Fifteen-year-old Christian Williams died after a call to 911 about a diabetic teen boy in distress. The caller said he was pretending to be dead for attention. Christian was in a residential treatment facility for seven young men in foster care in Mesa, Arizona. He had been in and out of the hospital for one month due to complications from his Type 1 diabetes.
A staffer at the foster care home told officers she had never dealt with a diabetic before and didn’t know anything about diabetes. Paramedics attempted to revive Christian with CPR. Christian’s death is one case. The broader problem is systemic, and it affects far more children than one boy in one home.
Foster Care’s Hidden Disability Problem
An NPR investigation found that children with disabilities make up the largest group entering foster care. They also suffer the worst outcomes, staying trapped in the system longer and experiencing lifelong harm. Bobbi Andrew-Green, an Alaska foster parent to children with complex medical needs, said navigating child welfare, mental health, Medicaid, special education, home nursing, and other systems is extremely complex.
Up to 80% of children in foster care enter with a significant mental health need, according to a report from the American Academy of Pediatrics citing multiple research studies. That figure points to a population already struggling before it enters the system.
Nancy Thaler, who leads a federally-funded program on children with complex behavioral health conditions, said these children are the ones everyone gives up on because they have disabilities. She said these kids are hard to understand and take sophistication to treat. They may be diagnosed with mental health issues, trauma, brain injuries, Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorders, intellectual disabilities, and autism.
Where These Children Come From
Thaler said these children often lived in state institutions years ago. They end up in child welfare in large numbers in therapeutic group homes and residential treatment centers because of behaviors that are off-putting or scary. Those behaviors include hurting others, hurting themselves, and damaging property.
These children are not a new problem. The current system has moved them from one setting to another.
The Treatment Problem
Child welfare programs largely depend on 100-year-old therapy models that don’t work with these disabled children, Thaler said. Instead, that treatment often makes their behaviors worse. The system is not just failing these kids. It is actively making their problems worse.
Federal data on foster care demographics is extensive. Black children make up 24% of the foster care population, according to AFCARS, the government’s mandated data collection system. Hispanic children represent 21%. One research study shows 53% of Black children in America will be the subject of a child protective services investigation by age 18.
The Data Gap
NPR obtained data from AFCARS and analyzed federal data on 505,591 children in foster care in 2025. Only 60% were marked as disabled or not disabled. Of the unmarked group, almost half have a disability. There is no statistically valid count of kids labeled “emotionally disturbed,” the one category of foster youth with mental health conditions.
Researchers use a broad range of 25 to 80% to estimate children and youth in foster care with disabilities. The lower percentage reflects federal foster care data counting, while the higher reflects research suggesting the vast majority have mental health issues. Missing numbers mean there’s no clarity on how many disabled children are in foster care.
What Works and What Doesn’t
Thaler said these kids can recover and be very successful. The problem is not the children. The problem is the system. A system that relies on century-old therapy models is not fit for children with complex behavioral health conditions.
Bobbi Andrew-Green’s experience in Alaska points to a better path. Navigating multiple systems is difficult, but it is possible. The complexity is real, but the failure is not inevitable.
The Case for Reform
Christian Williams’ death is a tragedy. It is also a symptom of a larger failure. The foster care system is not equipped to serve children with complex medical needs, mental health issues, or behavioral challenges.
The system treats their behaviors as problems to be managed rather than symptoms of underlying trauma, disability, or neglect. The result is a cycle of institutionalization, repeated placement, and lifelong harm.
The only relevant position is the one that serves the children. The system should be redesigned around their needs, not around the convenience of bureaucrats or the comfort of politicians.
Where the paper stands
The paper backs smaller government and more local control over foster care, and is against agencies writing their own authority to run residential facilities for children. In this case, the story shows a system built around old therapy models that fail children with complex behavioral health needs, and data kept without clear counts of how many of them are in care. The death of Christian Williams is one case, but the problem is systemic, affecting far more children than one boy in one home.
The paper’s position against centralized power applies directly here: the foster care system operates as a vast, opaque bureaucracy that treats children’s behaviors as problems to be managed rather than symptoms of underlying trauma, disability, or neglect. When the government runs residential facilities for children, it gathers power over their lives, and the story shows that power has failed to protect them. The system relies on century-old therapy models that do not work for these children, and Thaler’s account of children being given up on because they have disabilities shows the human cost of that failure.
The reader should watch for the gap between official data and the reality of children’s lives. Federal data analysis shows that up to 80% of children in foster care enter with significant mental health needs, yet only 60% of the roughly half-million children in care in 2025 were even marked as disabled or not disabled. The paper supports a system redesigned around children’s needs, not around the convenience of bureaucrats or the comfort of politicians. The story’s own reporting points to a better path in Bobbi Andrew-Green’s experience in Alaska, where navigating multiple systems is difficult but possible. The tragedy of Christian Williams demands that the system be fixed, and the paper supports the push to do so.
Key Facts
- Christian Williams was 15 years old and died in a residential treatment facility in Mesa, Arizona
- Up to 80% of children in foster care enter with a significant mental health need, per the American Academy of Pediatrics
- Black children make up 24% of the foster care population (35% including biracial children per Child Trends)
- Hispanic children represent 21%
- 53% of Black children in America will be the subject of a child protective services investigation by age 18
- NPR’s analysis of federal data on 505,591 children in foster care in 2025 found only 60% were marked as disabled or not disabled
- Of the unmarked group, almost half have a disability
- Researchers estimate 25 to 80% of children and youth in foster care have disabilities
Christian’s death is a tragedy. But it is also a warning. The foster care system is failing children with disabilities. It is time to fix it.
Source material: “Foster care often fails kids with disabilities. Consider these cases,” NPR.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.