video |
| Pushback | The employee says she can report the dismissal to HR | Not specified in the video |
The video does not lay out a timeline for these events. It presents the confrontation and the employee’s reaction, yet it fails to offer details about when Janice found out about the complaint or when she made her threat.
“My manager found out I reported her to HR for calling me stupid.”
The video’s recording conveys that straightforward message, nothing more than a plain account of what took place, without passing any judgment on the matter.
What the Employee Can Do Next
The employee has choices if Janice holds her position. She has already said she can consult an employment attorney.
Janice’s response to the complaint has drawn attention to the tension between managers and employees over workplace complaints. The employee has reported Janice to HR, and she has pushed back against Janice’s threat of dismissal, which now stands as the consequence of her complaint.
The situation has sparked a discussion about how far workplace discipline can go. The footage has drawn attention to the disagreement between managers and workers over complaints made at work. The employee is now facing the results of her complaint.
A manager has informed her she faces termination for bringing forward a complaint, and for the moment, that is exactly where the employee stands.
The situation of the EEOC’s guidance is clear about retaliation protections, but the law is more complicated than the video implies. The employee’s case hinges on whether the dismissal stems from her protected activity, reporting harassment, and whether retaliation can be established.
Source material: “This Manager Called an Employee ‘Stupid.’ When the Employee Reported It to HR, She Tried to Fire Her,” The Daily Dot.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.